Loading...
05/07/2019 06C 1st Quarter 2019 Claim Report to\'4\lyy tbxk ik 1 PPP +� PPP d g. P A P p P 1 PPi ittYlltYlt.\ta. BUSINESS OF THE CITY COUNCIL YAKIMA, WASHINGTON AGENDA STATEMENT Item No. 6.C. For Meeting of: May 7, 2019 ITEM TITLE: Resolution accepting and approving 1st Quarter 2019 Claim Report SUBMITTED BY: Helen Harvey, Senior Assistant City Attorney Steve Groom, Director of Finance & Budget SUMMARY EXPLANATION: The purpose of this report is to provide information on claims that were closed during the 1st Quarter 2019. All claims listed in this report were resolved and settled pursuant to the City Council's prior annual Resolution authorizing the City Manager to settle claims against or by the City in an amount of $50,000 or less, and Resolution No. R-2018-125 was adopted on November 6, 2018. All payment amounts listed on the CIAW report show the amount paid by the City of Yakima toward the settlement within the City's $100,000 insurance deductible. The City Council previously authorized settlement on one closed claim in the report by prior Resolution. In the case of Lorena Arias, Special Administrator for the Estate of Rocendo Arias v. Casey Gillette, Yakima Police Chief Dominic Rizzi, City of Yakima Police Department, and the City of Yakima, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Washington Case No. CV-16- 3213-SAB, the City Council adopted Resolution No. R-2018-003 on January 2, 2018, which authorized settlement of the case for$500,000, which entire amount was paid by CIAW and reinsurer Munich Reinsurance to settle all claims in the lawsuit that was filed November 22, 2016. The City paid no money toward the settlement since it had reached its deductible of$100,000. The report includes information for the first quarter 2019: (1) CIAW claim summary by type of claim; (2) CIAW claim summary by department; (3) CIAW closed claims for the 1st Quarter 2019; and (4)WSTI P closed claims for the 1st Quarter 2019. Adopting the attached claims resolution affirms and ratifies the payments made by the City of Yakima on claims closed during the 1st Quarter of 2019 as listed in the reports. ITEM BUDGETED: Yes STRATEGIC PRIORITY: Public Trust and Accountability 2 APPROVED FOR City Manager SUBMITTAL: STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt resolution BOARD/COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: ATTACHMENTS: Description Upload Date Type D Resolution 4/2512019 Resolution D 1st Quarter 2019 Closed Cairns 412612019 Backup Material 3 RESOLUTION NO. R-2019- A RESOLUTION accepting and approving the 1st Quarter 2019 Claim Report for the City of Yakima. WHEREAS, the City of Yakima previously was self insured as to most claims; and WHEREAS, the City of Yakima is currently a member of the Cities Insurance Association of Washington ("CIAW') for most claims, and joined CIAW effective December 14, 2005, with a $99,000 deductible for insurance policies from September 1, 2010 to September 1, 2012, and a $100,000 deductible on policies from September 1, 2012 to the present; and WHEREAS, the Transit Division is in the Washington State Transit Insurance Pool ("WSTIP") for Transit claims, effective September 1, 2005, with liability coverage which is not subject to a deductible amount; and WHEREAS, pursuant to an annual Resolution that has been adopted by