HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-2004-070 1st Quarter 2004 Claims ReportRESOLUTION NO. R-2004- 70
A RESOLUTION accepting and approving the 1st Quarter 2004 Claim Report
for the City of Yakima.
WHEREAS, the City of Yakima self insures as to claims; and
WHEREAS, the attached Claim Report contains information on the various
claims submitted to the City of Yakima along with the disposition; now, therefore,
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF YAKIMA:
The attached and incorporated 1st Quarter 2004 Claim Report, together
with all payments and disbursements listed therein, is hereby accepted, approved,
affirmed, and ratified.
ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this 20th day of April, 2004.
ATTEST:
City Clerk
Paul P. George, Mayor
BUSINESS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
YAKIMA, WASHINGTON
AGENDA STATEMENT
Item No. r `.
For Meeting of April 20, 2004
ITEM TITLE: 1st Quarter 2004 Claim Report and Resolution authorizing and
approving 1st Quarter 2004 claims activity
SUBMITTED BY: Legal Department and Finance Department
CONTACT PERSON/TELEPHONE: Helen A. Harvey, Assistant City Attorney, 575-6030
Rita Anson, Finance Director, 575-6070
SUMMARY EXPLANATION:
The purpose of this report is to provide historical information on claims made against
the City of Yakima pertaining to general exposures.
The report includes information for year 2004 claims by: (a) type of loss; (b) department
summary; (c) claim listing by department; (d) a listing of all claims opened or closed
during 2004; and (e) a listing of all claims closed from 1/1/04 to 3/31/04. Adopting the
attached claims resolution affirms and ratifies the payments made in the 1st quarter of
2004 as disclosed in the report.
Resolution X Ordinance Other (Specify)
Contract Mail to (name and address):
Phone:
Funding Source:
APPROVED FOR SUBMITTAL: City Manager
STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt Resolution.
BOARD/COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION:
COUNCIL ACTION: Resolution adopted. RESOLUTION NO. R-2004-70
MARSH
CITY OF YAKIMA
1st Quarter Claim
REPORT - 2004
Prepared by:
Joel Pearson, Senior Vice President
Deb Krautwurm, Vice President
CITY OF YAKIMA
CLAIM REPORT INDEX
1. 16 YEAR SUMMARY
PAID CLAIM SUMMARY BASED ON YEAR OF OCCURRENCE
2. 2004 TYPE OF LOSS BREAKDOWN
CLAIMS THAT OCCURRED AND WERE PAID IN 2004
3. 2004 DEPARTMENTAL SUMMARY
CLAIMS THAT OCCURRED AND WERE PAID iN 2004
4. 2004 CLAIMS BY DEPARTMENT
CLAIMS THAT OCCURRED AND WERE PAID IN 2004
5. DETAILED LISTING OF OPENED & CLOSED CLAIMS 2004
ALL CLAIMS OPENED OR CLOSED IN 2004
6. CLOSED CLAIMS 01/01/2004 TO 03/31/2004
ALL CLAIMS CLOSED DURING 2004
16 YEAR SUMMARY
CITY OF YAKIMA
16 YEAR CLAIM SUMMARY
FOR THE PERIOD OF 01/01/2004 TO 03/31/2004
Total number of claims are based on the year in which they occurred, not the year they were reported.
NUMBER OF CLAIMS 1989 1990
A Total Occurrences
B Open Claims
C Closed - No Payment
D Closed - With Payment
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims
1991 1992
101 90 109 112
0 0 0 0
34 27 47 43
67 63 62 69
$121,437.13 $117,642.44 $86,608.27 $246,315.63
NUMBER OF CLAIMS 1993 1994 1995 1996
A Total Occurrences 118 136 120 166
B Open Claims 0 0 1 1
C Closed - No Payment 57 64 49 44
D Closed - With Payment 61 72 70 121
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims
$256,527.50 $196,576.63 $214,359.92 $169,571 45
CITY OF YAKIMA
16 YEAR CLAIM SUMMARY
PAGE 2
NUMBER OF CLAIMS 1997 1998 1999 2000
A Total Occurrences 169 153 114 97
B Open Claims 3 1 0 4
C Closed - No Payment 44 53 41 33
D Closed - With Payment 122 99 73 60
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims $259,141.63 $7,238,545.30 (1) $245,114.49 $152,058.50
(1) The claim summary for the year 1998 includes the case of Murphy, et al. v. City of Yakima, et al., Yakima County Superior Court Cause No. 99-2-00611-8, which was a
class action case alleging damages due to wastewater odors with approximately 3,500 residents in the defined class area. The initial damage claims were filed on
May 14, 1998; for the purpose of this claim summary only, an occurrence date was assigned of May 14, 1998. Plaintiffs alleged a continuing occurrence. In 2003,
the case settled for $7,000,000.
