HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-2006-069 1st Quarter Claims ReportRESOLUTION NO. R-2006- 69
A RESOLUTION accepting and approving the 1st Quarter 2006 Claim Report for the
City of Yakima.
WHEREAS, the City of Yakima has been self insured as to most claims; and
WHEREAS, the Transit Division is in the Washington State Transit Insurance Pool
("WSTIP") for Transit claims, effective September 1, 2005, with a $5,000 deductible; and
WHEREAS, the City of Yakima is in the Cities Insurance Association of
Washington ("CIAW") for other claims, effective December 14, 2005, with a $100,000
deductible; and
WHEREAS, the attached Claim Report contains information on the various claims
submitted to the City of Yakima along with the disposition; now, therefore,
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF YAKIMA:
The attached and incorporated 1st Quarter 2006 Claim Report, together with all
payments and disbursements listed therein, is hereby accepted, approved, affirmed, and
ratified.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this 2nd day of May, 2006.
ATTEST:
Kms-.-- ,,d ie--0-44-
City Clerk
avid dler, Mayor
CSordia'
CITY OF YAKIMA
1st Quarter Claim
Report - 2006
Prepared by:
Joel Pearson, Senior Vice President
Deb Krautwurm, Senior Vice President
CITY OF YAKIMA
CLAIM REPORT INDEX
1. 16 YEAR SUMMARY
PAID CLAIM SUMMARY BASED ON YEAR OF OCCURRENCE
2. 2006 TYPE OF LOSS BREAKDOWN
CLAIMS THAT OCCURRED AND WERE PAID IN 2006
3 2006 DEPARTMENTAL SUMMARY
CLAIMS THAT OCCURRED AND WERE PAID IN 2006
4. 2006 CLAIMS BY DEPARTMENT (DETAILED LISTING)
CLAIMS THAT OCCURRED AND WERE PAID IN 2006
5 DETAILED LISTING OF OPENED & CLOSED CLAIMS 2006
ALL CLAIMS OPENED OR CLOSED IN 2006
6. CLOSED CLAIMS 01/01/2006 TO 03/31/2006
ALL CLAIMS CLOSED DURING 2006
16 YEAR SUMMARY
CITY OF YAKIMA
16 YEAR CLAIM SUMMARY
FOR THE PERIOD OF 01/01/2006 TO 03/31/2006
Total number of claims are based on the year in which they occurred, not the year they were reported.
NUMBER OF CLAIMS
1991 1992 1993 1994
A Total Occurrences 109 112 118 136
B Open Claims 0 0 0 0
C Closed - No Payment 47 43 57 64
D Closed - With Payment 62 69 61 72
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims $86,608.27 $246,315.63 $256,527.50 $196,576.63
NUMBER OF CLAIMS
1995 1996 1997 1998
A Total Occurrences 120 166 169 155
B Open Claims 1 0 1 1
C Closed - No Payment 49 45 44 55
D Closed - With Payment 70 121 124 99
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims $214,359.92 $169,571.45 $317,141.63 $7,238,545.30 (1)
NUMBER OF CLAIMS
CITY OF YAKIMA
16 YEAR CLAIM SUMMARY
PAGE 2
1999 2000 2001 2002
A Total Occurrences 114 97 126 164
B Open Claims 0 3 0 8
C Closed - No Payment 41 33 51 54
D Closed - With Payment 73 61 75 102
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims $245,114.49 $162,058.50 $267,122.83 $466,632.49
NUMBER OF CLAIMS
2003 2004 2005 2006
A Total Occurrences 139 136 128 19
B Open Claims 5 12 35 16
C Closed - No Payment 34 38 16 1
D Closed - With Payment 100 86 77 2
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims
$187,393.37 $243,473.41 $156,061.54 $60,111.90
Compiled on 04/13/2006 from the records of Zaremba Claims Service, Inc.
Paid Claims
500,000.00
450, 000.00
400,000.00
350,000.00
300,000.00
250,000.00
200,000.00
150, 000.00
100, 000.00
50, 000.00
0.00
CITY OF YAKIMA
Paid Claims
II Total Paid
n
1991 1992
1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998(1) 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
(1) The claim summary for the year 1998 includes the case of Murphy, et al. v. City of Yakima, et al., Yakima County Superior Court Cause No. 99-2-00611-8, which was a
class action case alleging damages due to wastewater odors with approximately 3,500 residents in the defined class area. The initial damage claims were filed on
May 14, 1998; for the purpose of this claim summary only, an occurrence date was assigned of May 14, 1998. Plaintiffs alleged a continuing occurrence. In 2003,
the case settled for $7,000,000.
