HomeMy WebLinkAbout11/15/2016 11 Martin Luther King Jr. Park UpdateITEM TITLE:
SUBMITTED BY:
SUMMARY EXPLANATION:
BUSINESS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
YAKIMA, WASHINGTON
AGENDASTATEMENT
Item No. 11.
For Meeting of: November 15, 2016
Martin Luther King Jr. Park Update
Scott Schafer, Public Works Director - (509) 576 6411
Ken Wilkinson, Parks and Recreation Manager - (509) 576 6416
Staff has been asked to provide information regarding Martin Luther King Jr. Park. The report
includes history of the park, amenities in and around the park, improvements that have been
made over the last fifteen years, upgrades that need to be made, maintenance information, and
safety concerns.
ITEM BUDGETED: No
STRATEGIC PRIORITY: Neighborhood and Community Building
APPROVED FOR
SUBMITTAL: `'City Manager
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
BOARD /COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION:
This report will be submitted to the Parks and Recreation Commission on November 9, 2016 at
its regular monthly meeting.
ATTACHMENTS:
Description
D Martin Luther King Jr. Park memo
Upload Date
1117/2016
Type
Go r Memo
D Me - Rules and Regulations regarding parks - Sara 11/4/2016 Backup Material
Watkins - Legal
Memorandum
November 15, 2016
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the Yakima City Council
City Manager, Cliff Moore
From: Scott Schafer, Director of Public Works
Ken Wilkinson, Parks and Recreation Manager
Subject: Martin Luther King Jr. Park
Martin Luther King Jr. Park was originally named Washington Park. The park was established in 1933.
The park was renamed Martin Luther King Jr. Park in 1984. Martin Luther King Jr. Park is located
south of Washington Middle School at Beech Street and S. 8th Street and is 4.01 acres. The property was
given to the city by Judge William J. and Anna G. Aumiller. The cost of acquiring the property was
$1,595. Of the total, the Aumiller's received $540.00, which we have not been able to determine why
they received this amount. In 1974, an additional 1 acre was acquired and 2 basketball courts and 2
tennis courts were constructed. The additional funds were to the City of Yakima Treasurer and the
Yakima County Treasurer for taxes. The public swimming pool was closed and removed in 2005 and
the spray park was constructed in 2006.
Annual park maintenance costs - $34,000 per year.
Maintenance costs are comprised of mowing, irrigation, electricity, portable toilet rentals, fertilization
and weed control, repairs and maintenance to the spray park, trash and graffiti removal, vandalism
repair, tree maintenance and water costs for the spray park.
Revenue
Revenue from Martin Luther King Jr. Park is minimal. The addition of a picnic shelter in the future will
result in some revenue.
Park amenities are as follows:
• Water Playground or spray park —1,800 square feet with 12 play features
• Mature shade trees
• Playground
• Basketball courts
• Security lights
• Tennis courts — now used for soccer and roller derby practice
• Picnic tables, benches, trash receptacles
• Sidewalks
Improvements to the park are as follows:
• Construction of 2 basketball courts -1978
• Construction of 2 tennis courts -1978
• Construction of small playground -1997
• Construction of the water playground or spray park - 2006
• Installation of the UIC or drain field for water from spray park - 2013
• Installation of new park sign - 2015
• Demolition of old pool bath house - 2016
Programs
• Park available for community use - e.g. Martin Luther King Jr. Day Celebration, Juneteenth
Celebration - cancelled in 2016 due to weather
Current issues
• Aging playground equipment
• Vandalism and graffiti
• Replacement of the basketball and tennis court surface
Possible future improvements
• Picnic Shelter
• Additional playground
• Restrooms
Current YMC Ordinances Regulating Parks - attached Memo from Sara Watkins provides details
1. Disorderly conduct
2. Fighting in Public
3. Drug and Alcohol regulations
4. Urinating in Public
5. Approaching people and asking for money.
6. Littering
Park Rules - title 13 YMC - Attached Memo from Sara Watkins provides details
• 13.16.015 Pedestrian right -of -way.