NUMBER OF CLAIMS 2001 2002 2003 2004
A Total Occurrences 123 153 134 30
B Open Claims 5 16 20 21
C Closed - No Payment 45 47 28 3
D Closed - With Payment 73 90 86 6
COST OF CLAIMS
A Paid Claims
$240,622.83 $208,063.85 $127,169.38 $4,365.91
Compiled on 04/06/04 from the records of Zaremba Claims Service, Inc.
Paid Claims
400,000.00
350,000.00
300,000.00
250,000.00
200,000.00
150,000.00
100,000.00
50,000.00
0.00
CITY OF YAKIMA
Paid Claims
III Total Paid
1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
(1)
(1) The claim summary for the year 1998 includes the case of Murphy, et al. v. City of Yakima, et al., Yakima County Superior Court Cause No. 99-2-00611-8, which was a
class action case alleging damages due to wastewater odors with approximately 3,500 residents in the defined class area. The initial damage claims were filed on
May 14, 1998; for the purpose of this claim summary only, an occurrence date was assigned of May 14, 1998. Plaintiffs alleged a continuing occurrence. In 2003,
the case settled for 57,000,000.
2004 TYPE OF LOSS
BREAKDOWN
1
1
1
1
CITY OF YAKIMA
SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS
CLAIMS THAT HAVE BEEN PAID AND OCCURRED
DURING THE PERIOD FROM 01/01/2004 TO 03/31/2004
TYPE OF CLAIM
OPEN CLOSED
PAID TO DATE
IAutomobile Liability 4 2 0.00
Errors & Omissions 0 1 0.00
IGeneral Liability 17 6 4,365.91
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
TOTALS ALL DEPARTMENTS 21 9
Compiled on 04/06/2004 from the records of Zaremba Claims Service, Inc.
$4,365.91
CITY OF YAKIMA
SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS
BASED ON PAID AMOUNT
■ Automobile Liability
■ Errors & Omissions
■ General Liability
2004 DEPARTMENTAL
SUMMARY
CITY OF YAKIMA
DEPARTMENTAL THIRD PARTY LIABILITY CLAIMS SUMMARY
CLAIMS THAT HAVE BEEN PAID AND OCCURRED
DURING THE PERIOD FROM 01/01/2004 TO 03/31/2004
TYPE OF CLAIM
OPEN CLOSED
TOTAL PAID
General Administration
Parks and Recreation
Public Works
Refuse
Water
Sewer
Police
Streets
Fire
Transit
Engineering
Animal Control
Other - Unallocated
Parking Enforcement
Community and Economic
1
1
0
2
0
11
2
3
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
3
0
4
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
500.00
3,099.50
0.00
766.41
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
TOTALS ALL DEPARTMENTS 21
Compiled on 04/06/2004 from the records of Zaremba Claims Service, Inc.