the City Council, the City Manager is authorized to settle claims against or by the City in an amount of$50,000 or less; and WHEREAS, the attached CIAW Claim Report contains information on and the disposition of the various claims submitted to the City of Yakima with the amount on the CIAW report that was paid by the City of Yakima toward the settlement which was within the City's $100,000 insurance deductible, and does not include the insurance company's contribution to the settlement, if any; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF YAKIMA: The attached 1st Quarter 2019 Claim Report, together with payments and disbursements listed therein, is hereby accepted, approved, and ratified. ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this 7th day of May, 2019. ATTEST: Kathy Coffey, Mayor Sonya Clear Tee, City Clerk 4 CITY F YAKIMA 1st I uarter Claim Re rt 2019 5 ClAW CLAIMS SUM A ' Y Y TYPE OF CLAIM 01/01/2019 T 13/31/211 ' 6 City of Yakima CIAW Closed Claims Summary by Type of Claim First Quarter 2019 January 1, 2018 through March 31, 2019 Auto Bodily Injury(ABI) Total Number of Claims: 1 Total Dollars Paid: $7,500.00 Automobile Liability- Property Damage (ALPD) Total Number of Claims: 1 Total Dollars Paid: $250.00 Employment Practices Liability (EPL) Total Number of Claims 0 Total Dollars Paid: $0.00 General Liability- Bodily Injury(GLBI) Total Number of Claims: 2 Total Dollars Paid: $45,000.00 General Liability- Property Damage (GLPD) Total Number of Claims: 8 Total Dollars Paid: $2,668.10 Law Enforcement (LE) Total Number of Claims: 4 Total Dollars Paid: $60.00 Wrongful Acts (WA) Total Number of Claims: 0 Total Dollars Paid: $0.00 TOTAL NUMBER OF CLAIMS: 16 TOTAL DOLLARS PAID: $55,478.10 6 City of Yakima CIAW Closed Claims Summary by Type of Claim First Quarter 2019 January 1, 2018 through March 31, 2019 Auto Bodily Injury(ABI) Total Number of Claims: 1 Total Dollars Paid: $7,500.00 Automobile Liability- Property Damage (ALPD) Total Number of Claims: 1 Total Dollars Paid: $250.00 Employment Practices Liability (EPL) Total Number of Claims 0 Total Dollars Paid: $0.00 General Liability- Bodily Injury(GLBI) Total Number of Claims: 2 Total Dollars Paid: $45,000.00 General Liability- Property Damage (GLPD) Total Number of Claims: 8 Total Dollars Paid: $2,668.10 Law Enforcement (LE) Total Number of Claims: 4 Total Dollars Paid: $60.00 Wrongful Acts (WA) Total Number of Claims: 0 Total Dollars Paid: $0.00 TOTAL NUMBER OF CLAIMS: 16 TOTAL DOLLARS PAID: $55,478.10 7 CI A W CLAIMS SUMM A ' Y IYDEIA ' TMENT 11/ 11/2019 T 03/31/211 ' 8 City of Yakima CIAW Closed Claims Summary by Department First Quarter 2019 January 1, 2019 through March 31,2019 Department/Division Closed Total Paid Animal Control Division 0 $0.00 Codes Division 0 $0.00 Community Development Department 0 $0.00 Engineering Division 0 $0.00 Finance Department 0 $0.00 Fire Department 0 $0.00 Other 0 $0.00 Parks and Recreation Division 1 $0.00 Planning Division 0 $0.00 Police Department 5 $7,560.00 Public Works Department 0 $0.00 Refuse Division 0 $0.00 Streets Division 6 $45,939.17 Wastewater Division 2 $1,968.93 Water/Irrigation Division 1 $10.00 Utility Services Division 1 $0.00 TOTAL: 16 $55,478.10 9 ClAW CL SE 1 CL A IMS 11/01/2019 T II 03/31/211 ' '' '''' AW City of Yakima Closed Loss Run 1/1/2019 to 3/31/2019 as of 4/1/2019 Cl. otiz7m,A.,ortSVTVYt'tlrt"1"-SV"1;' \,�:a``.