The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About06/16/2009 07 Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One; Yakima Register of Historic Places BUSINESS OF THE CITY COUNCIL III YAKIMA, WASHINGTON AGENDA STATEMENT • Item No. 7 For Meeting of June 16, 2009 ITEM TITLE: Closed Record Public Hearing and consideration of a Resolution initiating the designation of the Barge - Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. SUBMITTED BY: William R. Cook Director of Community and Economic'Development CONTACT PERSON/TELEPHONE: Vaughn McBride, Associate Planner (576 -6315) SUMMARY EXPLANATION: The Barge - Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One nomination meets Criteria 1 through 5 for designation to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. On May 28, 2009 the Historic Preservation Commission conducted an open record public hearing to review the nomination application submitted by the Barge - Chestnut Neighborhood Association to place the Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One, 0 located in the vicinity east of 32 Avenue, west of 24"' Avenue, south of Barge Street and north of Walnut Street on the Yakima Register of Historic Places. Based upon a review of the complete application, site visit, discussions with the applicant/agent, staff Report of Findings, exhibits, testimony and other evidence presented at the open record public hearing the Historic Preservation Commission issued a written recommendation for approval of this application on May 28, 2009. Resolution X Ordinance_ Contract _ Other Funding Source APPROVAL FOR SUBMITTAL: \� -� City Manager STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the Historic Preservation Commission's recommendation. BOARD RECOMMENDATION: Historic Preservation Commission recommends approval of the nomination of the Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. COUNCIL ACTION: III �►.r -. Ti 7 • �. RESOLUTION NO. R 2009- _ • A RESOLUTION related to Historic Preservation, initiating the designation of the Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One under • the provisions of Yakima Municipal Code 11.62.045 Yakima Register of Historic Places WHEREAS, the City of Yakima desires to establish the "Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" under the provisions of Yakima Municipal Code 11.62.045; and WHEREAS, the "Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" is generally described as the properties that are located within the following boundary: north of West Chestnut Avenue between 31st Avenue and 32nd Avenue, then east of 32 Avenue between West Chestnut Avenue and Barge Avenue, then south of Barge Avenue between 24th and 32nd Avenue, then west of 24th Avenue between Barge Avenue and West Chestnut Avenue, then north of Chestnut Avenue between 24th Avenue and 26th Avenue, then west of 26th Avenue between Chestnut Avenue and Walnut Street ; then north of Walnut Street between 26th Avenue and 28th Avenue, then properties along both sides of South 28th Avenue between Walnut Street and West Chestnut,. excluding Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital's parcel number. 181323 -33438 at the northwest corner of Walnut Street South 28th Avenue, and the properties located along the south frontage of West Chestnut . Avenue between 28th Avenue and 31st Avenue (see Attachment "A ", Map of Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One); and WHEREAS, residents of the proposed Historic District submitted a petition signed by a majority of the properties within the limits of the district; and WHEREAS, the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission reviewed the resident petition and determined that the area contains a significant resource of buildings with architectural qualities which exemplify Yakima's cultural, economic and distinctive history; • and conducted a public hearing on May 28, .2009 to receive testimony regarding the formation of the Historic District and, WHEREAS, the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission at the conclusion of the public hearing on May 28, 2009 voted to approve the formation of the Historic District and Barge Chestnut Neighborhood Area Phase One Resolution Pagel of 2 adopted Findings of Fact to support the recommendation that the district be established in • consideration of the requirements of YMC 11.62.045, now, therefore BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF YAKIMA: The City of Yakima hereby designates the "Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" as a Local Historic District in the Yakima Register of Historic Places under the provisions of the Yakima Municipal Code 11.62.045 ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this day of June, 2009. ATTEST: Dave Edler, Mayor City Clerk Barge Chestnut Neighborhood Area Phase One Resolution Page 2 of 2 0 ,inch = 300 feet Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historical District: Phase One )7 3205 112 .._ ■ ■,, ..v N N N ..w• 114 116 .... 115 O 120 113 116 111 114 113 114 113 115 113 112 N M . o , m 0 N 3N II CANTE' - • 112 111 112 W 113 110 111 114 EL ANOR ST 3204 J 109 112 111 112 � 111 111 2 w '>' 111 2808 �• 109 J 112 108 107 110 w 107 108 Q 109 0 0 2812 112 109 110 < 109 110 109 108 < 107 Q 110 0 108 > 107 '= 107 105 Q 1 106 105 108 106 i. 107 1 108 M $ 106 10.5 rp .-1 106 N N N N 104 % 103 104 103 104 N 105 N 105 Q 103 106 LEY N N ° n- 104 3011 3009 M 103 om $ § m 7 ,_ r 104 104 Z 104 1° 3201 j� 101 102 M 102 z 101 " N N N 2 2807 102 2701 fO ` ,P 102 103 2307 2301 Z 2709 " 101 102 101 102 " % RAW= VT-- (.4 m 8 10 �I;� � N N � 28 / r i "'Too, rior /' n prr - 2302 %/ % /. %♦ /. I / I / , r� r'I/ : + % A ` � ,17 r r A ,a , �. 4 3209 2 J J _ _ FA l JI �� .� I 7 :� " 7 /� �� PIMP, �,� / I �dA 30 2301 � 1��.i I/. // �I/.II. /. I. % / � ►I/ � � �� 0 `� o 2 / / /:� i r � re • 50 N N 320E 2 rovirr.. JI I r � ' rt%�y�, f �J '� 4 r . 7 -67 1 ,3 , 7 0 / r � s ►/ /% �! %4� 2402 `r <n 6 ' % // �__I_I ∎ /// r Ah , / I/. el 4 A A j A r4 - $ 2302 � � , / , ' / , � � I / % I I � � / %I II/ " N N N Al I FY 11 3209 _ / ►�'+ �. 7 �/ / % % % � i �. �/ / / p/ 3203 8 A , � - , F� r ��/ , � ' i r i �� / -- /� �� i A - a , A % I/I m ,T /��' / ' � � I�%r-I� � / t� � v • NA / / 1'0 10 o A .E TNUT 'V � 2311 2307 /. to .n / . A 2810 , � �, / / , ' 204 204 203 7, 204 , �� ^ v , / ' /� �' m 2412 201 23 m m 202 201 ° )102 <� , , P ' Z; //I i/ 202 I / I � / //� % f� 201 ,ag 25oE 2504 q 2402 206 205 206 205 204 205 204 205 E � .�. I � . / " " > 205 w " / /1'/ 205 208 205 208 208 207 208 207 206 207 208 20 204 L>.< 207 Q 207 r �/ ' �� 209 212 209 210 209 210 209 210 209 ► E , , ' 707 2 10 209 2 10 LL 207 208 % % RiII �1� i 209 > z 212 211 212 N 211 , . / ! �J 212 14 211 212 = 211 _ :71.1 .