9
$4,365.91
Departmental Third Party Liability Claims for 2004
Based on Paid Amount
,v #
❑ General Administration
■ Parks and Recreation
❑ Public Works
❑ Refuse
Et Water
❑ Sewer
MI Police
IN Streets
■ Fire
❑ Transit
■ Engineering
■ Animal Control
■ Other - Unallocated
■ Parking Enforcement
I■ Community and Economic
2004 CLAIMS BY DEPARTMENT
(Detailed Listing)
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Automobile Property
CTY24011 RAUERT, ROBERT & COLLEEN
1/8/2004 CITY VEHICLE BACKED INTO
CLAIMANT DRIVE AND DAMAGED
TIER LIGHT
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
417 N. 29TH PLACE IN YAKIMA OPEN $0 00
Total Paid for Automobile Property $0 00
Total Paid All Claims $0 00
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Parks and Recreation
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
General Liability
CTY24021 BEVERLY, BETTY 38TH AVENUE BETWEEN PARK OPEN $0 00
3/14/2004 GOLF BALL DAMAGED CLAIMANT
VEHICLE
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Total Paid for General Liability
Total Paid All Claims
Page 1
$0 00
$0 00
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Refuse
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Automobile Property
CTY24018 THOMAS, CINDY 1407 S 10TH AVENUE IN YAKIM OPEN $0 00
2/11/2004 REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED
CLAIMANT FENCE
CTY24024 SLIMAN, ELVIE 1704 CORNELL AVENUE IN YAKI OPEN $0 00
3/3/2004 REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED
CLAIMANT FENCE
Total Paid for Automobile Property $0 00
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
7ARPAARA ('T ATmc cPR\TTPT TNTC
Total Paid All Claims $0 00
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Water
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
General Liability
CTY24001 HAYNES, ANDREW & KATHRYN 1417 LANDON AVENUE CLOSED $500 00
1/42004 CITY TOOK 3 1/2 HOURS TO SHUT
OFF WATER AFTER PIPE BROKE
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
Total Paid for General Liability
Total Paid All Claims
Page 1
$500 00
$500 00
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Sewers
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Paid
Site / Operator Status ToDate
General Liability
CTY24003 BASTARDO, FRANK & ESTHER 620 W MEAD AVENUE IN YAKIM CLOSED $312.07
1/4/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24010 SANCHEZ, HUGO "D" STREET & N. 6TH STREET CLOSED $985 00
1/26/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24012 VIVEROS, JESSICA & JACOB 709 S 18TH AVENUE CLOSED $1,802.43
1/31/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24013 BARRIGA. MARIA 903 5 18TH AVENUE OPEN $0 00
2/4/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24017 CARLSON, TIM 4706 DOUGLAS AVENUE OPEN $0 00
2/28/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24032 WENDT, HELEN 610 5 72ND AVENUE IN YAKIMA OPEN $0 00
3/13/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24020 CONNECTIONS FELLOWSHIP VINEYARD CHURCH, 221 E. B S OPEN $0 00
2/17/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24029 HOPE, JOHN & CINDY 40TH AND W LINCOLN AVENUE OPEN $0 00
3/14/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24031 KEATLEY, DARLA 4003 W LINCOLN AVENUE IN YA OPEN $0 00
3/14/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24023 HOON, GARY & ROSEMARY 1004 S 41ST AVENUE IN YAKIM OPEN $0 00
3/9/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24015 VINEYARD CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP 221 E. 'B' STREET IN YAKIMA OPEN $0 00
2/17/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24026 GARZA, DIANE 4004 W LINCOLN AVENUE OPEN $0 00
3/14/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24027 MACIAS, DENNIS 509 E. SPRUCE STREET IN YAKI OPEN $0 00
3/6/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24028 MCCARTNEY, DAVID 4004 W LINCOLN AVENUE OPEN $0 00
3/14/2004 SEWER BACKUP
Total Paid for General Liability $3,099 50
Total Paid All Claims $3,099 50
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC.