�i,```1„`.,i`,�i;�'�.'��'';`�\,<`.��.,, �3.,�,�..,� ,, 'zc�. `3'�♦ ','g,`''�`„§4,,, ����z'"`�.. ""y., `S � i ,"♦ "�`.`'2� i' '`�y �,;..' ^a1zj,'�,�``Haattli v��`� ♦ 'g� py �, ♦;`\`. •♦*,\�,,'., § \.`ak`:n �',.�^'`"'•:�" \\ ,;'Y�, "�', 'asi:3♦ ,1 r', ' `i5 Pti 4 i1`♦ '1�,''�"s.;Z,;�z�,,,�:;.��'t `4«�,,.. ♦\�,,: �<.k�a.a\,.,:'..+1..,e". ' a a 1 4,ti\'.ie '0.� �•��k, � t`,<,.,�., •`it` �* ",. �v \..,.�y „♦' :a:, :a„`Z• ``��,�\..•�;':+'.��'� •i�^��^`..�v,�°',o-\. \?,�,.t, .d "�. \ '�` `�,,. �' t }+.♦� �'^:=•Sv,`, r`.`:'za, ,'+, "" .4 �'.,a .,,, �a„''',+'���`�.. $$,,,,.�',v�',`.: .,\�♦„.C ' 1'�.>1,`r„.:�. :`� ��`..r. .\.'S .t,`�a,.4'§. \z,, ♦' \ "`tea \',° tea•♦,. s , \. ` `.' �.^» x,.ao �.'�<:♦e� ,WR.♦ ♦� a �\,,4 ', �,;�', ,. •„1 � ;•. ,♦ ��, �` iivomot a„Zvi♦•m, M �1,, ♦ 00 � <�> ♦.,.a�.y 4�+"ice.. ,���1,�',t�.�♦.,.v xx<,� ";"���� i \ k. �`:�` ""`.• :. v�1' JJ�M` Zit*I .+ Oda •� < v �.`�, v ♦. ^Sti's^,tJ�<, '`��'i`�s��^�� <;`041 ��4�`S'♦' �`+V� =4� "\♦ s,.� �,1��':,,v, ` �• '1'�v.:"n,`4j,�' „+ , 3 Yakima Parks&Recrea ion LCYPark2017046902 12/26/2017 12/22/2017 12/18/2017 GLBI Rousculp,Joshua Claimant slipped and fell C 3/25/2019 Boruff $0.00 Division on court • 1 Sum: $0.00 RgligsgMETRWMPRINTIUMISTIMMITMInVITIMP,,,,iira!'a1::7e?�y'vuz fi.,�',,,,,,x a <,,5'ai`:�; `♦,��,=``ti. " e,1 ,'ai„�:` esat ''.'77,71151,1::RIERMelfapi ,`'v`` 4':`c`.< fi. '"`<L �`h: a``"'ik•,y'` Y, ` 'a.`.. S` 'r. ro w ','aStii'3'..`♦ r'•:, ',a., ,�`&.\. e`3,w aE., c;;,�, :���ti r`•tia:�. ";�'4,.'._�,�.�..,'@.�,, w•'a♦,;\, ^" �,,`\ a.',�;"�Jtie3.:.„eti > � 'z rz ,<,:,,ai'i ii`;>„ \ . :`.,:Win`,,;\ ti\• "`,','♦,. a, ♦ T, ` \,- � �• :<•., eaa, �%�Tk�., :. c s ;F, �`�.t;\,`'. �¢ .a,�.,^fib; ,e: .•1 �` ;`. �,. \` °m ��,. `�., A ^�`�.tea T .>iU\"���.aa��wk��k��k��� i�.` ";.vv,'4�,♦.S'd� '`',a"`v':Y"u♦,• t�a,Y::;�i'. Yakima Police Department LCYPD2014040065 5/1/2014 5/1/2014 1/4/2014 LE Estate of Rocendo Claimant shot by insured C 3/25/2019 Fletcher $0.00 Arias LCYPD2015045763B 5/16/2017 5/15/2017 11/30/2015 ABI Thielen,Skyler Insured vehicle hit C 1/29/2019 Schafer $7,500.00 claimants vehicle LCYPD2016045806 5/19/2017 5/19/2017 9/1/2016 LE Dulaney,Connie Discrimination issue C 1/22/2019 Schafer $0.00 LCYPD2018048567 11/2/2018 11/1/2018 3/9/2018 LE Nevarez,Connie Claimant taken against her will C 1/28/2019 Schafer $0.00 LCYPD2019048952 1/16/2019 1/2/2019 1/2/2019 LE Vanzant,Melinda Claimant's property lost C 3/25/2019 McWilliams $60.00 5 Sum: $7,560.00 ,yz 1 "�,�����,'"'r,, '�� Z-.. �i ��'� a: ,2. ,�,, y`� .\- :� '",ti. ,\.,,�'ti' O,,1V01AEyR7: I NF "�,.,. "�_� �a z..a�., .w♦ '"�1n:'� ♦ .'`„T,.`'� +. 5�, a ^, "'`v,.•a.,;♦�"4, k��. v".','^.,.\ `>,,m' "'.�`".v' ''♦ .`\ ♦ \ \ ♦ VtitP A:tOtI j,M;I, e,liif,C',ilatittttfoaPtilt,a,t,il s,0,,:t Ail l , ` .x.'\ a, ,pia:." "�i, a 'y''a ``., 3`;`a ♦a� ♦. ,zI0r714t1'e4"t`a0fistAgxvW iI;tt:IE''li,s,,,g,,t,,Wa,,t,l,ri3Oi,,tll,,AietNeli T �„ =.fix. ,.'.x`„ ♦ `� '\ •,a `�L' e,.=: "��:`\'-' ,'m. ,\. ' ,fix `a. y�� � �.,,,., a.\ '�-�' c@, ,i ,�.4�. 'fir `�, 2„.\.':.�. ":,. �'~.,haw"• .',r. `'♦ � > .,�.,• +fi< � a� ,y' ;♦ � � ♦.\ �, .`a may, u; `,=`c. C. ,t'`r �,' ,� w t. 3i. ? �` va A,,,.:, '>�;Vi, �',>\ '�: ,;\ .``,, ,b. ".wa y� d @ i Wit, ,'. •:z,. >, a '•mom,♦ `,` v,+ . � �... �� ,a xn, .ice ,':a, ;,�` t G T .