�1�1 \I� �� 1"" 210 216 Homes in Phase I fn 213 �� 214 213 z1s 213 218 z1a co 2 36 Homes are Non - Contributing 213 ' m /„„ " iI r r- o y �� i N 216 215 215 / ��//' N� r �/ �� %/, 1 217 215 216 180 Homes are Contributing 216 (/) 212515 6 N . �,��4 217 // I , �� 1 219 220 Q 2310 83.3 % Contributre to the Historic District 218 217 218 . re % ro ri i rA .7 j ~ 219 216 217 _ 222 F. 222 219 220 218 i // � ' 223 0 221 220 219 Need a Minimum 109 Signature i , l � N zza N 219 AIM AM Target 135 Signatures 222 32 i 225 • 2608 2604 404 qOq aua Rentals of as 5/2007 4C — W N W 403 404 403 405 ° m — f Homes Contributing > (/) > ` 406 W ---g66— 406 auo 71 410 407 408 407 4os H 2906 '�Og - -L ao W 408 QJ - 407 408 410 O 407 409 410 M ti 409 < 410 409 410 409 412 _Cj w 412 411 412 2811 u) 411 412 411 414 411 414 41 i 414 I 411 413 414 413 416 413 416 416 U) A17 a 1111 RESOLUTION NO. R 2009- A RESOLUTION related to Historic Preservation, initiating the designation of the Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One under the provisions of Yakima Municipal Code 11.62.045 Yakima Register of Historic Places WHEREAS, the City of Yakima desires to establish the "Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" under the provisions of Yakima Municipal Code 11.62.045; and WHEREAS, the "Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" is generally described as the properties that are located within the following boundary: north of West Chestnut Avenue between 31 Avenue and 32 Avenue, then east of 32 Avenue between West Chestnut Avenue and Barge Avenue, then south of Barge Avenue between 24 and 32 Avenue, then west of 24 Avenue between Barge Avenue and West Chestnut Avenue, then north of Chestnut Avenue between 24 Avenue and 26 Avenue, then west of 26 Avenue between Chestnut Avenue and Walnut Street ; then north of Walnut Street between 26 Avenue and 28 Avenue, then properties along both sides of North 28 Avenue between Walnut Street and West Chestnut, and the properties located along the south frontage of West Chestnut Avenue between 28 Avenue and 31 Avenue; and WHEREAS, residents of the proposed Historic District submitted a petition signed by a majority of the properties within the limits of the district; and WHEREAS, the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission reviewed the resident petition and determined that the area contains a significant resource of buildings with architectural qualities which exemplify Yakima's cultural, economic and distinctive history; and conducted a public hearing on May 28, 2009 to receive testimony regarding the formation of the Historic District and, WHEREAS, the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission at the conclusion of the public hearing on May 28, 2009 voted to approve the formation of the Historic District and adopted Findings of Fact to support . the recommendation that the district be established in consideration of the requirements of YMC 11.62.045, now, therefore BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF YAKIMA: The City of Yakima hereby designates the "Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" as a Local Historic District in the Yakima Register of Historic Places under the provisions of the Yakima Municipal Code 11.62.045 ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this 16th day of June, 2009. ATTEST: David Edler, Mayor • 'City Clerk Barge Chestnut Neighborhood Area Phase One Resolution Page 1 of 1 BCNA Historical Preservaommittee G 1 inch =3 Phase One Historical District: Phas "Yakima" 1 _ 23 ti. �p ea c -_. - � t 1 - ' rte . _ , F _ TM. - l i. IR ''�' IT'S • T ' - Air,- _ __ at -°- f '.. RI _ i ll 1 � � v - i� If l 0 . III a { 4 I Fes r a _ r i t ..., N j,, y :' � V C' _ s _- — . — 1 i 1 � t r I I - I * v 1/1-4-41- . -- f, T Lii i -.. --, , r _ _ -,. �. - . ,,: _ mot, , . . .,,., . 'b . � � lar - : - t . . ,�- . .. , = , E� _ . � IC N i• ~� ; �° r f . . o . Esc 1[ - i .r i I7I ' E 3 - Ai IF „.- , . , li 4 _.. *Lai r L. i i i O ; , . .- L-r ` 1 jr IMP IC �r i , c 1 _ - r— F . ,... pat, �� E 406 r j , ae, a: e i i .__.„.4,. " l �i..d.e: .. 1 --( .. t - E , 1� I _ 1 ..` :•t, i !f! i i � ._ .e • _ l ' At � � r (( i 1 I t • t rad _ 1 i Yf _ V.I.! • Chapter 11.62 HISTORIC P =ESERW =,TOOlN • ROpIN };.INCE FOR SPECIAL V ';LUATO • N Sections: 11.62.010 Purpose. 11.62.020 Short title. 11.62.025 Applicability. 11.62.030 Definitions. 11.62.040 Yakima historic preservation commission. 11.62.045 Yakima register of historic places. 11.62.050 Review of changes to Yakima register of historic places properties. 11.62.060 Review and monitoring of properties for special property tax valuation. 11.62.010 Propose. The purpose of this chapter is to provide for the identification, evaluation, designation, and protection of designated historic and prehistoric resources within the boundaries of the city of Yakima and preserve and rehabilitate eligible historic properties within the city of Yakima for future generations through special valuation, a property tax incentive, as provided in Chapter 84.26 RCW in order to: A. Safeguard the heritage of Yakima as represented by those buildings, districts, objects, sites and structures which reflect significant elements of Yakima history; B. Foster civic and neighborhood pride in the beauty and accomplishments of the past, and a sense of identity based on Yakima history; • C. Stabilize or improve the aesthetic and economic vitality and values of such sites, improvements and objects; D. Encourage capital investment in the rehabilitation of real property and assist in strategic economic development through the creation of jobs, construction spending and physical improvement within Yakima; E. Promote fundamental growth management principles and the development of sound tools for land use planning, urban design and environmental protections; F. Conserve valuable material and energy resources by ongoing use and maintenance of the existing built environment; and G. Assist, encourage and provide incentives to private owners for preservation, rehabilitation, restoration, redevelopment, and use of historic buildings, districts, objects, sites and structures. (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). 11.62.020 Short tit0e. The following sections shall be known and may be cited as the "historic preservation ordinance of Yakima." (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). 11.62.025 AppOicabiliity. This chapter applies to any property which fall into the following categories: A. Property listed or eligible to be listed on the Yakima historic inventory; B. Property listed or eligible to be listed on the Yakima register of historic places, National Register of Historic Places, or Washington Heritage Register. (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). 11.62.030 Definitions. • The following words and terms when used in this chapter shall mean as follows, unless a different meaning clearly appears from the context: A. "Actual cost of rehabilitation" means costs incurred within twenty -four months 410 prior to the date of application and directly resulting from one or more of the following: 1. Improvements to an existing building located on or within the perimeters of the original structure; or 2. Improvements outside of but directly attached to the original structure which are necessary to make the building fully usable but shall not include rentable /habitable floor space attributable to new construction; or 3. Architectural and engineering services attributable to the design of the improvements; or 4. All costs defined as qualified rehabilitation expenditures for purposes of the federal historic preservation investment tax credit. B. A "building" is a structure constructed by human beings. This includes both residential and nonresidential buildings, main and accessory buildings. C. "Certificate of appropriateness" means the document indicating that the commission has reviewed the proposed changes to a local register property or within a local register