2006 TYPE OF LOSS
BREAKDOWN
CITY OF YAKIMA
SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS
CLAIMS THAT HAVE BEEN PAID AND OCCURRED
DURING THE PERIOD FROM 01/01/2006 TO 03/31/2006
TYPE OF CLAIM
OPEN CLOSED
PAID TO DATE
Automobile Liability 5 1 13,831.98
Errors & Omissions 4 0 533.25
General Liability 7 2 45,746.67
TOTALS ALL DEPARTMENTS 16 3
Compiled on 04/13/2006 from the records of Zaremba Claims Service, Inc.
$60,111.90
CITY OF YAKIMA
SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS
BASED ON PAID AMOUNT
0 Automobile Liability
■ Errors & Omissions
■ General Liability
2006 DEPARTMENTAL
SUMMARY
CITY OF YAKIMA
DEPARTMENTAL THIRD PARTY LIABILITY CLAIMS SUMMARY
CLAIMS THAT HAVE BEEN PAID AND OCCURRED
DURING THE PERIOD FROM 01/01/2006 TO 03/31/2006
TYPE OF CLAIM
OPEN CLOSED
TOTAL PAID
General Administration 0 0
Parks and Recreation 1 0
Public Works 0 0
Refuse 0 1
Water 3 0
Sewer 3 0
Police 6 1
Streets 1 1
Fire 0 0
Transit 1 0
Engineering 0 0
Animal Control 0 0
Other - Unallocated 0 0
Community and Economic 1 0
0.00
0.00
0.00
272.98
533.25
44,269.12
13,559.00
1,477.55
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
TOTALS ALL DEPARTMENTS 16
Compiled on 04/13/2006 from the records of Zaremba Claims Service, Inc.
3
$ 60,111.90
Departmental Third Party Liability Claims for 2006
Based on Paid Amount
m,
• General Administration
• Parks and Recreation
❑ Public Works
❑ Refuse
❑ Water
❑ Sewer
Police
• Streets
OFire
❑ Transit
la Engineering
■ Animal Control
■ Other - Unallocated
■ Community and Economic
2006 CLAIMS BY DEPARTMENT
(Detailed Listing)
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Parks and Recreation
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
General Liability
CTY26021 QWEST AREA CLAIMS OFFICE
2/13/2006 DAMAGE TO CABLE WITH HACKSAW
WHILE CITY EMPLOYEE WAS
LANDSCAPING
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
40TH AND ARLINGTON
OPEN $0.00
Total Paid for General Liability $0.00
Total Paid All Claims $0 00
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Refuse
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Automobile Property
CTY26012 DUNKEL, DAMON 1010 SOUTH 36TH AVENUE CLOSED $272.98
1/23/2006 REFUSE TRUCK HIT GARAGE AND
MAILBOX
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Total Paid for Automobile Property
Total Paid All Claims
Page 1
$272.98
$272.98
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Water
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Errors and Omissions
CTY26010 DECKARD, PATRICIA AND MICHAEL 620 N 5TH AVE OPEN $533.25
1/6/2006 SEWER SIDE LINE BREAKAGE
CAUSED BY IRRIGATION CREW
WORK
Total Paid for Errors and Omissions $533.25
General Liability
CTY26019 ANGUTANO, MARIA 1010 PITCHER STREET OPEN $0.00
1/25/2006 BROKEN PIPE -WATER IN BASEMENT
CTY26029 KILBURY, BLAKE 1015 SUMMITVIEW OPEN $0.00
2/13/2006 WATER DAMAGE TO INTERIOR OF
HOME ON 1ST AND 2ND FLOOR
AFTER WATER CREW USED WATER
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Total Paid for General Liability
Total Paid All Claims
Page 1
$0.00
$533.25
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Sewers
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
General Liability
CTY26002 HUWE, PAT 6915 MIDVALE ROAD IN YAKIMA OPEN $6,153.32
1/1/2006 SEWER BACKUP
CTY26009 TORRES, NORMA 1020 S 9TH AVENUE OPEN $0.00
1/17/2006 SEWER BACKUP
CTY26001 GARCIA, FERNANDO 6915 MIDVALE BLVD OPEN $38,115.80
1/1/2006 SEWER BACKUP
Total Paid for General Liability $44,269.12
Total Paid All Claims $44,269.12
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Police
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator
Status
Paid
ToDate
