The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutR-1996-025 Broker ReportRESOLUTION NO. R-96 2 5 4 A RESOLUTION accepting and approving the Quarterly Insurance Claims Report. WHEREAS, the City self insures as to claims; and WHEREAS, the attached Quarterly Insurance Claims Report contains information on the various claims submitted to the City along with the disposition, now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF YAKIMA: The attached and incorporated Quarterly Insurance Claims Report, together with all payments and disbursements disclosed therein, is hereby accepted, approved, and affirmed, and ratified. � ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this 0 day of February, 1996. ArtEST: CITY CLERK Legal/bd Agenda/SJames CITY OF YAKIMA 1995 YEAR END CLAIM REPORT Joel Pearson Vice President Sedgwick 2/15/96 Deborah A. Krautwurm Vice President James of Washington, Inc. P.O. Box 2547 Yakima, WA 98907 509-248-7460 1-800-572-9170 ei% .V Sedgwick ‘119 Sedgwick Sedgwick James of Washington, Inc. 1430 N 16th Avenue, Lake Aspen Park, PO Box 2547, Yakima. Washington 98907 Facsimile 509 248-9007 Telephone 509 248-7460 February 15, 1996 John Hanson Director of Finance and Budget City of Yakima 129 N. Second Street Yakima , WA 98901 Re: Annual Claim Report Dear John: The City of Yakima has now been self-insured for ten years. During that period of time, there have been an average of 110 claims reported each year, and average incurred losses (paid claims plus reserves) of $134,060. Ten Year Claim Summary For the self-insurance period 1986 through 1995, this report indicates the total number of claims reported as well as the number of claims :remaining open for each year. There are no open reserves until 1991, so all claims prior to that time have been finalized. Graphs for both the number of claims reported each year and the total incurred amount are included in this section. Claims by Department This report indicates the total number of claims reported for each department as well as the incurred cost of those claims. Type of Claim Claims are separated accouding to category including general liability, automobile liability, automobile property damage, and public officials errors and omissions. Insurance BroK,np Risk Services Employee Benefits Elik% IV Sedgwick Detailed Listing of all Claims Reported in 1995 All claims which occurred and have been reported in 1995 are listed. It indicates the amount paid to date and whether the claim is open or closed. You will notice that the total paid amount shown on this detailed report does not match the claim summary section. The reason is the claim summary is taken from the claims adjuster (Zaremba) report, and the detailed listing is prepared in our office. There is a delay between the time the claim is actually settled, and when we receive notice that it has been finalized. The City initially issues the settlement check and the paid amount is on the city report, but Zaremba does not list it on their claims report until Zaremba has actually received a release form in exchange for the check. After the claim has been settled, the paperwork is sent to us and we include it on our report. The time delay is why the dollar amount varies. Detailed Listing of all Claims for the Self -Insured Period In addition to the detailed listing for 1995, we are including a separate report with a detailed listing of all claims for the ten year self-insured period. This report indicates some of the larger settlements for claims in 1992 and 1993. Conclusion The overall claims experience for the City of Yakima has been excellent. In reviewing prior insurance company loss runs, we found that INA paid $174,671 in general liability and automobile liability claims in 1984, and $214,006 in general liability and automobile liability claims in 1983. Any public officials errors and omissions and police professional liability claims would be in addition to those amounts. Considering that was ten years ago, and the cost of claims have