historic district and certified the changes as not adversely affecting the historic characteristics of the property which contribute to its designation. D. "Certified local government' or "CLG" means the designation reflecting that the local government has been jointly certified by the State Historic Preservation. Officer and the National Park Service as having established its own historic preservation commission and a program meeting federal and state standards. E. "Class of properties eligible to apply for special valuation in Yakima" means all properties in Yakima listed on the National Register of Historic Places or certified as contributing to a National Register Historic District which have been substantially 110 rehabilitated at a cost and within a time period which meets the requirements set forth in Chapter 84.26 RCW, until the city of Yakima becomes a certified local government (CLG). Once the city of Yakima becomes a CLG, the lass of properties eligible to apply for special valuation in the city of Yakima means only all properties listed on the Yakima and National Registers of Historic Places or properties certified as contributing to a Yakima or National Register Historic District which have been substantially rehabilitated at a cost and within a time period which meets the requirements set forth in Chapter 84.26 RCW. F. "Cost" means the actual cost of rehabilitation, which cost shall be at least twenty - five percent of the assessed valuation of the historic property, exclusive of the assessed value attributable to the land, prior to rehabilitation. G. A "district" is a geographically definable area —urban or rural, small or large, possessing a significant concentration, linkage, or continuity of sites, buildings, structures, and /or objects united by past events or aesthetically by plan or physical development. H. "Emergency repair" means work necessary to prevent destruction or dilapidation of real property or structural appurtenances thereto immediately threatened or damaged by fire, flood, earthquake or other disaster. I. "Historic property" means real property together with improvements thereon, except property listed in a register primarily for objects buried below ground, which is listed in the Yakima register of historic places or on the National Register of Historic Places. J. "Incentives" are such rights or privileges or combination thereof which the Yakima city council, or other local, state, or federal public body or agency, by virtue of applicable present or future legislation, may be authorized to grant or obtain for the owner(s) of 110 register properties. Examples of economic incentives indude but are not limited to tax relief, conditional use permits, rezoning, street vacation, planned unit development, III transfer of development rights, facade easements, gifts, preferential leasing policies, beneficial placement of public improvements or amenities, or the like. K. "Local review board" or "board" used in Chapter 84.26 RCW and Chapter 254-20 WAC for the special valuation of historic properties means the commission created in YMC 11.62.040. L. "National Register of Historic Places" means the national listing of properties significant to our cultural history because of their documented importance to our history, architectural history, engineering, or cultural heritage. M. An "object" is a thing of functional, aes Ii etic, cultural, historical, or scientific value that may be, by nature or design, movable yet related to a specific setting or environment. N. "Ordinary repair and maintenance" means work for which a permit issued by the city of Yakima is not required by law, and where the purpose and effect of such work is to correct any deterioration or decay of or damage to the real property or structure appurtenance therein and to restore the same, as nearly as may be practicable, to the condition prior to the occurrence of such deterioration, decay, or damage. O. "Owner" of property is the fee simple owner of record as exists on the Yakima County assessor's records. P. "Significance" or "significant" used in the context of historic significance means the following: a property with local, state, or national significance is one which helps in the understanding of the history or prehistory of the local area, state, or nation (whichever is applicable) by illuminating the local, statewide, or nationwide impact of the events or persons associated with the property, or its architectural type or style in 0 information potential. The local area can include the city of Yakima, Yakima County, or south central Washington, or a modest geographic or cultural area, such as a neighborhood. Local significance may apply to a property that illustrates a theme that is important to one or more localities, state significance to a theme important to the history of the state, and national significance to property of exceptional value in representing or illustrating an important theme in the history of the nation. Q. A "site" is a place where a significant event or pattern of events occurred. It may be the location of prehistoric or historic occupation or activities that may be marked by physical remains, or it may be the symbolic focus of a significant event or pattern of events that may not have been actively occupied. A site may be the location of ruined or now nonextant building or structure if the location itself possesses historic cultural or archaeological significance. R. "Special valuation for historic properties" or "special valuation" means the local option program which when implemented makes available to property owners a special tax valuation for rehabilitation of historic properties under which the assessed value of an eligible historic property is determined at a rate that excludes, for up to ten years, the actual cost of the rehabilitation. S. A "structure" is a work made up of interdependent and interrelated parts in a definite pattern of organization. Generally constructed by human beings, it is often an engineering project. T. "Waiver of a certificate of appropriateness" or "waiver' means the document indicating that the commission has reviewed the proposed whole or partial demolition of a local register property or in a local register historic district and failing to find altematives to demolition has issued a waiver of a certificate of appropriateness which allows the building or zoning official to issue a permit for demolition. S U. "Washington Heritage Register' means the state listing of properties_significant to the community, state, or nation but which may or may not meet the criteria of the National Register. V. "Washington State Advisory Council's Standards for the Rehabilitation and Maintenance of Historic Properties" or "State Advisory Council's Standards" means the rehabilitation and maintenance standards used by the Yakima historic preservation commission as minimum requirements for determining whether or not an historic property is eligible for special valuation and whether or not the property continues to be eligible for special valuation once it has been so classified. W. "Yakima historic inventory" or °inventory° means the comprehensive inventory of historic and prehistoric resources within the boundaries of Yakima. X. "Yakima historic preservation commission" or commission" means the commission created by YMC 11.62.040. Y. "Yakima register of historic places," "local register," or "register" means the listing of locally designated properties provided for in YMC 11.62.045. (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). 