Automobile Property
CTY26005
1/4/2006
CTY26007
1/9/2006
Bodily Injury
CTY26017
2/3/2006
CTY26018
2/3/2006
ATKINS, BRENT
CLAIMANT REARENDED BY POLICE
VEHICLE
LOPEZ, ADAM AND TANIA
YPD OFFICER REARENDED PARKED
VEHICLE
Liability
MERKT, JERRIANN
POLICE VEHICLE COLLIDED WITH
CLAIMANT VEHICLE
STONE, JEANNA
POLICE VEHICLE COLLIDED WITH
CLAIMANT VEHICLE
Errors and Omissions
CTY26014
1/20/2006
CTY26026
1/10/2006
200 S 1ST STREET IN SELAH
Total Paid for Automobile Property
3RD AND E MAPLE STREET
MAPLE STREET & 3RD STREET
Total Paid for Bodily Inju►y Liability
RIDDLE, DAN AND SHERRI
DAMAGE TO FENCE BY PERSON
ELUDING POLICE
IN TOWN CAR SALES, INC
CLAIMANT ALLEGES THAT A
VEHICLE WAS STOLEN FROM A CAR
SALES LOT ON SOUTH 1ST STREET
AND WHEN YPD OFFICERS LOCATED
VEHICLE THEY FAILED TO
APPREHEND SUSPECT ALLOWING
THE SUSPECT TO ATTEMPT TO
ELUDE POLICE IN A CHASE THAT
ENDED WHEN THE STOLEN VEHICLE
COLLIDED W/ A CONCRETE BRIDGE
SUPPORT AT INTERSECTION OF 1-82
AND N 1ST STREET.
607 N 5TH AVENUE
YAKIMA
Total Paid for Errors and Omissions
OPEN
OPEN
OPEN
OPEN
OPEN
OPEN
General Liability
CTY26016 FOWLER, RITCHIE 23001 S. 84TH STREET, KENT, W CLOSED
1/19/2006 VEHICLE VANDALISM AND THEFT OF
ITEMS FROM PRIVATE CAR USED BY
YPD OFFICER TO ATTEND TRAINING
Page 1
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$13,559.00
$0 00
$13,559.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Police
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Total Paid for General Liability $0.00
Total Paid All Claims $13,559.00
Page 2
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Streets
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
General Liability
CTY26008 GARDNER, CHRISTOPHER
1/11/2006 VEHICLE AND TRAILER HIT
POTHOLE, MOTORCYCLE FELL OFF
TRAILER.
CTY26027 WILLIAMS, WILLIE R
3/22/2006 VEHICLE DAMAGE CAUSED BY
RAILROAD TRACKS
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
40TH AND ENGLEWOOD
H & 1ST STREET
CLOSED $1,477.55
OPEN $0.00
Total Paid for General Liability $1,477.55
Total Paid All Claims $1,477.55
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Transit
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Bodily Injury Liability
CTY26025 STRAHSBURG, ALBERT WAYNE AND 48TH AND NOB HILL OPEN $0.00
SUSAN
3/14/2006 ALLEGES BODILY INJURY AND
BROKEN WATCH BAND WHEN
TRANSIT BUS BRAKED
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Total Paid for Bodily Injury Liability $0 00
Total Paid All Claims $0 00
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Finance
For the period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Errors and Omissions
CTY26028 DILLS, FRED AND PATRICIA
3/16/2006 ALLEGE WATER UTILITY SERVICE TO
RENTAL PROPERTY WAS NOT SHUT
OFF AS REQUESTED, RESULTING IN
BROKEN WATER PIPE AND WATER
DAMAGE TO BUILDING
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
313 S 4TH STREET
OPEN $0 00
Total Paid for Errors and Omissions $0.00
Total Paid All Claims $0.00
Page 1
OPENED OR CLOSED CLAIMS
FROM 01/01/2006 TO 03/31/2006
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
File /
Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Paid
Type Type ToDate Closed
CTY26001 GARCIA, FERNANDO GL 0 $38,115.80
1/1/2006 SEWER BACKUP
CTY26002 H U W E, PAT GL 0 $6,153.32
1/1/2006 SEWER BACKUP
CTY26003 PEARCEY, IRENE GL 0 $613.98
12/25/2005 CLAIMANT VEHICLE DAMAGE FROM POTHOLE
CTY26005 ATKINS, BRENT AP 0 $0.00
1/4/2006 CLAIMANT REARENDED BY POLICE VEHICLE
CTY26006 LEMON, DOUG E0 0 $0.00
4/28/2005 CLAIMANT ALLEGES HE SHOULD NOT HAVE TO INSTALL A
SEWER LINE TO HIS PROPERTY AT 405 POPLAR AND
ALLEGES LOST INCOME ON RENTAL PROPERTIES,
MISCONDUCT, THEFT AND DAMAGES. SEE LEMON V.