• 13.16.080 Trash to be placed in receptacles - Toilets not be defaced.
2
• 13.16.110 Animals prohibited from running at large.
• 13.20.020 Using park with unlawful intent or purpose.
• 13.20.030 Park curfew imposed- Exceptions -Park posting and warning as conditions
precedent to conviction.
Possible Strategies to Address Issues - Attached Memo from Sara Watkins provides details
Aerial photo of Martin Luther King Jr. Park New Park Sign
old pool bath house shown in picture has been removed
3
CITY OF YAKIMA
LEGAL
DEPARTMENT
200 South Third Street, 2nd Fl. I Yakima, WA 98901 P: 509.575.6030 1 F: 509.575.6160
MEMORANDUM
October 4, 2016
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
FROM: Sara Watkins, Senior Assistant City Attorney
SUBJECT: Current Ordinances Regarding Activities in Parks
The Public Safety Committee and the City Council inquired as to regulations of activities at
parks in the City. This memorandum addresses the current regulations on the books that are
relevant to the discussion and can be enforced in City parks.
The following is a list of ordinances currently in place that are relevant to the issues and
activities previously discussed by councilmembers as going on in public parks:
1. Disorderly conduct.
The Disorderly Conduct rules are adopted by reference and include only the state statute,
which states, in part:
(1) A person is guilty of disorderly conduct if the person:
(a) Uses abusive language and thereby intentionally creates a risk of assault;
(b) Intentionally disrupts any lawful assembly or meeting of persons without
lawful authority;
(c) Intentionally obstructs vehicular or pedestrian traffic without lawful authority...
2. Fighting in Public.
Yakima Municipal Code 6.04.070 regulates fighting in any public place, including parks:
It is unlawful for any person to fight or quarrel or to encourage others to fight in
any public place in the city of Yakima.
3. Drug and Alcohol regulations.
The Yakima Municipal Code adopts by reference the state's controlled substances regulations.
Further, the Code adopts many of the alcohol regulations, including the following:
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 2
RCW 66.44.100
Opening or consuming liquor in public place — Penalty.
Except as permitted by this title, no person shall open the package containing
liquor or consume liquor in a public place. Every person who violates any
provision of this section shall be guilty of a class 3 civil infraction under
chapter 7.80 RCW.
RCW 66.44.250
Drinking in public conveyance — Penalty against individual— Restricted
application.
Every person who drinks any intoxicating liquor in any public conveyance, except
in a compartment or place where sold or served under the authority of a license
lawfully issued, is guilty of a misdemeanor. With respect to a public conveyance
that is commercially chartered for group use and with respect to a for hire vehicle
licensed under city, county, or state law, this section applies only to the driver of
the vehicle.
Further, alcohol is not allowed in any park in Yakima without a permit under Title 13 of the
Yakima Municipal Code.
4. Urinating in Public.
Yakima's code makes urinating and /or defecating in public a crime. This is a hard one for
officers to arrest on because there generally has to be an eye witness to the crime to make the
charge.
6.55.040 Urinating or defecating in a public place.
A. It is unlawful for any person to urinate or defecate in any public place or
place open or available to the public, other than in a facility designed or provided
for that purpose.
B. A violation of this section is a misdemeanor.
5. Approaching people and asking for money.
In general, soliciting money from others, or begging, is not able to be regulated due to
constitutional matters and a person's freedom of speech. However, when people aggressively
beg or interfere with another's ability to use the sidewalk or street, those actions can be
regulated. Yakima has the following ordinance regarding pedestrian and vehicular interference:
6.75.020 Pedestrian or vehicular interference.
A. A person is guilty of pedestrian or vehicular interference if, in a public place in
the city of Yakima, he or she intentionally:
1. Obstructs pedestrian or vehicular traffic; or
2. Aggressively begs; or
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 3
3. Participates in begging within the perimeter of any city public parking lot
or within the area of parking stalls located within the city's public right -of -way.