escalated, it appears that the City has done an excellent job of both preventing and controlling the cost of the claims. We will be available at the City council meeting to answer any questions that may arise. Siq. erely, Jh'el Pearson Vice President JP:tr Enclosures OLD iNeWet-W1-1(-1LA-)"----- Deborah Krautwurm Vice President NUMBER OF CLAIMS A. Total Reported B. Open Claims C. Closed No Payment D. Closed With Payment COST OF CLAIMS CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIM SUMMARY DATE: 12/31/95 SELF - INS. 1986 113 0 55 68 A. Total Incurred $ 121,748.93 B. Paid Claims $ 121,748.93 7. Reserves $ 0.00 .). Amount Claimed $6,121,535.59 SELF - INS. 1987 103 0 37 66 SELF - INS. 1988 120 0 46 74 SELF - INS. 1989 101 0 34 67 $ 51,165.12 $133,209.46 $ 121,437.13 $ 51,165.12 $133,209.46 $ 121,437.13 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $113,079.56 $318,581.28 $5,085,195.99 Incurred Claims: Paid claims, reserve amount. Reserves: The amount the adjusting firm feels City will eventually pay on open claims. Amount Claimed: The dollar amount claimant is requesting. 12/31/95 CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIM IM SUMMARY DATE: 12/31/95 SELF - INS. 199_ NUMBER OF CLAIMS A. Total Reported 90 B. Open Claims 0 C. Closed No Payment 27 D. Closed With Payment 63 COST OF CLAIMS A. B. C. D. Total Incurred $ Paid Claims $ Reserves $ Amount Claimed $ 117, 642.44 117, 642.44 0.00 384,653.88 SELF - INS. 191 109 1. 47 61 SELF - INS. 12.2? 122 2 52 68 $ 96,608.27 $246,327.95 $ $ 71, 608.27 $230,827.95 $ $ 25,000.00 $ 15,500.00 $ $124,081.05 $693,694.31 $ SELF - INS. 1993 115 2 57 56 213,491.03 213, 491.03 .00 467,601.36 Incurred Claims: Paid claims, reserve amount. Reserves: The amount the adjusting firm feels City will pay on open claims. eventually Amount Claimed: The dollar amount claimant is requesting. 12/31/95 NUMBER OF CLAIMS A. Total Reported B. Open Claims ^ Closed No Payment -zed With Payment COST OF CLAIMS A. B. C. a. Total Incurred $ Paid Claims $ Reserves $ Amount Claimed $ CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIM SUMMARY DATE: 12/31/95 SELF - INS. 1994 128 9 56 63 136,343.50 92, 266.50 44,077.00 288, 032.55 SELF - INS. 1995 105 26 45 34 $ 102,621.20 38, 765.20 63,856.00 76,979.22 Incurred Claims: Paid claims, reserve amount. Reserves: The amount the adjusting firm feels City will eventually pay on open claims. Amount Claimed: The dollar amount claimant is requesting. 12/31/95 140 CITY OF YAKIMA NUMBER OF CLAIMS BY YEAR 120 V on 80 0 oc 60 W m 40 20 0 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 YEAR 1992 1993 A"AA VU'4 Antic I UUU $300,000 $250,000 to 2 Q $200,000 J 0 W $150,000 D $100,000 0Z $50,000 CITY OF YAKIMA TOTAL INCURRED CLAIMS BY YEAR 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 YEAR CITY OF YAKIMA DEPARTMENTAL THIRD PARTY LIABILITY CLAIMS SUMMARY FOR THE PERIOD FROM 01/01/95 TO 12/31/95 DEPARTMENT/DIVISION OPEN CLOSED TOTAL INCURRED General Administration Parks and Recreation Public Works Refuse Water Sewer Police Streets Fire Eransit Engineering Animal Control Parking Enforcement Other TOTALS ALL DEPARTMENTS 0 0 1 4 1 4 1 2 2 11 5 27 6 8 5 16 0 1 4 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 26 $ 0.00 3605.20 4801.57 450.00 2613.98 15075.25 49469.28 3954.16 907.16 20744.60 0.00 0.00 0.00 1000.00 79 $ 102,621.20 Compiled on 02/07/96 from the records of ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC. $60,000 $50,000 co 2 $40,000 0 W $30,000 W $20,000 0 Z $10,000 $0 CITY OF YAKIMA 1995 CLAIMS BY DEPARTMENT DEPARTMENT ONLY THOSE DEPARTMENTS WITH REPORTED CLAIMS ARE SHOWN. PARKS & RECREATION PUBLIC WORKS REFUSE CITY OF YAKIMA SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS FOR THE PERIOD FROM 01/01/95 TO 12/31/95 TYPE OF CLAIM OPEN CLOSED PAID TO DATE RESERVES TOTAL INCURRED AUTO LIABILITY 9 5 $ 16033.25 50500.00 66533.25 AUTO PROPERTY 5 5 3409.22 2970.00 6379.22 E & 0 0 0 0.00 0.00 0.00 GEN. LIABILITY 12 69 19322.73 10386.00 31533.73 TOTALS 26 79 38765.20 63856.00 102621.20 COMPILED ON 02/07/96 FROM THE RECORDS OF ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC. Date of Loss and Description CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIMS REPORT 1/01/95 THROUGH 12/31/95 PAGE 1 Claimant 01/02/95 Murphy, Victoria G. Trip & fall city sidewalk. Amount Amount Paid Claimed or Denied 01/10/95 Price, Bertha Clm't veh. hit hole in street/tire 01/12/95 L'Esperance, Carl J. Sewer back up. 01/05/95 Pacheco, Clara Clm't fell on bus/driver braked. 