`'1+, w,.a ti♦. ♦` \ off � l. `r.. ```�\:° ��. "', ♦ '� ?" ;���,"�"'.0 aaa'T2:Yv ���`.,�wav:..«. �"`w>a��S �,a a>�aa�.. r�,.o�w tiaaia�i„s~'i� a���� 'fi' Yakima Streets Division LCYStree2015041726A 4/13/2015 4/13/2015 2/5/2015 GLBI Simpson,Shirlene Claimant alleged vehicle C 1/3/2019 Schafer $45,000.00 struck storm drain LCYStree2015041726B 4/13/2015 2/5/2015 2/5/2015 GLPD Simpson,Shirlene Claimant alleged vehicle C 1/3/2019 Schafer $0.00 struck storm drain LCYStree2016048908 1/9/2019 1/9/2019 8/1/2016 GLPD Neveu,Cheri Water damage C 2/26/2019 Whetstone $0.00 LCYStree2018048839 12/26/2018 12/21/2018 11/28/2018 GLPD Meadowbrook Tree branch fell on roof C 2/12/2019 Whetstone $0.00 Estates LCYStree2018048861 1/2/2019 1/2/2019 12/4/2018 GLPD Silvernail,Ka hleen Claimant hit a pothole C 2/7/2019 Owens $825.56 LCYStree2019049178 2/20/2019 2/20/2019 2/14/2019 GLPD Flores,Juan Claimant hit pothole C 3/11/2019 Owens $113.61 6 Sum: $45,939.17 8 w\ Atomettizio \t`t, !♦ \ t \tom \t \ v Yakima Wastewater Division LCYWaste2018048085 5/15/2018 5/15/2018 5/15/2018 ALPD Jang,Eun Seog Ibuildinnsuredg hit claimant's C 2/28/2019 Owens $250.00 LCYWaste2019048961 1/18/2019 1/17/2019 1/9/2019 GLPD Gazca,Roberto Sewer backup C 3/26/2019 Whetstone $1,718.93 2 Sum: $1,968.93 7r7K'Fr7:FTlr7777,rpl'17FF7rEz7Zriln:F1r,”F.' -^,��\�.;.`',',. ,`x�., <� yt ♦;� .\`' \:"v,' 't1, :•`..:,\ � of y *gat,. $� ,\y, `,�����`•�1..`ti,` ,h,"-,'h.'h�^�, `y, \ .�+ `A`. '. .Z y , .V',A,�,x,^ ..u4".i`�,-.\.''t`y.. .ty �.ti +,�,.,\, 5� •.'„>.� +.� '�. �. \t \^fig•\> \, 5.`%;;.�..c „a `^. t n� :t a.+.\-.tea, .^t�°v. \.. �,'„ ,:v,.^ \i �..�tv.,\,. �,^,\`' ,a, ,.`, �4* �� !:`.` \> < ,..a ..�`\.,. ."'�,�. '.`n..ti a\S,s hv-.'i.>.. ,w +a <�... \f �'�'� `l��-'\,...\ � 4 � \ a< a `E,>a `,Si ``A ' H.��\.a".:\i. ..L 'Y\•vas c\ > ^�Os� �a tit, �. i Yakima Water&Irrigation LCYWater2018048615 11/9/2018 8/9/2018 8/9/2018 GLPD Harmia,Julie Water damage C 2/21/2019 Whetstone $0.00 Division LCYWater2019048921 1/11/2019 1/11/2019 1/10/2019 GLPD Aslan,Leticia Dirty water splashed car C 2/20/2019 McWilliams $10.00 2 1 Sum: $10.00 16 Grand Total: $55,478.10 12 WSTIP CLOSED CLAIMS O1/01/2019 TO 03/31/211 ' Yakima Transit Closed Claims — 01/01/2019 — 03/31/2019 Claim/Event Date of Total Paid Number Event Date Claim Claimant Dept. Location Type Status Description Date Closed to Claimant Outcome by WSTIP Vehicle damage. Vehicle 19-017050 01/09/2019 01/11/2019 Raul Blanco 28FR S.4th Ave. and Walnut ALPD C collision between bus and 03/11/2019 $13,887.46 Settled claimant's truck. Vehicle damage.Vehicle 19-017050-2 01/09/2019 01/15/2019 Martin Lovins 28FR S.4th Ave. and Walnut ALPD C collision,between bus and 03/11/2019 $1,626.00 Settled claimants truck causing truck to hit parked vehicle. 18-017032-1 12/27/2018 01/17/2019 Mohammad 28PT 704 N. 5th Ave ALPD C Vehicle damage. Paratransit 02/27/2019 $2,701.01 Settled Musbeh driver hit parked vehicle. The City of Yakima WSTIP Transit Insurance has a$0 deductible on its WSTIP insurance,so the amounts paid on the Transit Closed Claims report were paid by WSTIP, not the City. Yakima Paratransit claims (with "PT" in Dept. column) after January 1, 2012, involve the current contractor for ADA paratransit services, Medstar, LLC. Prior to January 1, 2012, the contractor for paratransit service was A-1 Tri-City Taxi, Inc. co