11.62.040 Yakima historic preservation commission. A. Creation and Size. There is hereby established a Yakima historic preservation commission consisting of seven members, as provided in subsection B of this section. Members of the Yakima historic preservation commission shall be appointed by the mayor with the approval of the Yakima city council and shall be residents of the city of Yakima. B. Composition of the Commission. (1) All members of the commission must have a demonstrated interest and competence in historic . preservation, history, urban planning, or architecture and possess qualities of impartiality and broad judgment. (2) The commission shall always include at least three professionals who have 4 10 experience in identifying, evaluating, and protecting historic resources and are selected from among the disciplines of history, architecture, architectural history, landscape architecture, historic preservation, planning, folklore, cultural anthropology, prehistoric and historic archaeology, American studies, curation, traditional building crafts, the practice of historic rehabilitation or restoration, finance and banking, law, and real estate, or related disciplines. The commission action that would otherwise be valid shall not be rendered invalid by the temporary vacancy of one or all of the professional positions, unless the commission action is related to meeting certified local government (CLG) responsibilities cited in the certification agreement between the mayor of Yakima and the State Historic Preservation Officer on behalf of the state. Furthermore, exception to the residency requirement of commission members may be granted by the mayor of Yakima with the approval of the Yakima city council in order to obtain representatives from these disciplines. (3) In making appointments, the mayor may consider names submitted from any source, but the mayor shall notify Yakima history, heritage, preservation, and development related organizations of vacancies so that names of interested and qualified individuals may be submitted by such organizations for consideration along with names from any other source. C. Terms. The initial appointments to the commission shall be staggered. Two members shall be appointed for one year, three members shall be appointed for two years, and two members shall be appointed for three years. Thereafter, the terms shall be made for three years. Membership on the commission shall be limited to two full consecutive three -year terms. Reappointment after two full consecutive terms may be made after at least a one -year absence. Vacancies shall be filled by the mayor with the approval of the council for a new or unexpired term in the same manner as the original appointment. • D. Powe s and Duties. The major responsibility of the historic preservation commission i. to identify and actively encourage the conservation of Yakima's historic resources by initiating and maintaining a register of historic places and reviewing proposed ch -nges to register properties, to raise community awareness of Yakima's history and h storic resources, and to serve as Yakima's primary resource in matters of history, histo ic planning, and preservation. In carrying out these responsibilities, the commission shall engage in the following: (1) Cond ct and maintain a comprehensive inventory of historic resources within the boundaries o the city of Yakima and known as the Yakima historic inventory, and publicize and periodically update inventory results. Properties listed on the inventory shall be reco ded on official zoning records with an "HI" (for historic inventory designation). This designation shall not change or modify the underlying zone classification. (2) Initiat- and maintain the Yakima register of historic places. This official register shall be com ' of buildings, structures, sites, objects, and districts identified by the commission -s having historic significance worthy of recognition and protection by the city of Yakim.; and encouragement of efforts by owners to maintain, rehabilitate, and preserve pro • erties. (3) Revi - nominations to the Yakima register of historic places according to criteria in YMC 11.6 -.045 and adopt standards in its rules to be used to guide this review. (4) Revie proposals to construct, change, alter, modify, remodel, move, demolish, or significant! . affect properties or districts on the register as provided in YMC 11.62.050 and adopt standards and design guidelines in its rules to be used to guide this review and the issua ce of a certificate of appropriateness or waiver. (5) Provi • e for the review either by the commission or its staff of all applications for approvals, permits, environmental assessments or impact statements, and other similar documents p rtaining to identified historic resources or adjacent properties. (6) Cond ct all commission meetings in compliance with Chapter 42.30 RCW, Open Public Meetin•s Act, to provide for adequate public participation and adopt standards in its rules to gu de this action. (7) Partic pate in, promote and conduct public information, educational and interpretive p ograms pertaining to historic and prehistoric resources. (8) Estab ish liaison support, communication and cooperation with federal, state, and other lo ...I government entities which will further historic preservation objectives, including pub ic education, within the city of Yakima. (9) Revie and comment to the Yakima city council on land use, housing and redevelopme t, economic development strategies, municipal improvements and other types of plan ing and programs undertaken by agencies of the city of Yakima, other neighboring •mmunities, Yakima County, the state or federal governments, as they relate to histo 'c resources of the city of Yakima. (10) Advi a the Yakima city council and the mayor of Yakima generally on matters of Yakima his ory and historic preservation. (11) Perf •rm other related functions assigned to the commission by the Yakima city council. (12) Prov de information to the public on methods of maintaining and rehabilitating historic prope ies. This may take the form of pamphlets, newsletters, workshops, websites, or s miler activities. (13) Officgally recognize excellence in the rehabilitation of historic buildings, structures, sits and districts, and new construction in historic areas and encourage appropriate m for such recognition. (14) Be informed about and provide information to the public and city of Yakima departments on incentives for preservation of historic resources including legislation, regulations and codes which encourage the use and adaptive reuse of historic properties. (15) Review nominations to the State and National Registers of Historic Places. (16) Investigate and report to the Yakima city council on the use of various federal, state, local or private funding sources available to promote historic resource preservation in the city of Yakima. (17) Serve as the local review board for special valuation and: a. Make determination concerning the eligibility of historic properties for special valuation; b. Verify that the improvements are consistent with the Washington State Advisory Council's standards for rehabilitation and