01/10/95 Miller, Kristin Hit pothole in street. 01/15/95 Clark, Marilyn Clm't hit curb to avoid police car 01/07/95 Sterling, Regina Injured on transit bus. 01/20/95 Chmielinske, Gail Trip and fall sidewalk 9th Ave. 01/20/95 Sewer back up. 01/20/95 Champie, Carlos A. 8,734.86 Water turned on by City flooded clm't residence TBD 189.96 TBD CNP and alignment. CNP TBD 500.00 364.74 53.75 CNP CNP 53.75 entering her lane. TBD 1,744.60 TBD Voelker, Olivine 95.49 02/06/95 Warren, Frank Slip & fall on loose gravel. 01/22/95 Kirschenman, Mark Sewer back up. 02/13/95 Clm't veh. Harrell, Sarah hit by transit bus. 67.16 729.89 TBD 02/20/95 Backes, Krystal & Bradley TBD Sewer back up. 02/23/95 Rodriguez, Karen Sewer back up. 01/29/95 Hughes, Tom & Shirley Sewer back up. 01/10/95 U S West Comm. Crew dmg'd line. 218.64 243.32 63.49 CNP CNP CNP 764.89 CNP 3,675.38 CNP CNP 63.49 Date Closed 03/30/95 02/27/95 03/31/95 03/23/95 03/23/95 02/27/95 04/14/95 05/30/95 03/31/95 03/31/95 04/14/95 05/30/95 06/22/95 06/22/95 05/30/95 06/02/95 Date of Loss and Description CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIMS REPORT 1/01/95 THROUGH 12/31/95 PAGE 2 Claimant Amount Claimed 01/04/95 U S West Comm. Garb. truck hit pedestal dm'g to line. 03/02/95 Taylor, Therese Trip & fall uneven curb. 03/08/95 Keller, Kymberly Sewer back up. 03/07/95 Sanchez, Betty Slip/fall on bus steps. 03/15/95 Maldonado, Teresa Sewer back up. 03/15/95 Sewer back up. Lea, Bill & Shylia 85.69 199.95 3,501.91 219.07 TBD 336.57 03/18/95 Franklin, Colette 120.85 Sewer back up. 01/21/95 Brown, Dolphus & Shirley795.71 Sewer back up. 04/30/95 Layne, James & Juanita TBD Sewer back up. 05/03/95 Hoffman, Kristine 1,072.20 City vehicle backed into claimants vehicle. 03/10/95 Titus, James M.H. 56.00 Yakima Police Department lost: knife belonging 05/03/95 Sewer back up. 03/30/95 Sewer back up. Dahlke, Doug 151.06 Kaps, Gary & Sandra 249.25 05/15/95 Rinehart, Wanda 350.00 Vehicle radiator punc. / deep crack in road. 05/15/95 Wilmoth, Jason TBD Claimant hit pothole damaged vehicle / tire. 05/08/95 Hays, Virginia Tree branch hit & broke windshield -- 04/29/95 Lemon, Doug Sewer back up. 387.89 claimant 89.02 Amount Paid or Denied Date Closed CNP 06/02/95 CNP 05/30/95 CNP 05/02/95 CNP 06/22/95 CNP 09/07/95 CNP 06/13/95 CNP 06/22/95 CNP 06/22/95 CNP 09/07/95 1,258.25 06/28/95 56.00 09/07/95 to claimant. CNP 09/07/95 CNP 09/07/95 CNP 07/31/95 157.69 07/07/95 344.24 07/31/95 vehicle. CNP 07/31/95 Date of Loss and Description CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIMS REPORT 1/01/95 THROUGH 12/31/95 PAGE 3 Claimant Amount Claimed 05/26/95 Wilbur, Frank 178.03 Water main broke / damaged claimants washer. Amount Paid or Denied Date Closed 178.03 07/31/95 05/23/95 Russell's Landscaping 393.84 393.84 07/31/95 City line broke. 04/17/95 Lewis, Florence 142.97 CNP 09/07/95 Sewer back up. 03/10/95 Morehoue, Carie 1,049.26 CNP 09/07/95 Neg.by City blocked drain water over road caused damage to clm'ts veh. 02/4&5/95 Wibberding, Gary & Bonnie 2,850.00 2,850.93 11/20/95 Sewer back up. 06/07/95 Sewer back up. 05/26/95 Copeland -Kelly, Chastity TBD Police car hit claimant's vehicle, claimant injured. 06/12/95 Haley, Christine 1,533.62 1,501.32 City vehicle throwing rocks from tires/ damaged clm't veh. 06/06/95 Waggoner, Kathy & Wayne 269.75 269.75 Employee w/ blower - rocks broke claimant's windshield. Strahsburg, Betty 206.00 02/06/95 Boyer/Grange YPD backed into claimant. 06/16/95 Hernandez, Carlos, Vehicle accident w/ police car. 06/19 & 22/95 Velikanje, Moore City cut on claimants trees. 