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Police
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
General Liability
CTY24030 LEWIS, DWIGHT 713 N. 5TH AVENUE OPEN $0 00
3/24/2004 CLAIMANT'S DOOR DAMAGED BY
POLICE
CTY24019 GARZA, JASON 512 W 3RD STREET IN WAPAT OPEN $0 00
2/26/2004 CLAIMANT BITTEN BY CITIZEN'S
DOG WHILE ON JOB SHADOW WITH
YPD OFFICER
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
Total Paid for General Liability
Total Paid All Claims
Page 1
$0 00
$0 00
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Streets
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
Paid
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description Site / Operator Status ToDate
Automobile Property
CTY24008 RAMOS, SERINA 1411 E. ALDER STREET IN YAKI CLOSED $0 00
1/8/2004 SNOW PLOW RAN OVER CLAIMANT
GARBAGE CANS
CTY24007 O'HARA, GERALD & LINDA 1402 S 42ND AVENUE IN YAKIM CLOSED $0 00
1/13/2004 SNOW PLOW DAMAGED CLAIMANT
LAWN
CTY24002 GONZALES, ANGEL NOB HILL AND FIRST STREET I OPEN $0 00
1/6/2004 CLAIMANT VEHICLE ALLEGEDLY HIT
BY SNOW PLOW AT INTERSECTION
Total Paid for Automobile Property $0 00
General Liability
CTY24025 BLADOW, AMANDA 1900 W JAY STREET IN YAKIMA OPEN $0 00
1/25/2004 CLAIMANT TIRE DAMAGE FROM POT
HOLE
CTY24006 BOSSERT, JAY & HILLARY 16TH AND MEAD AVENUE OPEN $0 00
1/7/2004 CLAIMANT VEHICLE DAMAGE FROM
OPEN MAN HOLE
CTY24004 HESSENTHALER, WALTER 16TH AND MEAD IN YAKIMA CLOSED $606 51
1/8/2004 UNCOVERED MANHOLE DAMAGED
CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY24009 RODRIGUEZ, IRMA BEECH STREET & CHAMLER CLOSED $159 90
1/20/2004 POT HOLE DAMAGED CLAIMANT
VEHICLE
Total Paid for General Liability $766 41
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
Total Paid All Claims $766 41
Page 1
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Transit
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
Bodily Injury Liability
CTY24014 LONG, MAXINE WALNUT AND S 3RD STREET CLOSED $0 00
2/7/2004 CLAIMANT INJURED WHEN CITY BUS
WAS HIT BY ANOTHER VEHICLE
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
Total Paid for Bodily Injury Liability
Total Paid All Claims
Page 1
$0 00
$0 00
CITY OF YAKIMA
Summary of Third Party Claims for the Department of Parking Enforcement
For the period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File / Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Site / Operator Status
Paid
ToDate
General Liability
CTY24022 SMITH, RAY & ELAINE 1102 HATHAWAY IN ELKO PARK OPEN $0 00
3/17/2004 CLAIMANT WINDOW BROKEN FROM
ROCK THROWN BY CITY MOWER
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
Total Paid for General Liability
Total Paid All Claims
Page 1
$0 00
$0 00
OPENED OR CLOSED CLAIMS
FROM 01/01/2004 TO 03/31/2004
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
Claimant / Description
Type Type
Paid
ToDate Closed
CTY24002 GONZALES, ANGEL AP 0 $0 00
1/6/2004 CLAIMANT VEHICLE ALLEGEDLY HIT BY SNOW PLOW AT
INTERSECTION
CTY24006 BOSSERT, JAY & HILLARY GL 0 $0 00
1/7/2004 CLAIMANT VEHICLE DAMAGE FROM OPEN MAN HOLE
CTY24011 RAUERT, ROBERT & COLLEEN AP 0 $0 00