maintenance; c. Enter into agreements with property owners for the duration of the special valuation period as required under WAC 254 -20- 070(2); d. Approve or deny applications for special valuation; e. Monitor the property for continued compliance with the agreement and statutory eligibility requirements during the ten -year special valuation period; and f. Adopt bylaws and/or administrative rules and comply with all other board responsibilities identified in Chapter 8426 RCW. E. Compensation. At members shall serve without compensation. F. Rules and Officers. The commission shall establish and adopt its own rules of procedure, and shall select from among its membership a chairperson and such other officers as may be necessary to conduct the commission's business. G. Commission Staff. Commission and professional staff assistance shall be provided by the department of community and economic development with additional assistance and information to be provided by other city departments as may be necessary to aid the commission in carrying out its duties and responsibilities under this chapter. (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). 11.62.045 Yakima register off historic places. A. Criteria for Determining Designation in the Register. Any building, structure, site, object, or district may be designated for inclusion in the Yakima register of historic places if it is significantly associated with the history, architecture, archaeology, engineering, or cultural heritage of the community; if it has integrity; is at least forty years old, or is of lesser age and has exceptional importance; and if it falls in at least one of the following categories: (1) Is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of national, state, or local history. (2) Embodies the distinctive architectural characteristics of a type, period, style, or method of design or construction, or represents a significant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction. (3) Is an outstanding work of a designer, builder, or architect who has made a substantial contribution to the art. (4) Exemplifies or reflects special elements of Yakima's cultural, special, economic, political, aesthetic, engineering, or architectural history. (5) Is associated with the lives of persons significant in national, state, or local history. (6) Has yielded or may be likely to yield important archaeological information related to history or prehistory. • (7) Is a building or structure removed from its original location but which is significant primarily for architectural value, or which is the only surviving structure significantly associated with an historic person or event. (8) Is a birthplace or grave of a historical figure of outstanding importance and is the only surviving structure or site associated with that person. (9) Is a cemetery which derives its primary significance from age, from distinctive design features, or from association with historic events, or cultural patterns. (10) Is a ' creative and unique example of folk or vernacular architecture and design created by persons not formally trained in the architectural or design professions, and which does not fit into formal architectural or historical categories. B. Process for Designating Properties or Districts to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. (1) Any person may nominate a budding, structure, site, object, or district for inclusion in the Yakima register of historic places. Members of the historic preservation commission or the commission as a whole may generate nominations. In its designation decision, the commission shall consider the Yakima historic inventory and the Yakima comprehensive plan. (2) Applications for nominations must bear the signature of the property owner(s) of record of the subject property as indicated by the records of the Yakima County auditor, or in the case of districts, signatures must be obtained from the owners of a majority of the properties within the proposed district. Applications shall be on forms and indude information and documentation supporting the historic significance of the building, structure, site, object, or district. (3) In the case of individual properties, the designation shall include the legal description and all features — interior and exterior —and outbuildings that contribute to its designation. (4) In the case of districts, the designation shall include description of the boundaries of the district, the characteristics of the district which justify its designation, and a listof all properties including features, structures, sites, and objects ,hick contribute to the designation of the district. (5) The commission shall consider the merits of the nomination, according to the criteria in subsection A of this section and according to the nomination review standards established in rules, at an open record public hearing. At least ten days prior to the hearing, written notice by first -class mail of the time, date, place, and subject of the hearing will be given to all owners of record of the subject property as indicated by the records of the Yakima County auditor, the authors of the nomination, if different, and lessees, if any, of the subject. property. Public notice of the hearing shall also be provided and sham include, at least ten days prior to the hearing, publication in a newspaper of general circulation in Yakima and posting of the property. • The commission shall, by a majority vote of its members, make a written recommendation to the city council that the nomination of the subject property be approved or rejected for listing on the Yakima register of historic places. The recommendation shall set forth findings of fact which constitute the basis for the recommendation. (6) Upon receipt of the commission's recommendation, the city council shall hold an open record public hearing to consider the recommendation. Notice of the hearing shall be provided in accordance with subsection (B)(5) of this section. The city council shall approve, reject or refer the recommendation back to the commission for further • consideration, as the council deems appropriate. Approval of a recommendation to designate a property for listing on the register shall be done by city council adoption of a resolution designating the building, structure, site, object, or district for listing on the Yakima register of historic places. (7) Properties listed on the Yakima register of historic places shall be recorded on official zoning records with an "HR" (for historic register) designation. This designation shall not change or modify the underlying zone classification. C. Removal of Properties from the Register. (1) In the event that any property is no longer deemed appropriate for designation or no longer meets the eligibility requirements for the Yakima register of historic places, the commission may initiate removal from such designation by the same procedure as provided for in establishing the designation in subsection B of this section. (2) Additionally, and except to the extent that a property is subject to a historic preservation special valuation agreement entered into under the authority of YMC 11.62.060 and applicable state law, the property owner(s) of record (as indicated by the records of the Yakima County auditor) of a property listed on the Yakima register of historic places may make a written request