1,065.00 Luz TBD 809.25 06/28/95 Dr. Harold McCartney 116.42 Claimants tires clogged w/ fresh oil/tar. 06/27/95 Gordon Wonder 258.96 Tires damaged by hot asphalt. 06/15/95 Many, Alice TBD Clean mud/tar from vehicle. 532.65 11,329.50 Claim W/D 116.48 258.96 CNP CNP CNP )6/23/95 Jacoby, Jerry 478.26 Work by city crew caused claimant coupler to break. 07/12/95 Winter, Brian TBD Hydrant left leaking, water damage to residence. 09/07/95 behind it. 09/07/95 11/08/95 08/30/95 09/15/95 09/29/95 10/30/95 0"9/07/95 09/07/95 Date of Loss and Description CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIMS REPORT 1/01/95 THROUGH 12/31/95 PAGE 4 Claimant Amount Amount Paid Date Claimed or Denied Closed 07/24/95 Murrell, Richard TBD 809.35 10/20/95 Claimants garage flooded/fire hydrant opened. 07/22/95 Novobielski, Deanna 60.96 60.96 10/25/95 Window broken by golf ball/Fisher Park. 06/26/95 Wielkiewicz, Kathy 98.00 58.27 11/28/95 Rusty water damaged claimants clothing. 07/21/95 Shirts, Shirley 50.00 50.00 09/29/95 PD assist damage lock claimants vehicle. 07/26/95 Fields, Dorothy TBD CNP 10/27/95 Sewer backup. 07/27/95 Bennett, Bill TBD 2,310.79 12/12/95 Sewer backup. 07/27/95 Olden, Susan TBD 1,270.55 12/12/95 Sewer backup. 06/27/95 Milum,Roland/Bonnie 674.37 CNP 10/30/95 Police broke door - serving warrant. 07/01/95 Derrick, Terri 65.00 56.00 10/30/95 Claimant stepped in fresh asphalt damage shoes. 01/07/95 Swafford, Albert 7,500.00 Passenger in bus/thrown from seat when bus hit curb. 01/07/95 SAA Owens, George 7,500.00 07/30/95 Sandoval, Arturo TBD CNP 10/30/95 Door damaged by police. 08/04/95 Ramirez,Maria/Chldrn TBD CNP 10/11/95 Transit bus stopped suddenly claimants injured. 08/07/95 Golden Villa(Ann Storm)5.38 5.38 10/09/95 Flood light broken under Flag by fire fighter. 08/05/95 Bohn, David E. TBD 100.00 10/27/95 Errant golfball broke window claimant vehicle. 07/11/95 Ramerman, George 100.00 CNP 10/27/95 Broken water line. CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIMS REPORT 1/01/95 THROUGH 12/31/95 PAGE 5 Date of Loss and Amount Amount Paid Date Description Claimant Claimed or Denied Closed 08/04/95 Tatro, David Lee TBD 500.00 10/27/95 Passenger injured when bus hit a car. 07/27/95 Quality Hay Co. 1,050.00 CNP 11/22/95 Fuel tank damaged by worn out manhole cover. 08/16/95 Tamez,Frank 237.38 237.38 10/11/95 City failed to notify Tow Co. re R/0 of veh. impounded. 06/14/95 Pacific Power & Light1,668.86 Backhoe struck pole / pole replaced. 08/04/95 Fortier, Henry Jr. 1,561.96 CNP 10/27/95 Sewer back up. 08/23/95 Flores, Frank TBD CNP 10/27/95 Veh. tossed rock, shattered backglass, clm't veh. 08/25/95 Hogan, James S. 250.00 CNP 10/27/95 Claimant w/s broken claim for his deductible. 07/09/95 Wentz, Juanita 3,038.85 CNP 11/27/95 Sewer Backup. 06/01/95 Eddy, J. Michael 350.00 REOPENED Claimants mower damaged mowing on city property. 08/04/95 Gutierrez, Cornelio TBD City bus hit claimant veh. claimant injured. 09/10/95 Fouts, Jack 388.84 Errant golfball broke w/s. 08/31/95 US West Comm. 241.49 City crew cut cable. 09/15/95 Meerdink, Lawrence 70.00 Garbage truck ran over evergreen tree. 09/20/95 Hattrup, Cheryl TBD Collision w/ fire truck. 100.00 11/27/95 CNP 11/08/95 907.16 10/25/95 Date of Loss and Description CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIMS REPORT 1/01/95 THROUGH 12/31/95 PAGE 6 Claimant Amount Amount Paid Claimed or Dentgc3 06/23/95 Reese, Paul 1,911.17 Claimant opened car door of parked veh., hit by bus. 09/23/95 Nelson, Roger Sewer back up. & Karen 431.60 09/20/95 Reyes, Miguel Police care and claimant collided. 09/01/95 Thompson, Ron E. Claimant hit head on prune tree limb. 10/03/95 Murphy, Mildred Trip and fall rough cement sidewalk. Date Closed Denied 11/27/95 4,500.00+ 4,150.00 12/04/95 3,000.00 194.87 200.00 12/28/95 1,618.32 12/28/95 331.79 12/12/95 10/26/95 Jaquins, Joseph 2,606.68 City vehicle backed into claimant (H&R). 