B. Among the circumstances to be considered in determining whether a person
intends to aggressively beg are whether that person:
1. Touches the person solicited;
2. Follows the person solicited;
3. Directs profane or abusive language toward the person solicited;
4. Uses violent or threatening gestures toward the person solicited; or
5. Persists in begging after the person solicited has given a negative
response.
C. The following definitions apply to subsection A of this section:
1. "Obstructs pedestrian or vehicular traffic" means to walk, stand, sit, lie or
place an object in such a manner as to block passage by another person or
vehicle to such an extent that evasive action is necessary to avoid physical
contact. Innocent acts which unintentionally and inadvertently block traffic or
cause others to take evasive action; acts authorized as an exercise of one's
constitutional right to picket or to legally protest; and acts authorized by
permit issued pursuant to this code shall not constitute an obstruction or
interference with pedestrian or vehicular traffic.
2. "Aggressively beg" means to beg with the intent to intimidate another
person into giving money or goods.
3. "Intimidate" means to engage in conduct which would make a
reasonable person fearful or feel compelled.
4. "Beg" means to ask for money or goods as a charity, whether by words,
bodily gestures, signs, or other means.
5. "Public place" means an area generally visible to public view and
includes, but is not limited to, alleys, bridges, buildings, driveways, parking
lots, parks, plazas, sidewalks and streets open to the general public, and
doorways and entrances to buildings or dwellings accessible to the public
and the grounds enclosing them. (Ord. 2010 -19 § 1, 2010: Ord. 98 -3 § 59
(part), 1998).
6. Littering
Littering under the Yakima Municipal Code is not a crime. It is punishable as an infraction,
much like a traffic ticket for speeding.
6.86.030 Scattering of litter prohibited.
No person shall throw, drop, deposit, discard or otherwise dispose of litter on any
street, alley, sidewalk or other public place or upon a private residence or other
private property not controlled or owned by such person within the city of
Yakima, or in any body of water or waterway within the jurisdiction of the city,
except:
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 4
1. When such property is designated by the state, its authorized agencies
or by the city of Yakima for the disposal of litter and solid waste; or
2. Into a litter receptacle or other container in such a manner so that the
litter will not be strewn or blown about or otherwise carried away and
deposited by the elements upon any public place or private property of
another; or
3. When the person disposing of the litter has prior consent of the owner or
person in possession of such property and when the litter is deposited in
such a manner so as not to cause a public nuisance or to be in violation of
any other applicable law or regulation.
6.86.110 Penalty for violation.
Any person convicted of violating any provision of this chapter shall be deemed
to have committed an infraction. A person who litters shall be ordered to pay a
fine of ninety -five dollars.
7. Park rules.
Under Title 13, there are park rules that have been established. These ordinances deal
specifically with park property, whereas the previous ordinances are enforceable city -wide. A
sample of the park rules relevant to the issues at hand are as follows:
13.16.015 Pedestrian right -of -way.
(1) At all times and at all locations within any park, pedestrians shall enjoy the
right -of -way over any motorized or unmotorized vehicle, bicycle, tricycle, animal,
skates, or skateboard.
(2) A violation of this section shall constitute a civil infraction for which a
monetary penalty may be assessed in the amount of two hundred fifty dollars.
Each separate day, or portion thereof, during which any violation occurs shall
constitute a separate violation.
13.16.080 Trash to be placed in receptacles - Toilets not be defaced.
No papers, boxes, food, litter, trash or material of any kind shall be thrown on the
grass, walks or driveways, but the same must be placed in the receptacles
provided for that purpose. The comfort stations and toilets shall not be defaced
nor improperly used, nor the plumbing thereof obstructed or injured.
13.16.110 Animals prohibited from running at large.
Except as provided in YMC 13.16.115, no cattle, horses, dogs or other animals
shall be turned into, or allowed to run at large in, any park, playground or
parkway, nor shall any dog or other animal be permitted to enter any pool or
water of any park. All dogs brought into any park or playground must be held on
leash.