to have said property removed from the register. The written request must be signed by said property owner(s) and notarized. - Upon receipt of such a properly notarized written request, the commission shall immediately remove the property from the register. D. Effects of Listing on the Register. (1) Listing on the Yakima register of historic places is an honorary designation denoting significant association with the historic, archaeological, engineering, or cultural heritage of the community. Properties are listed individually or as contributing properties to an historic district. (2) Prior to the commencement of any work on a register property, excluding 0 ordinary and maintenance and emergency measures defined in YMC 11.62.030, the owner must request and receive a certificate of appropriateness from the commission for the proposed work. Violation of this rule shall be grounds for the commission to review the property for removal from the register. (3) Prior to whole or partial demolition of a register property, the owner must request and receive a waiver of a certificate of appropriateness. (4) Once the city of Yakima is certified as a certified local government (CLG), all properties listed on the Yakima register of historic places may be eligible for special tax valuation on their rehabilitation under YMC 11.62.060. (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). 11.62.050 Review of changes to Yakima register of historic places properties. To achieve the comprehensive plan and historic preservation goals and to safeguard the heritage of Yakima, a two -part evaluation system shall be followed: (1) The identification of those materials, features and combinations of features that give significance to property(ies) or districts on the Yakima register of historic places. (2) Assessing the potential impact or effect of rehabilitation work necessary for efficient contemporary utilization of the property. The historic character of a property or district is defined by many features: materials, style, method of construction, composition and decorative features; the presence of architectural metals; window number, arrangements and styles (fenestration); entrances and porches, storefronts on commercial buildings, internal arrangement and detailing; and the historic relationship between buildings, landscape features and open space, as well as many other materials and features can all contribute to a property's character. After identifying the distinguishing historic characteristics of a property subject to the design review process, retention and preservation of those features and materials are the primary goals of the design review effort. • This is accomplished through the review process individual to each property. Preferred approaches to the treatment of properties, specified by the Secretary of the Interior, are common to each property. These are, in descending order of preference: (1) protecting and maintaining, (2) repairing, (3) replacing in -kind, (4) design for missing features, and (5) alterations and additions to historic buildings. The guidelines for the above are listed in the "rules and procedure? adopted herewith. A. Review Required. No person shall construct any new building or structure, or reconstruct, alter, restore, remodel, repair, move, demolish or make any material change affecting significant historic features as listed in the designation form(s) to any existing property on the Yakima register of historic places or within a historic district on the Yakima register without review by the commission and without receipt of a certificate of appropriateness, or in the case of demolition, a waiver of certificate of appropriateness, as a result of the review. The review shall apply to all features of the property, interior and exterior, that contribute to its designation and are listed on the designation. This requirement shall apply whether or not the proposed alteration also requires a building or other permit, except as noted under subsection B of this section. Material, documents and other information required by the commission to review the proposed changes shall be established in its rules and procedures. A preapplication conference is recommended but is at the request of the applicant. B. Exemptions. The following actin' ies do not require a certificate of appropriateness or review by the commission: (1) Ordinary repairs and maintenance which do not affect significant historic features, including painting, or emergency measures as defined in YMC 11.62.030. (2) Ordinary repairs and maintenance which do not alter the appearance of a i significant feature and do not, utilize substitute materials. (3) If there are not interior features of significance, repairs to or replacement of utility systems. C. Review Process. (1) Requests for Review and Issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness or Waiver. The code administration and planning manager or his /her designee shall report to the commission any application for a permit to work on a designated Yakima register of historic places property or in a Yakima register historic district. If the activity is not exempt from review, the commission or staff shall notify the applicant of the review requirements. The code administration and planning manager or his/her designee shall not issue any such permit until a certificate of appropriateness or a waiver is received from the commission but shall work with the commission in considering building and fire code requirements. (2) There shall be two types of reviews for issuance of a certificate of appropriateness: a. Type I. An administrative review by commission staff for repairs and replacements -in -kind as listed below, but not limited to, the following: i. Repairs (other than ordinary repair and maintenance) using the same materials and d esign as the original; ii. Re- roofing using the same type and color of material; iii. Replacement of sidewalks and driveways using the same type and color of materials; iv. Replacement of foundations or major portions thereof, using the same type and color of materials; S v_ Replacement of utility systems if contributing interior features of significance are esent; vi. Structural or seismic upgrades which do not alter or affect significant features. b. Type II. A public meeting review by the commission is required for any alteration in the appearance of a significant contributing feature, the replacement of historic material (other than in -kind) in a significant feature, and /or additions to a Yakima register property; new construction on a Yakima register property or in a historic district; demolition or removal of a Yakima register property; or any excavation on an archaeological site. When a certificate of appropriateness is required, the following procedures shall govern according to the type of review required. (3) Type I Commission Staff Review. A Type I application for review for certificates of appropriateness shall be reviewed by the commission staff. a. The property owner or his /her agent shall file an application with the commission staff on a form provided by the commission. At a minimum, applications shall be accompanied by the following documents, materials and information: a dear photograph or photographs of the building, object, site or structure; a brief description of the proposed work; scaled drawings depicting the proposed work; and samples of replacement material for comparison with the existing or the original building or structure must be fumished with the application. b. A Type I commission staff review decision shall be made within thirty days from the date on which the commission staff receives a fully complete application. c. The commission staff may, on his or her own motion, refer the application to the commission for a decision in accordance with the procedures set forth for a Type II commission review. The time for a decision of the commission on the application shall run from the date that the application is referred to the commission by the staff. d. A Type I commission staff review decision shall be final and binding unless it is appealed to the commission by the aggrieved person, public agency or other legal entity. 