10/29/95 Sewer back 10/29/95 Sewer back 11/02/95 W/S broken Terk, Cecil up. DeBlasio, Jeff up. Sinnes, Betty J. by rock from street sweeper. 10/28/95 Watkins, Theodore Claimant damaged tire / glass on street. 07/27/95 Sewer back up. Simison, 01/19/95 Wangler, Sewer back up. 11/07/95 Wangler, Sewer back up. Eric & Eugene Eugene Pam & Patricia & Patricia TBD TBD TBD 55.86 52.50 379.53+ 17.26+ 09/20/95 Lopez -Reyes, Ramon TBD Inj. when IV collided w/ claimants vehicle. 09/20/95 Reyes, Oscar(Minor) TBD SAA (Mother) 09/20/95 Herrera, Victoria Salazar TBD SAA CNP 12/17/95 12/20/95 49.26 CITY OF YAKIMA CLAIMS REPORT 1/01/95 THROUGH 12/31/95 PAGE 7 Date of Loss and Amount Amount Paid Date Description Claimant Claimed or Denied Closed (Minor) 09/28/95 Rosales, Johnathan TBD Claimant struck by city vehicle. 11/27/95 Steen, Eric & Gina 221.41 CNP 12/20/95 RF tire damaged due to 5" hole in road. 10/12/95 Isaacson, Mirtie & Jim TBD Trip & fall. 11/13/95 James Obert TBD Sewer back up. 09/22/95 Farmer's Ins./Fig Leasing 448.26 Auto acc'd subro. 12/08/95 Lamb, George & Yolanda 50.71 Sewer back up. 12/03/95 Wesner, Tina 60.00 )mg'd claimant vehicle when assisting w/ lockout. 11/15/95 Vincent, Max 1,100.91 City failed to locate leak in water line. TOTAL 76,979.22 27,225.42 The description columns shows what has been alleged by the claimant and it is not necessarily what happened. CNP = Closed No Payment 12/31/95 LISTING OF CLOSED CLAIMS FOR THE CITY OF YAKIMA FROM THE RECORDS OF ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC. FOR THE PERIOD OF 10/01/95 TO 12/31/95 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT PAID CTY94124 10/04/95 10/29/94 POTTENGER, KENNETH 960.84 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95070 10/04/95 08/07/95 GOLDEN VILLA (ANN STORM) 5.38 BROKER FLOOD BULB. CTY95069 10/10/95 08/04/95 RAMIREZ, MARIA ELENA 0.00 CLAIMANT INJURED ON BUS. CTY94073 10/18/95 07/06/94 CARSON, TYLER (MINOR) 0.00 CLAIMANT FELL IN MANHOLE. CTY95057 10/18/95 07/24/95 MURRELL, RICHARD & JOANNE 809.35 FIRE HYDRANT FLOODED GARAGE. CTY95075 10/18/95 08/16/95 TAMEZ DBA THE AUTO EXCHANGE 237.38 FAILURE TO NOTIFY TOW CO. CTY95080 10/18/95 12/01/94 PERCIVAL LATERAL, INC. 0.00 DAMAGE TO IRRIGATION LINE. .:TY95052 10/26/95 06/08/95 MANY, ALICE 0.00 TAR ON CLAIMANTS VEHICLE. CTY95058 10/26/95 07/22/95 NOVOBIELSKI, DENNA 60.96 GOLF BALL BROKE WINDOW. CTY95060 10/26/95 06/27/95 MILUM, ROLAND & BONNIE 0.00 POLICE DAMAGED DOOR. CTY95063 10/26/95 07/26/95 FIELDS, DOROTHY 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95066 10/26/95 07/30/95 SANDOVAL, ARTURO V. 0.00 POLICE DAMAGED DOOR. CTY95071 10/26/95 08/05/95 BOHN, DAVID & LORI 100.00 GOLF BALL BROKE VEHICLE WINDOW. CTY95072 10/26/95 07/11/95 RAMERMAN, GEORGE & PHYLLIS 0.00 BROKEN WATER LINE. CTY95073 10/26/95 08/04/95 TATRO, DAVID LEE 500.00 BUS PASSENGER INJURED. CTY95077 10/26/95 08/04/95 FORTIER, HENRY JR. 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95078 10/26/95 08/23/95 FLORES, FRANK 0.00 GRAVEL BROKE VEHICLE WINDOW. CTY95081 10/26/95 08/25/95 HOGAN, JAMES S. 0.00 GRAVEL BROKE WINDSHIELD. LISTING OF CLOSED CLAIMS FOR THE CITY OF YAKIMA FROM THE RECORDS OF ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC. FOR THE PERIOD OF 10/01/95 TO 12/31/95 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT CTY95089 10/26/95 09/20/95 HATTRUP, CHERYL A FIRE TRUCK HIT ' B' . CTY95038 11/06/95 02/06/95 GRANGE INS. (FOR A. BOYER) Y.P.D. BACKED INTO ANOTHER CAR. CTY95088 11/06/95 09/15/95 MEERDINK, LAWRENCE & CATHY GARBAGE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANTS TREE. CTY95065 11/07/95 06/30/95 DERRICK, PAUL & TERRI ASPHALT DAMAGED SHOES. CTY95019 11/10/95 12/07/94 PALMER, EDWIN & LEONA DUMP TRUCK HIT CLAIMANTS VEHICLE. CTY95044 11/17/95 02/04/95 WIBBERDING, GARY & BONNIE SEWER BACKUP. CTY95064 11/21/95 06/26/95 RUST BUILDUP IN WATER LINE. CTY95074 11/21/95 07/27/95 MANHOLE COVER DAMAGED VEHICLE. CTY95082 11/21/95 07/09/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95085 11/21/95 09/10/95 GOLF BALL BROKE WINDSHIELD. CTY95090 11/2:L/95 