HomeMy WebLinkAbout01/17/2017 00 Misc Distributed at the Meeting Distri
at
Petition No 17-02 Meetingb __ jile
We, the undersigned registered voters of Yakima, strongly oppose the
designation of Yakima as a sanctuary city We support the laws of the
United States of America and legal immigration In addition, Yakima does
not have the resources to engage in legal battles regarding this issue nor
the funds for extra law enforcement for ensuing challenges.
Name Address Phone
Ai .. / , /I ,-------.
,776 f/ // --z-,-,4) -Da_ 9s-02.2011-dt,
,Ilt
,,, .r
., ,T, 11% 4I
�'� /5 V76S o -- 1 /fie
4.,:iiri h. • geirel
— - .-
___i:-ee4 ; fJy1( -s-d 7 , -.",/.40-0,-,,,7j- /4- y03_,
V ,, - s
4€4.iwor,
Ivi % 4. ir mac e, < < i ( it
p*,,,,_ y. ,4,6( Yla i /?,,,1„, zi q99 ai
1 t,.._, ,, c ? reit , e frEcfc Of'U. 1Lt
.ft--.41pli V‘ *qk ,,_ . ali)\ 0 rtAiu)\@\f\t(\lf -1 sJ\ c' cf, 676 ,
ir-44.-4.) ,�6' - Fa, 7w( &,w , , _ 567-g(-3r-,f—
s'�6G /eii'66,/41,4_ e6� --7j� G
ff
,�1 7 a-D)- SMklAJ '1a4 6761
We, the undersigned registered voters of Yakima, strongly oppose the
designation of Yakima as a sanctuary city We support the laws of the
United States of America and legal immigration In addition, Yakima does
not have the resources to engage in legal battles regarding this issue nor
the funds for extra law enforcement for ensuing challenges.
Name Address Phone
L z//5 5 . 1.71) av ' �� Z/9-z )
Mama010 LO- . 1/62 -086l
4zWo /(kke .. c.f 4ea 4' X19--
�46,,eri USG 7/`--/v&geft gs.3J'
Ala , M ,, 4,1�-tP-0a3. 93/ --033
76`'J``) a a f'fr://i414;9ia ,5,3 --.__? y/
"-- --c. Y e,
ifOLA- S 6 tv‘
Ur 1 Sc'�9'� 3 '760 5`
Aldi A -1 f � ' 1(Q _ v G�0I. `' c
h /� • 9- 4$U-o6OG
64A4
,lsk vuo ad 9 ?gas, , 5c_,7,_it 5-7
//
.' '.7` z. / f//, '1-,,,/L-; ••1'l.,is /-y-, L
/ J
a2/ 4:.
e.,. '`�^�� 2ZC .Sa ( ,/,/,'„) ,4(1 .1p Ta 5 1-1
' .1,4 `-' rvt 1/ .1J;)( s` )M;-v, 6!Ar- 0 /%'4? 17 /7
O;9141 ( Af /LI R d. ' 2//m li/ , A r /
We, the undersigned registered voters of Yakima, strongly oppose the
designation of Yakima as a sanctuary city We support the laws of the
United States of America and legal immigration In addition, Yakima does
not have the resources to engage in legal battles regarding this issue nor
the funds for extra law enforcement for ensuing challenges.
Name Address Phone
+-ke-ttlie _ 5161 41/ x--017
�.4. 45,,.c, a-24 iirl`4Il? /�+//a s-7/-‘‘/- 33Y
( Y3 e�,,to ,, ,7 / /
• ' ", I 5107v 6.6
1
- i _ c . .52)/1/1ZeIi/ir Ati6 1 ci--ei gLiAm c A ?c69
'' I $ 1 3103 LO. Citafnc l VI 'vytx. 0— /
ice\ o u) IQ \ 1G_t m q t LtS-0/7_S—
Ile t-Ne.14Atrt4 700 ct..) . 1-4,,.c..iti gAc.._ (dtkifiv ?ce si4e-/2(
/L-412#1°14Axkt-2-1 //9-07 eitic U n • t r✓b9, 307- 81-6Q C
ak,4-1,.CA7, t‘v/Iti 014- fmo, 5-16-tti, gzif-t.-44.4 72g.05vy
,1 �i,��' #7`J S • q2 34.71--4352-e)
,j .S4-O2 Cots Ie ers, 7.0t 1t,iwca./ 1-te19'., 410•2_v2..