MAYO & MAPLES
CTY26007 LOPEZ, ADAM AND TANIA AP 0 $0.00
1/9/2006 YPD OFFICER REARENDED PARKED VEHICLE
CTY26009 TORRES, NORMA GL 0 $0.00
1/17/2006 SEWER BACKUP
CTY26010 DECKARD, PATRICIA AND MICHAEL E0 0 $533.25
1/6/2006 SEWER SIDE LINE BREAKAGE CAUSED BY IRRIGATION
CREW WORK
CTY26011 RICHARDS, JOEL A. E0 0 $0.00
7/23/2005 ALLEGES EXCESSIVE FORCE IN ARREST BY YPD
OFFICERS AND DEPRIVATION OF DUE PROCESS OF LAW
AND LIBERTY. SEE RELATED CLAIM CTY26015
CTY26013 AILLS, JERRY AND CATHY E0 0 $0.00
12/27/2005 ALLEGES THEFT OF JEWELRY (TWO RINGS) FROM CITY
JAIL
CTY26014 RIDDLE, DAN AND SHERRI E0 0 $0.00
1/20/2006 DAMAGE TO FENCE BY PERSON ELUDING POLICE
CTY26015 RICHARDS, CHERYL E0 0 $0.00
7/23/2005 ALLEGES EXCESSIVE FORCE BY YPD OFFICERS IN
HUSBAND'S ARREST AND DEPRIVATION OF DUE
PROCESS OF LAW AND LIBERTY. SEE RELATED CLAIM
CTY26011
CTY26017 MERKT, JERRIANN AB 0 $13,559.00
2/3/2006 POLICE VEHICLE COLLIDED WITH CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY26018 STONE, JEANNA AB 0 $0.00
2/3/2006 POLICE VEHICLE COLLIDED WITH CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY26019 ANGUIANO, MARIA GL 0 $0.00
1/25/2006 BROKEN PIPE -WATER IN BASEMENT
CTY26020 CROOK, MONTGOMERY AND REBECCA E0 0 $0.00
7/1/2005 YPD OFFICER ALLEGEDLY DAMAGED RIFLE
Page 1
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
Claimant / Description
Paid
Type Type ToDate Closed
CTY26021 QWEST AREA CLAIMS OFFICE GL 0 $0.00
2/13/2006 DAMAGE TO CABLE WITH HACKSAW WHILE CITY
EMPLOYEE WAS LANDSCAPING
CTY26022 O'BRIEN, THOMAS AND ALICE GL 0 $0 00
WATER DAMAGE FROM STREET RUNOFF ON SOUTH 32ND
AVENUE ALLEGEDLY DAMAGED BASEMENT AND
RETAINING WALL FROM 2005 TO PRESENT
CTY26023 DONALDSON, GORDON E0 0 $0.00
CLAIMS DAMAGES TO HOUSE, FENCE, CAR, CAMERA,
PRINTER, TELEPHONE, AND PERSONAL INJURY, DUE TO
ALLEGED DRUG AND GANG ACTIVITY IN NEIGHBORHOOD
FROM 1999 TO PRESENT.