09/23/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95061 12/0:1/95 07/27/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95092 12/01/95 09/20/95 'A' FAILED TO YIELD TO ' B' . CTY95095 12/05/95 10/29/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95059 12/11/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95101 12/15/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95100 12/18/95 SEWER PLUG. 07/27/95 01/19/95 11/07/95 WIEKIEWICZ, KATHY QUALITY HAY CO. (VON ESSEN) WENTZ, JUANITA FOUTS, JACK W. ROGER & KAREN NELSON BENNETT, BILL & MARIDEAN REYES, MIGUEL TERK, CECIL & JANE OLDEN, SUSAN & CARL WANGLER, EUGENE & PATRICIA WANGLER, EUGENE & PATRICIA PA]:D 907.16 532.65 0.00 56.00 11,124.11 2,850.93 58.27 0.00 0.00 100.00 0.00 2,310.79 4,150.00 331.79 1,270.55 46.92 0.00 LISTING OF CLOSED CLAIMS FOR THE CITY OF YAKIMA FROM THE RECORDS OF ZAREMBA CLAIMS SERVICE, INC. FOR THE PERIOD OF 10/01/95 TO 12/31/95 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT PAID CTY95106 12/18/95 11/27/95 STEEN, ERIC P. & GINA 0.00 WHEEL DAMAGE FROM DEEP HOLE. CTY95093 12/28/95 10/03/95 MURPHY, MILDRED 200.00 TRIPPED ON BROKEN CEMENT. CTY95094 12/28/95 10/26/95 JAQUINS, JOSEPH & PATRICIA 1,618.32 'A' BACKED INTO ' B' . ADDITIONAL NOT ON ZAREMBA REPORT LE240298 10/19/95 WILBANKS, SHEILA & LINDSAY 40,000.00 LE240282 09/25/95 LAMPERS CONSTRUCTION 35,000.00 LE240293 10/18/95 DELLINGER, KEVIN 16,335.00 CITY OF YAKIMA REPORT OF CLOSED CLAIMS FOR THE PERIOD OF JANUARY 1, 1995 TO DECEMBER 31, 1995 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CTY94122 01/11/95 11/03/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY94118 01/19/95 10/30/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY94121 01/19/95 10/30/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY94128 01/25/95 12/15/94 CITY TRUCK BACKED INTO VEHICLE. CTY92050 02/02/95 07/13/89 TRAFFIC SIGN NOT SEEN. CTY94125 02/22/95 10/26/94 SEWER BACKUP. CLAIMANT BI -MART STORE #605 PAID $ 137.03 MARLER, PHIL & DUNKEL, LEIGH 1,596.00 BROWN, SCOTT & SHELLY SHOCKLEY, WESLEY M. SCOTT OSBORNE MATA, RAMON & VIRGINIA CTY94135 02/22/95 01/1.5/95 CLARK, MARILYN COLLISION W/ :POLICE CAR. CTY94131 02/23/95 01/10/95 PRICE, BERTHA POTHOLE DAMAGE CLAIMANT VEHICLE. CTY94134 02/23/95 12/13/94 CARR, NOAMA J. TRIP AND FALL. CTY94127 02/28/95 12/27/94 KEITH, ROYAL & KAY WATER LINE BROKE. CTY95005 03/:14/95 01/20/95 CHAMPIE, CARLOS ALAN WATER METER TURNED ON. CTY95005 03/14/95 02/06/95 WARREN, FRANK V. FELL ON SIDEWALK. CTY91011 03/20/95 09/02/89 NICOLOV MARVIN ALLEGED FALSE ARREST. CTY94133 03/21/95 01/05/95 PACHECO, CLARA SLIP AND FALL ON CITY BUS. CTY94137 03/21/95 01/10/95 MILLER, KRISTEN D. POTHOLE DAMAGED CLAIMANTS VEHICLE. CTY94130 03/28/95 0:1/09/95 MURPHY, VICTORIA TRIP AND FALL. 1,368.97 0.00 62,500.00 787.02 53.75. 0.00 0.00 2,948.43 0.00 0.00 1,200.00 0.00 0.0('- 189.96 CITY OF YAKIMA REPORT OF CLOSED CLAIMS FOR THE PERIOD OF JANUARY 1, 1995 TO DECEMBER 31, 1995 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT CTY94078 03/31/95 07/29/94 KELLEY, CARRIE A. MANHOLE LID NOT CLOSED. CTY94085 03/31/95 07/16/94 CLAIMANT INJURED IN GUTTER. CTY94112 03/31/95 02/11/94 POLICE MISTREATMENT ALLEGED. CTY94114 03/31/95 10/05/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY94120 03/31/95 09/11/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY94123 03/31/95 11/30/94 CITY VEHICLE HIT CLAIMANTS CAR. CTY94126 03/31/95 08/01/94 NOT PAID BY POLICE DEPT. CTY94129 03/31/95 12/28/94 CLAIMANT BROKE WATCH (FIREMAN). CTY94132 03/31/95 01/12/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95002 04/04/95 12/10/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY94136 04/13/95 01/07/95 CLAIMANT INJURED ON BUS. CTY95006 04/13/95 SEWER BACKUP. CTY93093 04/25/95 01/22/95 11/20/93 COLLISION W/ POLICE CAR. CTY95039 05/01/95 11/01/93 FOR RECORD ONLY, SETTLEMENT OF. CTY95016 05/17/95 11/01/94 300PR CBL HIT DURING WATER EXCA. CTY92107 05/19/95 12/10/92 FALL ON CITY BUS. KELLER, TERRY JOE MILLER, MELVIN (RAMOS) ARRELLANO, GRACIELA