1/8/2004 CITY VEHICLE BACKED INTO CLAIMANT DRIVE AND
DAMAGED TIER LIGHT
CTY24013 BARRIGA, MARIA GL 0 $0 00
2/4/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24015 VINEYARD CHRISTIAN FELLOWSHIP GL 0 $0 00
2/17/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24016 SULLIVAN, JANE E0 0 $0 00
3/7/2003 CLAIMANT ALLEGES FALSE ARREST AND INJURY
CTY24017 CARLSON, TIM GL 0 $0 00
2/28/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24018 THOMAS, CINDY AP 0 $0 00
2/11/2004 REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANT FENCE
CTY24019 GARZA, JASON GL 0 $0 00
2/26/2004 CLAIMANT BITTEN BY CITIZENS DOG WHILE ON JOB
SHADOW WITH YPD OFFICER
CTY24020 CONNECTIONS FELLOWSHIP GL 0 $0 00
2/17/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24021 BEVERLY, BETTY GL 0 $0 00
3/14/2004 GOLF BALL DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY24022 SMITH, RAY & ELAINE GL 0 $0 00
3/17/2004 CLAIMANT WINDOW BROKEN FROM ROCK THROWN BY
CITY MOWER
CTY24023 HOON, GARY & ROSEMARY GL 0 $0 00
3/9/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24024 SLIMAN, ELVIE AP 0 $0 00
3/3/2004 REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANT FENCE
CTY24025 BLADOW, AMANDA GL 0 $0 00
1/25/2004 CLAIMANT TIRE DAMAGE FROM POT HOLE
CTY24026 GARZA, DIANE GL 0 $0 00
3/14/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24027 MACIAS, DENNIS GL 0 $0 00
3/6/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24028 MCCARTNEY, DAVID GL 0 $0 00
3/14/2004 SEWER BACKUP
Page 1
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
Claimant / Description
Type Type
Paid
ToDate Closed
CTY24029 HOPE, JOHN & CINDY
3/14/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24030 LEWIS, DWIGHT
3/24/2004 CLAIMANT'S DOOR DAMAGED BY POLICE
CTY24031 KEATLEY, DARLA
3/142004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24032 WENDT, HELEN
3/13/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY23068 SCHAFER, ROBERT
6/16/2003 DUST ABATEMENT MATERIAL DAMAGED CLAIMANTS
VEHICLE
CTY23113 ANDREWS, VELMA & ALFRED
7/1/2003 OVERPAYMENT FOR PROPERTY CLEANUP
CTY23145 MINER, DIANE
10/28/2003 REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANTS MAILBOX
CTY23150 ALEXANDER, ANTHONY
7/8/2003 CLAIMANT ALLEGES WISHA DISCRIMINATION
CTY23127 SPRATT, CYNTHIA
10/14/2003 REMOVAL OF BULLETT FOR EVIDENCE DAMAGED
CLAIMANTS HOUSE
CTY23146 MORFIN, JESUS & ELOISA
12/5/2003 TREE BRANCH DAMAGED FENCE
CTY23152 BURNS, MARTHA & MARK
12/15/2003 CITY VEHICLE BACKED INTO CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY23142 STEVENSON, ELAINE J
11/6/2003 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24005 ROYBAL, RODNEY
11/1/2003 POT HOLE CAUSED DAMAGE TO CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY24003 BASTARDO, FRANK & ESTHER
1/4/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY23151 GONZALEZ, LOLA
9/23/2003 CLAIMANT ALLEGES THAT SHE HAS BEEN
OVERCHARGED FOR WATER
CTY23140 SCHOOLEY, COLETTE & MARK
11/21/2003 GARBAGE TRUCK PULLED DOWN POWER LINE
CTY24004 HESSENTHALER, WALTER
1/8/2004 UNCOVERED MANHOLE DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY23149 PERKINS, BRIAN