CTY26024 DOCKINS, GLEN EDWARD AB 0 $0.00
12/21/2005 ELUDING OFFICERS AND JUMPED OUT OF VEHICLE, RAN
AND WAS HIT BY POLICE VEHICLE
CTY26025 STRAHSBURG, ALBERT WAYNE AND SUSAN AB 0 $0.00
3/14/2006 ALLEGES BODILY INJURY AND BROKEN WATCH BAND
WHEN TRANSIT BUS BRAKED
CTY26026 IN TOWN CAR SALES, INC E0 0 $0.00
1/10/2006 CLAIMANT ALLEGES THAT A VEHICLE WAS STOLEN FROM
A CAR SALES LOT ON SOUTH 1ST STREET AND WHEN
YPD OFFICERS LOCATED VEHICLE THEY FAILED TO
APPREHEND SUSPECT ALLOWING THE SUSPECT TO
ATTEMPT TO ELUDE POLICE IN A CHASE THAT ENDED
WHEN THE STOLEN VEHICLE COLLIDED W/ A CONCRETE
BRIDGE SUPPORT AT INTERSECTION OF 1-82 AND N 1ST
STREET.
CTY26027 WILLIAMS, WILLIE R GL 0 $0.00
3/22/2006 VEHICLE DAMAGE CAUSED BY RAILROAD TRACKS
CTY26028 DILLS, FRED AND PATRICIA E0 0 $0.00
3/16/2006 ALLEGE WATER UTILITY SERVICE TO RENTAL PROPERTY
WAS NOT SHUT OFF AS REQUESTED, RESULTING IN
BROKEN WATER PIPE AND WATER DAMAGE TO BUILDING
CTY26029 KILBURY, BLAKE GL 0 $0.00
2/13/2006 WATER DAMAGE TO INTERIOR OF HOME ON 1ST AND 2ND
FLOOR AFTER WATER CREW USED WATER
CTY25070 OROZCO, MARIA GUADALUPE & JESUS AB F $0.00 1/9/2006
7/25/2005 CITY BUS HANDICAP LIFT ALLEGEDLY HIT CLAIMANT IN
THE LEG
CTY25093 NEUMEISTER, TRINA GL F $1,250.99 1/17/2006
9/10/2005 TRIP AND FALL ON SIDEWALK
CTY25024 HOWELL, CHRIS & ANGLA GL F $15,550.79 1/18/2006
3/15/2005 SEWER BACKUP
CTY25090 FAY, STEVEN TODD AND KRISTIN GL F $3,267.97 1/18/2006
9/7/2005 SEWER BACKUP
Page 2
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
Claimant / Description
Paid
Type Type ToDate Closed
CTY25127
12/1/2005
CTY25131
12/12/2005
CTY25083
8/18/2005
CTY25134
12/19/2005
CTY25137
11/8/2005
CTY26004
12/25/2005
CTY23139
11/19/2003
CTY25136
12/8/2005
CTY25132
11/11/2005
CTY25121
11/3/2005
CTY25133
12/22/2005
CTY25102
9/23/2005
CTY25112
9/26/2005
CTY25055
8/30/2004
CTY25080
5/16/2005
CTY25109
10/18/2005
CTY26012
1/23/2006
HENNING, GERALD
CITY SNOW PLOW KICKED ROCK THROUGH CLAIMANT
VEHICLE WINDOW
CABRERA, ANNETTE
CLAIMANT PARKED VEHICLE WAS STRUCK BY SUSPECTS
VEHICLE DURING HIGH SPEED CHASE
CLARK, CHERYL
GRAVEL FLEW OFF CITY STREET DEPARTMENT TRUCK
AND DAMAGED CLAIMANT WINDSHIELD
CHIN, GORDON & GRACE
YAKIMA REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANT MAILBOX
QWEST AREA CLAIMS OFFICE
CITY WORKERS DAMAGED CABLE
KENDALL, JANE
SEWER BACKUP
HILTON, JAMEY ROSS
DEBRIS OR ROCK FROM CITY STREET CREW ROAD
WORK SCRATCHED CLAIMANT'S EYE
TESTERMAN, SHERRIE & GREG
CLAIMANT VEHICLE DAMAGE FROM POTHOLE
BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA- GRAND COLUMBIA COUNCIL
#614
SEWER BACKUP
MENDOZA, CARMEN & ISRAEL
CITY WORKERS DAMAGED CLAIMANT FENCE
RESENDEZ, JOE
YAKIMA POLICE HIGH SPEED CHASE ALLEGEDLY
RESULTED IN DAMAGES TO CLAIMANT'S PARKED
VEHICLE BY SUSPECT'S VEHICLE
GODOY, ED & TERRI
SEWER BACKUP
LEON, ANTHONY