KRIER, PETER & MARGARET JACKSON, DAVID B. BALMES, TAMMY AHMANN, GREGORY L'ESPERANCE, CARL SHEPLER, VALERIE & JOEL STERLING, REGINA G. KIRSCHENMANN, MARK & TONI HOWELL, SARA BEESON (FIRE CHIEF) US WEST COMMUNICATIONS DEBI L. CAMERON PAID $ 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 374.51 1,744.60 764.89 19,577.07 38,500.00 290.31 0.00 CITY OF YAKIMA SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS PERIOD OF JANUARY 1, 1995 TU DECEMBER 31, 1995 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT PAID CTY95003 05/26/95 01/20/95 VOELKER, OLIVINE 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95007 05/26/95 02/13/95 HARRELL, SARAH & DANIEL 0.00 BUS HIT SIDE OF CLAIMANTS VEHICLE. CTY95010 05/26/95 07/27/94 WOMEN'S CENTURY CLUB 0.00 INSPCT. APPOVED BAD ROOFING JOB. CTY95013 05/26/95 01/29/95 HUGHES, TOM & SHIRLEY 0.00 SEWER BAKCUP. CTY95014 05/26/95 03/02/95 TAYLOR, THERESE J. 0.00 TRIP AND FALL. CTY95011 06/01/95 01/10/95 US WEST COMMUNICATIONS 63.49 WATER DEPT. HIT CABLE. CTY95012 06/01/95 01/04/95 US WEST COMMUNICATIONS 0.00 GARBAGE TRUCK HIT PHONE TRUCK. CTY95008 06/20/95 02/20/95 BACKES, KRYSTAL & BRADLEY 3,675.38 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95009 06/20/95 02/23/95 RODRIGUEZ, KAREN 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95018 06/20/95 10/18/94 LEAVITT, WAYNE G. 0.00 MANHOLE OPEN, DAMAGE TO CAR. CTY95020 06/20/95 03/09/95 SANCHEZ, BETTY 0.00 CLAIMANT FELL GETTING OFF BUS. CTY95023 06/20/95 03/18/95 FRANKLIN, COLETTE M. 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95026 06/20/95 01/21/95 BROWN, DOLPHUS & SHIRLEY 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95028 06/27/95 05/03/95 HOFFMAN, KRISTINE 1,258.25 VEHICLE HIT BY CITY DUMP TRUCK. CTY94102 06/28/95 09/16/94 VINEYARD, BILLY J. 5,409.72 BUS DRIVER FAILED TO STOP. CTY95036 07/05/95 05/15/95 WILMOTH, JASON 157.69 VEHICLE DAMAGED BY POTHOLE. CTY95024 07/07/95 10/01/94 BRAUN, ROBERT & SUSAN 97.60 DAMAGE TO SPRINKLER LINE. CITY OF YAKIMA SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS PERIOD OF JANUARY 1, 1995 TO DECEMBER 31, 1995 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT PAID CTY95015 07/26/95 06/06/89 SMITH, RICHARD C. FOR RECORD ONLY/SEWER BACKUP. CTY95022 07/26/95 03/15/95 LEA, BILL & SHYLLA SEWER LINE DAMAGE BY WATER DEPT. CTY95032 07/26/95 05/15/95 RINEHART, WANDA J. CLAIMANT VEHICLE DAMAGED BY TRENCH. CTY95035 07/26/95 05/08/95 HAYS, VIRGINIA TREE BRANCH DAMAGE VEHCLE. CTY95037 07/26/95 04/29/95 LEMON, DOUG SEWER BACKUP. CTY95040 07/26/95 05/23/95 RUSSELL'S LANDSCAPING BREAK IN IRRIGATION PIPE. CTY95041 07/26/95 05/26/95 WILBUR, FRANK IRRIGATION LINE BROKE. CTY95049 08/28/95 06/19/95 VELIKANJE, MOORE & SHORE TREES CUT DOWN ON CLAIMANTS PROPERTY. CTY95017 09/06/95 03/08/95 KELLER, KYMBERLY SEWER BACKUP. CTY95021 09/06/95 03/15/95 MALDONADO, TERESA SEWER BACKUP. CTY95027 09/06/95 04/30/95 LAYNE, JAMES & JUANITA SEWER BACKUP. CTY95029 09/06/95 10/03/93 ROWLAND, GREGORY MARK CONFISCATED MONEY NOT RETURNED. CTY95030 09/06/95 03/10/95 TITUS, JAMES M.H. CONFISCATED KNIFE NOT RETURNED. CTY95031 09/06/95 05/03/95 DAHLKE, DOUG & CATHERINE SEWER BACKUP. CTY95033 09/06/95 03/30/95 KAPS, GARY & SANDRA SEWER BACKUP. CTY95034 09/06/95 01/01/93 KAPS, GARY & SANDRA SEWER BACKUPS THRU 03/30/95. CTY95042 09/06/95 04/17/95 LEWIS, FLORENCE SEWER BACKUP. 0.00 0.00 0.00 344.24 0.00 393.84 178.03 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 56.