12/11/2003 CLAIMANT'S VEHICLE WINDOW DAMAGED WHILE ON
CITY PROPERTY
Page 2
GL 0 $0 00
GL 0 $0 00
GL 0 $0 00
GL 0 $0 00
GL F $151 10 1/6/2004
EO F $100 00 1/12/2004
AP F $35 00 1/23/2004
GL F $500 00 1/23/2004
GL F $295 51 2/4/2004
GL F $420 42 2/6/2004
AP F $1,193 38 2/6/2004
GL F $297 46 2/10/2004
GL F $538 16 2/10/2004
GL F $312.07 2/12/2004
EO F $0 00 2/13/2004
AP F $3,531.24 2/18/2004
GL F $606 51 2/23/2004
GL F $0 00 2/25/2004
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
File /
Date of Loss Claimant / Description
Type Type
Paid
ToDate Closed
CTY24001 HAYNES, ANDREW & KATHRYN GL F $500 00 2/26/2004
1/4/2004 CITY TOOK 3 1/2 HOURS TO SHUT OFF WATER AFTER
PIPE BROKE
CTY24010 SANCHEZ, HUGO GL F $985 00 3/1/2004
1262004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24014 LONG, MAXINE AB F $0 00 3/1/2004
2/7/2004 CLAIMANT INJURED WHEN CITY BUS WAS HIT BY
ANOTHER VEHICLE
CTY24007 O'HARA, GERALD & LINDA AP F $0 00 3/3/2004
1/132004 SNOW PLOW DAMAGED CLAIMANT LAWN
CTY24008 RAMOS, SERINA AP F $0 00 3/3/2004
1/8/2004 SNOW PLOW RAN OVER CLAIMANT GARBAGE CANS
CTY24009 RODRIGUEZ, IRMA GL F $159 90 3/4/2004
1/20/2004 POT HOLE DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY23131 BURROW, CARL & MARTHA GL F $1,774 90 3/8/2004
10/9/2003 SEWER BACKUP
CTY23138 BURGESS, JERRY & AUDREY GL F $588 57 3/8/2004
11/112003 DUST FROM KISSEL PARK BLEW ON CLAIMANTS
PROPERTY
CTY23143 CLARK, LISA AB F $300 00 3/8/2004
11242003 BUS DOOR PINCHED CLAIMANT
CTY24012 VIVEROS, JESSICA & JACOB GL F $1,802.43 3/8/2004
1/31/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY23075 BOOTHMAN, RODGER AND CHRISTINE GL F $0 00 3/162004
6/30/2003 GOLF BALL DAMAGED CLAIMANTS WINDSHIELD AND
BEDROOM WINDOW
CTY22115 APOLLO, INC GL F $104,000 00 3/23/2004
12/20/2001 CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT CLAIM FOR ADDITIONAL
COSTS FOR INTERFERENCES OF UTILITIES ON AHTANUM
TRUNK LINE
CTY22151 HELEN VANCE 1 HARTFORD CASUALTY INSURANCE CO GL F $0 00 3/23/2004
12222000 SLIP AND FALL ON ALLEGED ICY PARKING LOT
CTY23153 SHAUL, STEPHEN & GRACE GL F $4,744 07 3/24/2004
12/17/2003 SEWER BACK UP
CTY21003 BARBOSA, LUIS & GEORGIA AP F $0 00 3/31/2004
1/16/2001 CITY BUS HIT CLAIMANT VEHICLE
Page 3
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
List of Claims Opened or Closed During Current Year
For period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
Claimant / Description
Type Type
Paid
ToDate Closed
Total Number of Claims Occurring or Closed for Current Year: 51
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
Pane 4
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
Listing of Closed Claims
For period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
Claimant / Description
Paid
ToDate Type Closed
CTY23068 SCHAFER, ROBERT
6/16/2003 DUST ABATEMENT MATERIAL DAMAGED CLAIMANTS VEHICLE
CTY23113 ANDREWS, VELMA & ALFRED
7/1/2003 OVERPAYMENT FOR PROPERTY CLEANUP
CTY23145 MINER, DIANE
10/28/2003 REFUSE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANT'S MAILBOX
CTY23150 ALEXANDER, ANTHONY