CLAIMANT INJURED ON CITY BUS WHEN IT WAS IN AN
ACCIDENT WITH AN UNINSURED PARTY ( PAID BY WSTIP
U/M COVERAGE
HARPER, BILL
SEWER BACKUP
BEN FRANKLIN TRANSIT (BFT)
CITY TRANSIT VAN BACKED INTO CLAIMANT VAN
EBERLE, EMILY & RANDY
CITY REFUSE TRUCK IMPACTED CLAIMANT MAILBOX
DUNKEL, DAMON
REFUSE TRUCK HIT GARAGE AND MAILBOX
Page 3
AP F $262.99 1/24/2006
EO F
$0.00 1/30/2006
AP F $179.25 1/31/2006
AP F $64.98
GL F $1,050 55
GL F $113.61
GL F $12,500.00
2/6/2006
2/8/2006
2/8/2006
2/13/2006
GL F $505.92 2/15/2006
GL F $254.06 2/17/2006
GL F $415.49 2/21/2006
EO F $0.00 2/22/2006
GL F $498.80 3/2/2006
AB F $6,500.00 3/23/2006
GL F $2,589.75 3/30/2006
AP F $655.65 3/30/2006
AP F $45.55 3/30/2006
AP F $272.98 3/30/2006
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
Claimant / Description
Paid
Type Type ToDate Closed
CTY26016
1/19/2006
CTY26008
1/11/2006
FOWLER, RITCHIE
VEHICLE VANDALISM AND THEFT OF ITEMS FROM
PRIVATE CAR USED BY YPD OFFICER TO ATTEND
TRAINING
GARDNER, CHRISTOPHER
VEHICLE AND TRAILER HIT POTHOLE, MOTORCYCLE FELL
OFF TRAILER.
Total Number of Claims Occurring or Closed for Current Year:
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Page 4
GL F
$0 00 3/30/2006
GL F $1,477.55 3/31/2006
48
CLOSED CLAIMS
FROM 01/01/2006 TO 03/31/2006
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
Listing of Closed Claims
For period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
Claimant / Description
Paid
ToDate Type Closed
CTY25070 OROZCO, MARIA GUADALUPE & JESUS
7/25/2005 CITY BUS HANDICAP LIFT ALLEGEDLY HIT CLAIMANT IN THE
LEG
CTY25093 NEUMEISTER, TRINA
9/10/2005 TRIP AND FALL ON SIDEWALK
CTY25024 HOWELL, CHRIS & ANGLA
3/15/2005 SEWER BACKUP
CTY25090 FAY, STEVEN TODD AND KRISTIN
9/7/2005 SEWER BACKUP
CTY25127 HENNING, GERALD
12/1/2005 CITY SNOW PLOW KICKED ROCK THROUGH CLAIMANT
VEHICLE WINDOW
CTY25131 ' CABRERA, ANNETTE
12/12/2005 CLAIMANT PARKED VEHICLE WAS STRUCK BY SUSPECT'S
VEHICLE DURING HIGH SPEED CHASE
CTY25083 CLARK, CHERYL
8/18/2005 GRAVEL FLEW OFF CITY STREET DEPARTMENT TRUCK AND
DAMAGED CLAIMANT WINDSHIELD
CTY25134 CHIN, GORDON & GRACE
12/19/2005 YAKIMA REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANT MAILBOX
CTY25137 QWEST AREA CLAIMS OFFICE
11/8/2005 CITY WORKERS DAMAGED CABLE
CTY26004 KENDALL, JANE
12/25/2005 SEWER BACKUP
CTY23139 HILTON, JAMEY ROSS
11/19/2003 DEBRIS OR ROCK FROM CITY STREET CREW ROAD WORK
SCRATCHED CLAIMANTS EYE
CTY25136 TESTERMAN, SHERRIE & GREG
12/8/2005 CLAIMANT VEHICLE DAMAGE FROM POTHOLE
CTY25132 BOY SCOUTS OF AMERICA- GRAND COLUMBIA COUNCIL #614
11/11/2005 SEWER BACKUP
CTY25121 MENDOZA, CARMEN & ISRAEL
11/3/2005 CITY WORKERS DAMAGED CLAIMANT FENCE
CTY25133 RESENDEZ, JOE
12/22/2005 YAKIMA POLICE HIGH SPEED CHASE ALLEGEDLY RESULTED IN
DAMAGES TO CLAIMANT'S PARKED VEHICLE BY SUSPECT'S
VEHICLE
CTY25102 GODOY, ED & TERRI