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 CITY OF YAKIMA SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS PERIOD OF JANUARY 1, 1995 TO DECEMBER 31, 1995 ZCS FILE CLOSED CTY95043 09/06/95 VEHICLE DAMAGED. CTY95047 09/06/95 D/LOSS CLAIMANT 03/10/95 06/06/95 GRAVEL DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE CTY95048 09/06/95 06/12/95 GRAVEL DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE. CTY95055 09/06/95 06/23/95 WATER COUPLING SPLIT. CTY95056 09/06/95 07/12/95 WATER LEAK INTO BASEMENT. CTY94119 09/13/95 11/09/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95051 09/13/95 06/29/95 TAR DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE. CTY94091 09/27/95 08/05/94 BUS REARENDED CAR. CTY95053 09/27/95 06/27/95 TAR DAMAGED CLAIMANT VEHICLE. CTY95062 09/27/95 07/21/95 POLICE DAMAGED VEHICLE DOOR. CTY94124 10/04/95 10/29/94 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95070 10/04/95 08/07/95 BROKER FLOOD BULB. CTY95069 10/10/95 08/04/95 CLAIMANT INJURED ON BUS. CTY94073 10/18/95 07/06/94 CLAIMANT FELL IN MANHOLE. CTY95057 10/18/95 07/24/95 FIRE HYDRANT FLOODED GARAGE. CTY95075 10/18/95 08/16/95 FAILURE TO NOTIFY TOW CO. CTY95080 10/18/95 12/01/94 DAMAGE TO IRRIGATION LINE. MOREHOUSE, CARIE WAGGONER, KATHEY HALEY, CHRISTINE PAID 0.00 & WAYNE 269.75 14 501.32 JOCOBY, JERRY 0.00 WINTER, BRIAN & TAMMY 0.00 MACLEAN, HAROLD & JAKKI 14,814.25 MCCARTNEY, HAROLD H. M.D. 116.48 JOLY, KENT L. 1,863.0C WONDER, GORDON 258.96 SHIRTS, SHIRLEY 50.00 POTTENGER, KENNETH 960.84 GOLDEN VILLA (ANN STORM) 5.38 RAMIREZ, MARIA ELENA 0.00 CARSON, TYLER (MINOR) 0.00 MURRELL, RICHARD & JOANNE 809.35 TAMEZ DBA THE AUTO EXCHANGE 237.38 PERCIVAL LATERAL, INC. 0.00 CITY OF YAKIMA SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS PERIOD OF JANUARY 1, 1995 TO DECEMBER 31, 1995 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT PAID CTY95052 10/26/95 06/08/95 TAR ON CLAIMANTS VEHICLE. MANY, ALICE 0.00 CTY95058 10/26/95 07/22/95 NOVOBIELSKI, DENNA 60.96 GOLF BALL BROKE WINDOW. CTY95060 10/26/95 06/27/95 MILUM, ROLAND & BONNIE 0.00 POLICE DAMAGED DOOR. CTY95063 10/26/95 07/26/95 FIELDS, DOROTHY 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95066 10/26/95 07/30/95 SANDOVAL, ARTURO V. 0.00 POLICE DAMAGED DOOR. CTY95071 10/26/95 08/05/95 BOHN, DAVID & LORI 100.00 GOLF BALL BROKE VEHICLE WINDOW. CTY95072 10/26/95 07/11/95 RAMERMAN, GEORGE & PHYLLIS 0.00 BROKEN WATER LINE. CTY95073 10/26/95 08/04/95 TATRO, DAVID LEE 500.00 BUS PASSENGER INJURED. CTY95077 10/26/95 08/04/95 FORTIER, HENRY JR. 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95078 10/26/95 08/23/95 FLORES, FRANK 0.00 GRAVEL BROKE VEHICLE WINDOW. CTY95081 10/26/95 08/25/95 HOGAN, JAMES S. 0.00 GRAVEL BROKE WINDSHIELD. CTY95089 10/26/95 09/20/95 HATTRUP, CHERYL A 907.16 FIRE TRUCK HIT 'B'. CTY95038 11/06/95 02/06/95 GRANGE INS. (FOR A. BOYER) 532.65 Y.P.D. BACKED INTO ANOTHER CAR. CTY95088 11/06/95 09/15/95 MEERDINK, LAWRENCE & CATHY 0.00 GARBAGE TRUCK DAMAGED CLAIMANTS TREE. CTY95065 11/07/95 06/30/95 DERRICK, PAUL & TERRI 56.00 ASPHALT DAMAGED SHOES. CTY95019 11/10/95 12/07/94 PALMER, EDWIN & LEONA 11,124.11 DUMP TRUCK HIT CLAIMANTS VEHICLE. CTY95044 11/17/95 02/04/95 WIBBERDING, GARY & BONNIE 2,850.93 SEWER BACKUP. CITY OF YAKIMA SUMMARY OF THIRD PARTY CLAIMS BY TYPE OF LOSS PERIOD OF JANUARY 1, 1995 TO DECEMBER 31, 1995 ZCS FILE CLOSED D/LOSS CLAIMANT PAID CTY95064 11/21/95 06/26/95 RUST BUILDUP IN WATER LINE. WIEKIEWICZ, KATHY 58.27 CTY95074 11/21/95 07/27/95 QUALITY HAY CO. (VON ESSEN) 0.00 MANHOLE COVER DAMAGED VEHICLE. CTY95082 11/21/95 07/09/95 WENTZ, JUANITA 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95085 11/21/95 09/10/95 FOUTS, JACK W. 100.00 GOLF BALL BROKE WINDSHIELD. CTY95090 11/21/95 09/23/95 ROGER & KAREN NELSON 0.00 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95061 12/01/95 07/27/95 BENNETT, BILL & MARIDEAN 2,310.79 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95092 12/01/95 09/20/95 REYES, MIGUEL 4,150.00 'A' FAILED TO YIELD TO ' B' . CTY95095 12/05/95 10/29/95 TERK, CECIL & JANE 331.79 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95059 12/11/95 07/27/95 OLDEN, SUSAN & CARL 1,270.55 SEWER BACKUP. CTY951.01 12/15/95 01/19/95 WANGLER, EUGENE & PATRICIA 46.92 SEWER BACKUP. CTY95100 12/18/95 11/07/95 WANGLER, EUGENE & PATRICIA 0.00 SEWER PLUG. CTY95106 12/18/95 11/27/95 STEEN, ERIC P. & GINA. 0.00 WHEEL DAMAGE FROM DEEP HOLE. CTY95093 12/28/95 10/03/95 MURPHY, MILDRED 200.00 TRIPPED ON BROKEN CEMENT. CTY95094 12/28/95 10/26/95 JAQUINS, JOSEPH & PATRICIA 1,618.32 'A' BACKED INTO ' B' . ***TOTAL*** 190,771.94