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 5
13.16.150 Penalty for violations.
It is unlawful for any person to violate or fail to comply with any rule or regulation
provided for in this chapter. Unless otherwise specified, any person convicted of
violating or of failing to comply with any rule or regulation provided for in this
chapter shall be punished by a fine of not more than two hundred fifty dollars or
by imprisonment in the city jail facility for a term not to exceed ninety days or by
both such fine and imprisonment
13.20.020 Using park with unlawful intent or purpose.
It shall be unlawful for any person to enter upon or remain in any public park
owned by the city of Yakima with the intent or for the purpose of committing any
unlawful act.
13.20.030 Park curfew imposed- Exceptions -Park posting and warning as
conditions precedent to conviction.
A. It is unlawful for any person to enter upon or remain in any public park
owned by the city of Yakima between the hours of ten p.m. and six a.m. of the
following day, unless the presence of such person in such park during prohibited
hours is authorized by a park use permit issued pursuant to YMC 13.16. 100 or
otherwise is incidental to an activity or function conducted by or under the
auspices of the department of parks and recreation of the city of Yakima.
B. No person shall be convicted for violating the curfew imposed by this section
unless such violation occurred in a park conspicuously posted with signs warning
against entry into or remaining in the park during prohibited hours.
C. No person shall be convicted for violating the curfew imposed by this
section unless, prior to being arrested, such person had been warned by a police
officer of the conditions established by this section.
D. The provisions of this chapter do not apply to any duly authorized city
employee in the performance of his or her duties.
13.20.040 Penalty for violation.
A violation of this chapter is a misdemeanor and is punishable by a fine not to
exceed one thousand dollars and by imprisonment for a period not to exceed
ninety days.
Other jurisdictions' park regulations or ordinances.
There are many park regulations and ordinances across the country. Below are a few
representative ordinances that dictate use of parks and facilities that the Council may consider
and have the Legal Department and Parks & Recreation Commission further discuss and study,
and my thoughts regarding whether they would work in the City of Yakima.
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 6
1. Everett
9.06.220 Reward for assistance in enforcing chapter.
The parks and recreation director may offer, post and pay a suitable reward not
exceeding twenty -five dollars for information leading to the arrest and conviction
of anyone violating the provisions of this chapter.
9.06.203 Opening or consuming marijuana in a city park - Failure to
respond - Failure to comply.
A. It is unlawful to open a package containing marijuana, usable marijuana, or
a marijuana- infused product, or consume marijuana, usable marijuana, or a
marijuana- infused product, in a city park. A person who violates this section is
guilty of a civil infraction and shall be penalized in accordance with the penalty
schedule for class 3 civil infractions under Chapter 7.80 RCW.
B. Any person who, after receiving a statement of the options provided in
Chapter 7.80 RCW for responding to the notice of civil infraction and the
procedures necessary to exercise these options, fails to exercise one of the
options in a timely manner is guilty of a misdemeanor regardless of the
disposition of the notice of civil infraction. A notice of civil infraction may be
complied with by an appearance by counsel.
C. A person who willfully fails to pay a monetary penalty or to perform
community restitution as required by a court under this section may be found in
contempt of court as provided in Chapter 7.21 RCW.
D. The terms "marijuana," "usable marijuana," and "marijuana- infused product"
shall be defined as set forth in Chapter 10.02.
Encouraging reporting of crimes in parks by offering a minor amount of money may increase
the calls from neighbors regarding illegal activity. However, $25.00 is not a lot of money and
the reward money would have to come out of the parks budget. An incentive program may be
useful, however, if voluntary programs for reporting do not work. It could be a tool in the tool
box to help fight crime at parks.
Marijuana use is currently not allowed in public, but to stress the point that people may not use
parks to smoke marijuana or use marijuana in any way (including marijuana- infused products)
the City Council could add an ordinance provision similar to that found in Everett's code to
make it clear.
2. New York City, NY
Exclusive Areas
Areas within the parks designated by the Commissioner for exclusive use shall
include:
1. Exclusive Children's Playgrounds: Adults allowed in playground areas only
when accompanied by a child under the age of twelve (12).