We, the undersigned registered voters of Yakima, strongly oppose the
designation of Yakima as a sanctuary city We support the laws of the
United States of America and legal immigration In addition, Yakima does
not have the resources to engage in legal battles regarding this issue nor
the funds for extra law enforcement for ensuing challenges.
Name Address ( Dvl U`S ( ^ Phone
CAA/-16 S '
divu:9-tv) 0,67tit .) 2-76.14, 4S2 SSfa
leavoirt.
d4 /Z. 73e'tf, - t 0Air6ttot ?o q P5
044(4 4h42 /Zo 4 V +mak.. g
/4444C - Yam 4M1.oZ
CAA"ej ll L �lkUtL
a a
4F,
►� r7aR hum °M03 c(30- V-tOLf
z 1 «/L/) se) //,;Ze)Fi4 ("), l �, 5K761 9 -/( 0)
/2 -
We, the undersigned registered voters of Yakima, strongly oppose the
designation of Yakima as a sanctuary city We support the laws of the
United States of America and legal immigration In addition, Yakima does
not have the resources to engage in legal battles regarding this issue nor
the funds for extra law enforcement for ensuing challenges.
Name Address Phone
mel 4,06f 544 ii,16/oe Ave
We, the undersigned registered voters of Yakima, strongly oppose the
designation of Yakima as a sanctuary city We support the laws of the
United States of America and legal immigration In addition, Yakima does
not have the resources to engage in legal battles regarding this issue nor
the funds for extra law enforcement for ensuing challenges
Name Address Phone
-
. �_ 21? S . 5`' ` A 5U - 5...3 �lJ �
Josi--ck5 /e2- &13 509 5 --'/1
i1& 7. 0441CA oZI3 ; 3 5OG - s3 -45105
Distributed at the
Meeting k 7-17
Yakima WA ---A City Of Sanctuary? Ura Cil rZ-z t'
s 4 s ,r•tab ti P, 4 I! , r ,i
ar •.. .�., ..
..« .
i,,!,,,,4 ..„.„4; ...
.. . , ,'°
� iw .?. ia � Fww II> •v 7 dxa '
t
"tF,
.1
" .Z p fp
(
ii I
r�. t7f e
c k [i r —!
two 4 „g;> 1 _ �
8
a,
1
r,,.,V.. ;.: su . e..� ,�-,-..mai 7�. .:,,.;,-,77.,q41,,;,t., h,., ..., .,, ... ,:
It's not only Ed Murray's Seattle, or San Francisco, or Chicago who are taking a position of lawlessness as
a so-called "sanctuary city"---now Yakima, WA ---the place of my birth---is considering standing against the
law of the land and possibly becoming a "sanctuary city "
"The reason," Councilwoman Carmen Mendez says, is that "council members took an oath at the beginning
of their term to protect all the city's residents, not just a handful "
Unless Yakima has crafted their own oath of office, the state recommended local oath of office doesn't say
that at all The oath is to uphold the Constitution of the United States and local law
To all my readers who do not live, or were not born in Yakima, WA , this is a snapshot of far Left
progressivism in action
Tiic ,3k,tl'hi -leraId is reporting that "Despite numerous complaints and concerns from audience members
the Yakima City Council voted unanimously Tuesday to create a resolution to ensure that all residents---
regardless of immigration status---feel safe "
The Herald says, "Many in the audience were upset that the council was discussing possible 'sanctuary city'
status "
An example Rick Weiss told the council, "I don't see why you want to bring more illegals in, needy people
who are already taxing our resources to the max Sanctuary cities are illegal It's been proven that crimes
increase in sanctuary cities "
He's right. I'll come back to that in a moment.