9/23/2005 SEWER BACKUP
CTY25112 LEON, ANTHONY
9/26/2005 CLAIMANT INJURED ON CITY BUS WHEN IT WAS IN AN
ACCIDENT WITH AN UNINSURED PARTY ( PAID BY WSTIP U/M
COVERAGE
CTY25055 HARPER, BILL
8/30/2004 SEWER BACKUP
Page 1
$0.00 AB 1/9/2006
$1,250.99 GL 1/17/2006
$15,550.79 GL 1/18/2006
$3,267.97 GL 1/18/2006
$262.99 AP 1/24/2006
$0.00 EO 1/30/2006
$179.25 AP 1/31/2006
$64.98 AP 2/6/2006
$1,050.55 GL 2/8/2006
$113.61 GL 2/8/2006
$12,500.00 GL 2/13/2006
$505.92 GL 2/15/2006
$254.06 GL 2/17/2006
$415.49 GL 2/21/2006
$0.00 EO 2/22/2006
$498.80 GL 3/2/2006
$6,500.00 AB 3/23/2006
$2,589.75 GL 3/30/2006
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
Listing of Closed Claims
For period from 1/1/2006 to 3/31/2006
Claimant / Description
Paid
ToDate Type Closed
CTY25080
5/16/2005
CTY25109
10/18/2005
CTY26012
1/23/2006
CTY26016
1/19/2006
CTY26008
1/11/2006
BEN FRANKLIN TRANSIT (BFT)
CITY TRANSIT VAN BACKED INTO CLAIMANT VAN
EBERLE, EMILY & RANDY
CITY REFUSE TRUCK IMPACTED CLAIMANT MAILBOX
DUNKEL, DAMON
REFUSE TRUCK HIT GARAGE AND MAILBOX
FOWLER, RITCHIE
VEHICLE VANDALISM AND THEFT OF ITEMS FROM PRIVATE
CAR USED BY YPD OFFICER TO ATTEND TRAINING
GARDNER, CHRISTOPHER
VEHICLE AND TRAILER HIT POTHOLE, MOTORCYCLE FELL OFF
TRAILER.
Compiled on 4/13/2006 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Total of Closed Claims Paid
Total Number of Closed Claims
Page 2
$655.65
$45.55
$272.98
$0.00
AP 3/30/2006
AP 3/30/2006
AP 3/30/2006
GL 3/30/2006
$1,477.55 GL 3/31/2006
$47,456.88
23
BUSINESS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
YAKIMA, WASHINGTON
AGENDA STATEMENT
Item No. l
For Meeting of May 2, 2006
ITEM TITLE: 1st Quarter 2006 Claim Report and Resolution authorizing and approving
1st Quarter 2006 claims activity
SUBMITTED BY: Legal Department and Finance Department y
CONTACT PERSON/TELEPHONE: Helen A. Harvey, Assistant City Attorney, 575-6030 O' y
Rita DeBord, Finance Director, 575-6070
SUMMARY EXPLANATION:
The purpose of this report is to provide historical information on claims made against the City of
Yakima pertaining to general exposures.
The report includes information for year 2006 claims by: (1) summary; (2) type of loss;
(3) department summary; (4) claim listing by department; (5) a listing of all claims opened or
closed during 2006; and (6) a listing of all claims closed from 1/1/06 to 3/31/06. Adopting the
attached claims resolution affirms and ratifies the payments made in the 1st quarter of 2006 as
disclosed in the report.
Resolution X Ordinance Other (Specify)
Contract Mail to (name and address):
Phone:
Funding Source:
APPROVED FOR SUBMITTAL:
City Manager
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Resolution.
BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
COUNCIL ACTION:
Resolution adopted. RESOLUTION NO. R-2006-69