0 The appeal must be in writing on forms provided by the commission, and filed with the commission within fourteen calendar days of the date of the decision. The written appeal must specify all grounds for the appeal, request a hearing before the commission and be accompanied by an appeal fee of one hundred dollars. The commission shall set a date, time and place for the appeal hearing. After the hearing, the commission shall make the final and conclusive written determination regarding the appeal. (4) Type II Commission Review. A Type II application for review for certificates of appropriateness or waiver thereof shall be reviewed by the commission in accordance with the following process. a. The property owner or his /her agent shall file an application with the commission on a form provided by the commission. Each application shall be accompanied by such documents, materials and information as required by the commission and which is reasonably necessary for the review of the proposed project. b. When an applicant is requesting a waiver of the certificate of appropriateness requirement in order to demolish a designated Yakima register of historic places property in whole or in part, the applicant shall also demonstrate in writing with the application that demolition altematives have been or are being pursued (alternatives include but are not limited to economic analysis; offers to lease, sell or dedicate site to a private, public or nonprofit entity, and outcome of the offer; relocation of building, etc.). The commission shall consider these and other altematives to demolition as part of its Type II review process. The commission may extend the review process as necessary to allow sufficient time to fully explore and consider altematives to demolition. The commission may also condition the issuance of a waiver upon the satisfaction of certain mitigation steps and measures (including, but not limited to, photographic documentation of the resource, an identification plaque, use of an architectural element in new construction, and /or buffering of the historic or cultural resource). c. The commission shall hold a public meeting to review the proposed work according to the design review criteria established in its rules. Notice of the time, date and place of the design review meeting shall be sent by first -class mail to the property owner(s) of record of the subject property as indicated by the records of the Yakima County auditor, applicant (if different), lessees and any other interested parties. The commission shall issue a written decision which shall set forth findings of fact and conclusions which constitute the basis for the decision. The commission's decision shall be forwarded to the code administration and planning manager or his/her designee. d. A Type II commission review decision shall be final and binding unless it is appealed to the city of Yakima hearing examiner by the aggrieved person, public agency or other legal entity. The appeal must be in writing on forms provided by the commission, and filed with the hearing examiner within fourteen calendar days of the date of the decision. The written appeal must specify all grounds for the appeal, request a hearing before the hearing examiner and be accompanied by an appeal fee of one hundred dollars. The hearing examiner shall set a date, time and place for the appeal hearing. The record on appeal shall be limited to that record developed before the commission at its public meeting to review the application. The hearing examiner shall apply the design review criteria established by the commission in considering the appropriateness of the commission decision. After the hearing, the hearing examiner shall make the final and conclusive written determination regarding the appeal. (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). 11.62.060 Review and monitoring of properties for special property tax valuation. A. Time Lines. (1) Special property tax valuations applications shall be forwarded to the commission by the assessor within ten calendar days of filing. (2) Applications shall be reviewed by the commission before December 31st of the calendar year in which the application is made. (3) Commission decisions regarding the applications shall be certified in writing and filed with the assessor within ten calendar days of issuance. B. Procedure. (1) The assessor forwards the applications to the commission. (2) The commission reviews the application(s), consistent with its rules of procedure, and determines if the application(s) are complete and if the properties meet the criteria set forth in WAC 254 -20- 070(1) (and as may be amended) and listed in subsection C of this section. a. If the commission finds the properties meet all the criteria, then, on behalf of the - city of Yakima, it shall enter into a historic preservation special valuation agreement with the owner in a form set forth in WAC 25420 -120 (and as may be amended) and listed in subsection D of this section. Upon execution of the agreement between the owner and commission, the commission shall approve the application. b. If the commission determines the properties do not meet all the criteria, then it shall deny the application. (3) The commission shall certify its decision in writing and state the facts upon which the approval or denial is based and file copies of the certification with the Yakima County assessor. - (4) For approved applications, the commission shall: a. Forward a copy of the agreement, application, and supporting documentation as required by WAC 254 -20- 070(4) (and as may be amended) and identified in subsection (C)(2) of this section to the assessor; i b. Notify the state review board that the properties have been approved for special valuation; and c. Monitor the properties for continued compliance with the agreements throughout the ten -year special valuation period, including but not limited to any special valuation agreements that were entered into under the authority of YMC Chapter 11.60 and that are still in effect. (5) The commission determines, in a manner consistent with its rules of procedure, whether or not a property is disqualified from special valuation either because of: a. The owner's failure to comply with the terms of the agreement; or b. A loss of historic value resulting from physical changes to the building or site. (6) In the event that the commission concludes that a property is no longer qualified for special valuation, the commission shall notify the owner, assessor, and state review board in