On December 9, 2015, The "r akima Herald reported, "It took generations for Yakima to elect its first Latinos
to the City Council "
The Herald said, "And as City Hall filled with observers and cameras flashed to document the historic
moment, it took just moments to swear them in "
"Councilwoman Carmen Mendez,"the Herald reports, said, "It's great that we get to be here and that the
city gets to have fair elections "
The "fair elections" she references was the result of a year of major shifts at City Hall after a federal judge
ordered new council district elections as part of the ACLU voting rights lawsuit against the city---a ruling the
city was appealing at the time
The federal judge also required the city to pay the ACLU $1 8 million in legal costs
Dulce Gutierrez said on that historic day back in 2015, she always believed change would come but didn't
expect it to happen so soon
About the oath they took The State of Washington has a published, r eGommended oath i for local
governments to use for swearing in
As the Herald reported, it's short---"only took a few moments "
This is the oath
1 do solemnly `;wear[et affirm]that l Lviii Itt,po t the v in 't Ilion of the t it itm'd
3l( t' ;irrt.t time C:onsirttrttor, and lawv of tee Sl 0 of h% .'iiit)C.Itv1i 1,0<ill loG,d ouitiii Iri(.i
-Ind Pm t 1 will faith/1.0ly and iitipartial4perfoini t i t gl 1 the P//Ilt; ?l time office ct
it.'e orzlinq In the lc?i; and the hes/ or tr4 t f4
It is assumed that all city council persons in every city will seek to serve the best interests of all the people
who live there---not just a "handful " And even try to protect them However, Ms Mendez's claim that they
"took an oath to protect"the people doesn't show up in the text of the oath
What is clear is the fact that they swore or affirmed to "support the Constitution of the United States and the
Constitution and laws of the State of Washington, and all local ordinances "
Their oath also swore or affirmed that they would faithfully and impartially perform and discharge the duties
of the office they are being sworn into "according to the law and the best of my ability "
I agree with Ms Mendez, she and the other council members should take their oath very seriously
Perhaps she and others should review what they actually swore or affirmed to do
Creating a so-called "Sanctuary City" stands in direct contradiction to the Constitution and the laws of the
United States and the State of Washington
Legal immigration is legal and celebrated
Illegal immigration is illegal and according to the law of the land, punishable
Rick Weiss, whom I don't know, was right
Crime rates do increase in sanctuary cities
The far Left progressives generally use 2 arguments in their position against the law
First, some say there is no increase in crime in sanctuary cities They generally quote a report by the CATO
Institute that claims "immigrants are less crime-prone than natives or have no effect on crime rates "
However, their conclusion is drawn from all immigrants---not illegal ones Legal immigrants have chosen to
comply with the laws of this country and become productive citizens---a value and principle upon which our
country was founded
Illegals have chosen to ignore and break the laws of this country
Iudv- i \,itc ii, a highly respected investigative organization, has done extensive research of actual crime
records in so-called sanctuary cities
The have found that crime rates do indeed go up in sanctuary cities If you read the link above you will see
that in San Francisco, a city that became a sanctuary city in 2011 they have seen crime rates skyrocket
From 2011 to 2015, the number of arrests for murder has increased by 55% and the number of arrests for
rape has increased 370%
TIME M flu reports that in Chicago, also a sanctuary city they have experienced an exponential
increase in crime---in fact, they report that Chicago is responsible for half of the crime increase in the entire
country
They report that just three cities Baltimore, Chicago, and Houston account for 31 5% of the increase in
murders nationwide
Baltimore and Chicago have formally declared they are "sanctuary cities"while Houston has adopted the
policies of sanctuary cities, but have not formally declared themselves to be, in an effort to avoid loosing
federal funding for refusing to cooperate with and enforce federal laws on immigration
In September, Louisiana's Attorney General reported that crime is up in their state in the "so-called
sanctuary cities "
And finally some advocates for sanctuary cities claim a biblical moral mandate
They often compare today's so-called sanctuary cities to those cities of refuge in the Bible
The "sanctuary cities" in the Bible were actually cities of refuge not sanctuaries A city of refuge (Numbers
35 11-34) was a city---there were 6 of them---to which a person who had committed a murder could go for a
trial If the murder was accidental the person would be freed, if it was premeditated, they were not freed
That's called justice, not fairness
My friend Erto i f"isuhor with American Family Association wrote an excellent article awhile back on this
subject I recommend you read it.