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 7
2. Exclusive Senior Citizens Areas: Certain areas of any park may be set aside
for citizens aged sixty -five (65) and older, for their quiet enjoyment and safety.
3. Dog Runs: Certain fenced park areas may be designated by the
Commissioner as dog runs, and persons owning or possessing dogs that are
wearing a license tag and vaccinated against rabies pursuant to the laws of the
State of New York and City of New York are permitted to allow such animals to
remain unleashed in these areas. Users of dog runs shall obey posted rules.
Users of such dog runs shall provide proof of current vaccination against rabies
and proof of current licensing upon the request of any Police Officer, Urban Park
Ranger, Parks Enforcement Patrol Officer or other Department employee or
employee of the DOHMH, the refusal of which shall constitute a violation of § 1-
03(c), § 1 -04(i) and of this paragraph. All exclusive areas will be specifically
designated as such and signs will be posted informing the public of this
designation.
New York City, and some other major cities, have exclusive children's playgrounds located
within some of their parks. These playgrounds do not allow adults present within the fenced
boundaries unless the adult is accompanied with a child under the age of 12. Although this
type of ordinance is found in New York, California and Florida, I do not believe that an
ordinance will withstand a review by the Washington State Supreme Court. People have a
constitutional liberty interest in using public property, including parks. To narrow that use there
must be a legitimate public interest to do so. Here, there currently are no facts or evidence that
there are problems with adults using children's play structures or otherwise interfering with
children playing in the parks. In my opinion, such an ordinance, if challenged, would be struck
down by the courts in the state of Washington.
3. Brookfield, IL
i of playground equipment prohibited.
No person shall in any manner use any of the playground apparatus or devices
for other than their intended purpose or misuse any playground apparatus, which
by its size and shape is meant exclusively for the use of children.
Sec. 38-72. - Interfering with department personnel prohibited.
No person shall interfere with or in any manner hinder any employee of the
playground and recreation department while engaged in constructing, repairing
tr caring for any park property.
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 8
4. Prince George County, MD
Section 11. Erecting Structures. Enclosure of any area or erection of any
structures on Commission property is prohibited unless authorized by permit.
I provide you this example of an ordinance as it would prohibit creating any structure that
enclosed an area of the park off from other users. Thus, any temporary fence, shack, or other
structure would not be allowed. I don't know if this is a problem at the parks, and would defer to
Mr. Wilkinson as to whether such an ordinance would be beneficial.
5. Snoqualmie, WA
12.12.045 Adopt -A -Park Program.
A. There is hereby authorized and established an Adopt -A -Park Program in the
city of Snoqualmie. The purpose of the program shall be to provide the
opportunity for organizations to assist in the maintenance, beautification and
improvement of the city's parks, trails and open spaces and to assist in planning
and carrying out events through a city- administered volunteer program.
B. The director of parks and recreation is hereby authorized to establish and
administer reasonable rules and regulations for the administration of the Adopt -
A -Park Program, subject to approval of the parks board, which shall at a
minimum include the following:
1. Qualifications for participating organizations;
2. Requirements for individual volunteers, including a background check;
3. Safety rules to be observed by all volunteers;
4. Provisions for the release of liability of the city by participating
organizations and individual volunteers;
5. Standards for signage recognizing organizations adopting a park; and
6. Standard forms of agreements, releases and other documents required to
implement the program, with the approval of the city attorney.
This program in Snoqualmie may help with parks here in Yakima. Many parks have non - profit
organizations who have either invested time or money in improvements, or are located nearby,
that may be interested in "adopting" the park and helping the City keep it clean and friendly. In
many neighborhoods experiencing problems with their parks, residents have gotten together at
Memorandum to Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
Cliff Moore, City Manager
October 4, 2016
Page 9
meetings and discussed how they can combat bad park behavior as a community, with the
support of the parks department and law enforcement.
If this is an avenue the Council wishes to explore, staff can find additional examples for the
Council to evaluate.