7/8/2003 CLAIMANT ALLEGES WISHA DISCRIMINATION
CTY23127 SPRATT, CYNTHIA
10/14/2003 REMOVAL OF BULLETT FOR EVIDENCE DAMAGED CLAIMANT'S
HOUSE
CTY23146 MORFIN, JESUS & ELOISA
12/5/2003 TREE BRANCH DAMAGED FENCE
CTY23152 BURNS, MARTHA & MARK
12/152003 CITY VEHICLE BACKED INTO CLAIMANT VEHICLE
l I ¥23142 STEVENSON, EVENSON, ELAINE J
11/6/2003 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24005 ROYBAL, RODNEY
11/1/2003 POT HOLE CAUSED DAMAGE TO CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY24003 BASTARDO, FRANK & ESTHER
1/4/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY23151 GONZALEZ, LOLA
9/23/2003 CLAIMANT ALLEGES THAT SHE HAS BEEN OVERCHARGED
FOR WATER
CTY23140 SCHOOLEY, COLETTE & MARK
11212003 GARBAGE TRUCK PULLED DOWN POWER LINE
CTY24004 HESSENTHALER, WALTER
1/8/2004 UNCOVERED MANHOLE DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE
CTY23149 PERKINS, BRIAN
12/11/2003 CLAIMANTS VEHICLE WINDOW DAMAGED WHILE ON CITY
PROPERTY
CTY24001 HAYNES, ANDREW & KATHRYN
1/4/2004 CITY TOOK 3 1/2 HOURS TO SHUT OFF WATER AFTER PIPE
BROKE
CTY24010 SANCHEZ, HUGO
1/26/2004 SEWER BACKUP
CTY24014 LONG, MAXINE
2/7/2004 CLAIMANT INJURED WHEN CITY BUS WAS HIT BY ANOTHER
VEHICLE
CTY24007 O'HARA, GERALD & LINDA
1/13/2004 SNOW PLOW DAMAGED CLAIMANT LAWN
CTY24008 RAMOS, SERINA
1/8/2004 SNOW PLOW RAN OVER CLAIMANT GARBAGE CANS
Page 1
$151.10 GL 1/6/2004
$100 00 EO 1/12/2004
$35 00 AP 1/23/2004
$500 00 GL 1/23/2004
$295 51 GL 2/4/2004
$420 42 GL 2/6/2004
$1,193 38 AP 2/6/2004
$2917 46 GL 2//02004
$538 16 GL 2/102004
$312.07 GL 2/122004
$0 00 EO 2/13/2004
$3,531.24 AP 2/18/2004
$606 51 GL 2/23/2004
$0.00 GL 2252004
$500 00 GL 2262004
$985 00 GL 3/1/2004
$0 00 AB 3/12004
$0 00 AP 3/3/2004
$0 00 AP 3/3/2004
File /
Date of Loss
CITY OF YAKIMA
Listing of Closed Claims
For period from 1/1/2004 to 3/31/2004
Claimant / Description
Paid
ToDate Type Closed
CTY24009
1/20/2004
CTY23131
10/9/2003
CTY23138
11/11/2003
CTY23143
11/24/2003
CTY24012
1/31/2004
C I if23075
6/30/2003
CTY22115
12/20/2001
CTY22151
12/22/2000
CTY23153
12/17/2003
CTY21003
1/16/2001
RODRIGUEZ, IRMA
POT HOLE DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE
BURROW, CARL & MARTHA
SEWER BACKUP
BURGESS, JERRY & AUDREY
DUST FROM KISSEL PARK BLEW ON CLAIMANTS PROPERTY
CLARK, LISA
BUS DOOR PINCHED CLAIMANT
VIVEROS, JESSICA & JACOB
SEWER BACKUP
BOOTHMAN, RODGER AND CHRISTINE
GOLF BALL DAMAGED CLAIMANT'S WINDSHIELD AND
BEDROOM WINDOW
APOLLO, INC
CONSTRUCTION CONTRACT CLAIM FOR ADDITIONAL COSTS
FOR INTERFERENCES OF UTILITIES ON AHTANUM TRUNK LINE
HELEN VANCE / HARTFORD CASUALTY INSURANCE CO
SLIP AND FALL ON ALLEGED ICY PARKING LOT
SHAUL, STEPHEN & GRACE
SEWER BACK UP
BARBOSA, LUIS & GEORGIA
CITY BUS HIT CLAIMANT VEHICLE
Compiled on 4/6/2004 from the records of
ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC
Total of Closed Claims Paid
Total Number of Closed Claims
Pape 2
$159 90
$1,774 90
$588 57
$300.00
$1,802.43
$0 00
GL 3/4/2004
GL 3/8/2004
GL 3/8/2004
AB 3/8/2004
GL 3/8/2004
GL 31162004
$104,000 00 GL 3/23/2004
$0 00
$4,744 07
$0 00
GL 3/23/2004
GL 3242004
AP 3/312004
$122,835 72
29