H� says referring to the murder of Kate Steinle "In San Francisco, the guilty are allowed to walk free and
the innocent required to pay the ultimate penalty for this misbegotten approach to immigration This is
profoundly contrary to Scripture, which insists that the guilty be punished and contrary to every concept of
Western jurisprudence "
Byran rightly concludes "Sanctuary cities like San Francisco are uncaring, unbiblical un-Christian,
unconstitutional, illegal, and un-American It's time they're scrapped once and for all "
As the City of Yakima oath does not call for the council members to "protect" the citizens---rather to uphold
the law and the Constitution, the Bible does not call for cities to arbitrarily claim to be "sanctuary" cities in
support of lawlessness---and most likely, a personal political agenda
Be Informed Be Discerning Be Vigilant. Be Free.
Good evening Mayor, members of the Council and my community
There is a common verse in many bibles I am sure many have heard
or read "Love thy neighbor as yourself "
(See http.//biblehub.com/mark/12-31 .htm)
Well this two-time awarded "All American City" does not seem to have
many vocal people who love themselves I am disappointed, well
actually, enraged to see and hear my most vocal neighbors speak
about other neighbors in a hateful, divisive, abhorrent manner We
have been conditioned to hate and fear - bullying out the latest label
we attach to anything that does not fit our insulated narrative festering
our hate Let me read you a few labels that I have seen happily thrown
around to demean Commie, DemoRat, Libtard, Snowflake, Wingnut,
Rethuglican, and one of the most nauseating "illegals "
It would be interesting to know how many of my neighbors have
actually read the US Supreme Court Case Arizona vs United States If
you have, you would know that the opinion reads, not once but twice
"As a general rule, it is not a crime for a removable alien to remain in
the United States "
(See https.//www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/11pdf/11 -182b5e1 .pdf
at pp 3, 15)
Let me read that again "As a general rule, it is not a crime for a
removable alien to remain present in the United States "
Our Native American brothers and sisters did not run Ellis Island nor
set in place the condition for which one was deemed what many now
cruelly call "illegal " In my limited understanding, our Native American
brothers and sisters, despite the injustice and horrors perpetrated on
them, still retain their grace and dignity to teach us to respect our earth
thus ourselves Could you imagine our Native American brothers and
sisters telling us that because of the whiteness of our skins, we
"illegals" must go back to where we came from? Think about how
those words would affect you daily Does the verse I quoted condition
your love? Does your deity instruct you to "love thy 'legal' neighbor as
yourself"?
There is no "legal" definition of what a "sanctuary city" means
Generally, "a sanctuary city is a city that has adopted a policy of
protecting undocumented immigrants by not prosecuting them for
violating federal immigration laws in the country in which they are
now living illcgally (See, https.//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanctuarv_city)
I believe because of vocal and intense hate being permeated
throughout, this is exactly one of the reason that we must be identified
as a sanctuary city
I was asked recently, if I were in your shoes would I vote for this
resolution My answer is I would happily stand for my community
against the conditioned hate and fear destroying our beautiful City
Dr Martin Luther King, Jr on April 27, 1965 said in part
"The time is always right to do right "
"It may be true that you can't legislate integration, but you can
legislate desegregation It may be true that morality cannot be
legislated, but behavior can be regulated It may be true that the law
cannot change the heart, but it can restrain the heartless It may be
true that the law can't make a man love me, but it can restrain him
from lynching me, and I think that's pretty important also So while
the law may not change the hearts of men, it does change the habits
of men And when you change the habits of men, pretty soon the
attitudes and the hearts will be changed And so there is a need for
strong legislation constantly to grapple with the problems that we
face "
(See at 33 23 http.//newsroom.ucla.edu/stories/archivist-finds-long-
lost-recording-of-martin-luther-king jr-s-speech-at-ucla)
Submitted by
Susan Soto Palmer
732 Summitview Avenue #664
Yakima, WA 98902
For entry in Council meeting 17 January, 2017
Members of the City Council
My name is Gerald Mellen and I have been a resident of Yakima for the past 37 years.
I have had the good fortune to reside on three continents during the course of my life time and can say
from experience, counter to what many say and believe,that this is the greatest country to live and
reside in. One of the founding principles is based on the fact that we are a nation of laws and those laws
need to be respected. If it is believed that a law is wrong or needs to be changed there are ways to
accomplish that.
It is shameful that you as our elected officials are even discussing passing an ordinance, directive,
proposal or whatever you want to call it that would place our law enforcement authorities outside
these laws is shameful at best. You took an oath to uphold the law and you are discussing a self initiated
proposal to direct officials of the City to ignore a current law of the land.
Many laws at all levels cannot be enforced to the letter of the law and the immigration laws certainly fit
into that category But to place a written directive directing our law enforcement authorities to ignore a
law is flat wrong if not unlawful in itself
If you as a City can chose to ignore lawful legislation can I,as a citizen, likewise chose to ignore or act
counter to laws that I don't like?
Thank you
Remarks Yakima City Council January 17, 2017
Mayor Coffey, City Council, City Manager, Staff
Thank you for the privilege to speak tonight.
I want to thank Andy Ferguson and Dennis Crane for their faithfulness these past months to offer publicly a
prayer to Father God on our behalf for you and our city at each of the City Council meetings.
We in this community continue to pray Wisdom in and upon your lives because you have been called to govern
our City
In December, I stood before you and proposed that Yakima be designated a"City of Refuge"
• where the Constitution of the State of Washington and the Constitution of our United States of America,
a Republic, are honored and followed,
• where the laws and ordinances of the City are enforced,
• where righteous and just governmental decisions are made,
• where our justice system is indeed just,
• where the citizens live orderly prosperous lives,
• where our law enforcement people are respected,
• where the citizens learn to read and are educated,
• where the path to becoming a U S citizen becomes, with a short wait, accessible, affordable and
achievable,
• and where neighbors help neighbors-always.
Laws, ordinances, and resolutions for our city have been and are established by you, the policy making body,
and by those that came before you. The laws that remain"on the books"to be enforced are in alignment with
the constitutions of the Republic of the United States of America and Washington State.
ENFORCEMENT IS THE ISSSUE!'
Emotions are running with a fever pitch. Fear is always part of life when one chooses to look at all the 'what
ifs' or chooses not to follow the rule of law Fear is False Evidence Appearing Real. Think `Wizard of Oz'
I remember the song, `Comm to America', when Neil Diamond so eloquently sang of all the virtues, benefits
and reasons why people come to America. And the expectation and hope that sprang forth.
If our city continues to allow alien persons to reside here without documentation, or establishes a"hiding zone",
or puts the priority on the protection of citizens from a foreign country above the protection of US Citizens, we
will have effectively robbed this current generation and the next OF THEIR HOPE and the virtues and benefits
of Amenca.
My ask: Before adopting a resolution or ordinance regarding this issue, establish a committee,representative of
the citizens of the entire city,with a specified timeline, so that all the consequences-positive and negative-for
Yakima can be examined.
Thank you for your time.
Beverly Breitenfeldt