writing and state the facts supporting its findings. C. Criteria for Special Valuation. (1) Historic Property Criteria. The class of historic property eligible to apply for special valuation in the city of Yakima means all properties listed on the National Register of Historic Places or certified as contributing to a National Register Historic District which have been substantially rehabilitated at a cost and within a time period which meets the requirements set forth in Chapter 84.26 RCW (and as may be amended), until the city of Yakima becomes a certified local govemment (CLG). Once Yakima becomes a CLG, the class of property eligible to apply for special valuation in Yakima means all properties listed on the Yakima and National Registers of Historic Places or properties certified as contributing to a Yakima or National Register Historic District which have been substantially rehabilitated at a cost and within a time period which meets the requirements set forth in Chapter 84.26 RCW (and as may be amended). (2) Application Criteria. Complete applications shall consist of the following documentation: a. A legal description of the historic property; b. Comprehensive exterior and interior photographs of the historic property before and after rehabilitation; c. Architectural plans or other legible drawings depicting the completed rehabilitation work; d. A notarized affidavit attesting to the actual cost of the rehabilitation work completed prior to the date of application and the period of time during which the work was performed and documentation of both to be made available to the commission upon request; and e. For properties located within historic districts, in addition to the standard application documentation, a statement from the Secretary of the Interior or code administration and planning manager or his/her designee indicating the property is a certified historic structure. (3) Property Review Criteria. In its review the commission shall determine if the properties meet all the following criteria: a. The property is historic property; b. The property is included within a class of historic property determined eligible for special valuation by the city of Yakima under subsection (C)(1) of this section; c. The property has been rehabilitated at a cost which meets the definition set forth in RCW 84.26.020(2) (and as may be amended), and identified in subsection C of this section within twenty -four months prior to the date of application; and d. The property has not been altered in any way which adversely affects those elements which qualify it as historically significant as determined by applying the Washington State Advisory Council's standards for the rehabilitation and maintenance of 41) historic properties (VVAC 254 -20- 100(1)). • (4) Rehabilitation and Maintenance Criteria. The Washington State Advisory Council's standards for the rehabilitation and maintenance of historic properties in WAC 254 -20 -100 (and as may be amended) shall be used by the commission as minimum requirements for determining whether or not an historic property is eligible for special valuation and whether or not the property continues to be eligible for.special valuation once it has been so dassified. D. Agreement. The historic preservation special valuation agreement in WAC 254- 20 -120 (and as may be amended) shall be used by the commission as the minimum agreement necessary to comply with the requirements of RCW 84.26.050(2). E. Appeals. Any decision of the commission acting on any application for classification as historic property, eligible for special valuation, may be appealed to superior court under RCW 34.05.570 in addition to any other remedy of law. Any decision on the disqualification of historic property eligible for special valuation, or any other dispute, may be appealed to the county board of equalization. (Ord. 2005 -02 § 2 (part), 2005). • B GE - C STNUT HISTORIC DISTRICT P SE ONE City Council Closed Record Public Hearing June 16, 2009 E IBIT LIST Applicant: Historic Preservation Commission / Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Association Site Address: Vicinity east of 32 Avenue, west of 24 Avenue, south of Barge Street, and north of Walnut Street Staff Contact Vaughn McBride, Historic Preservation Staff Liaison Table of Contents CHAPTER A Resolution and Agenda Statement CHAPTER B Historic Preservation Commission Findings of Fact and Recommendation to Council CHAPTER C Vicinity Map — Barge Chestnut Historic District CHAPTER D Public Notices CHAPTER E Public Comments BUSINESS OF THE CITY COUNCIL YAKIMA, WASHINGTON AGENDA STATEMENT |tern No. For Meeting (]f: lune lG^ 2009 ITEM TITLE: Closed Record Public Hearing for the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One Nomination to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. SUBMITTED BY: William R. Cook Director of Community and Economic Development CONTACT PERSON/TELEPHONE: Vaughn McBride Associate Planner (576-63|5) SUMMARY EXPLANATION: The Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One nomination meets Criteria 1 through 5 for designation to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. On May 28. 2009 the Historic Preservation Commission conducted an open record public hearing to review the nomination application submitted by the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Association to place the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic Di»Lrict, Phase One, located in the vicinity east of 32"«Axcnue. west of24mAvenue, south of Barge Street and north of Walnut Street on the Yakima Register of Historic Places. Based upon a review of the complete app|icalinn, site visit, discussions with the applicant/agent, staff Report of Hndings, exhibiLs, testimony and other evidence presented at the open record public hearing the Historic Preservation Commission issued a written recommendation for approval of this application on May 28, 2009. Resolution X Ordinance Contract Historic Preservation Commission recommendation Funding Source _ _ APPROVAL FOR SUBMITTAL: City Manager STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the Historic Preservation Commission's recommendation. BOARD RECOMMENDATION: Historic Preservation Commission recommends approval of the nomination of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic Disrrict, Phase One to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. COUNCIL ACTION: � -� / ` ^/ ` . RESOLUTION NO. R 2009- A RESOLUTION related to Historic Preservation, initiating the designation of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One under the provisions of Yakima Municipal Code 11,62.045 Yakima Register of Historic Places WHEREAS, the City of Yakima desires to establish the "Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" under the provisions of Yakima Municipal Code 11,62.045; and WHEREAS, the "Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" is generally described as the properties that are located within the following boundary: north of West Chestnut Avenue between 31st Avenue and 32nd Avenue, then east of 32 Avenue between West Chestnut Avenue and Barge Avenue, then south of Barge Avenue between 24 and 32nd Avenue, then west of 241h Avenue between Barge Avenue and West Chestnut Avenue, then north of Chestnut Avenue between 24th Avenue and 26th Avenue, then west of 26th Avenue between Chestnut Avenue and Walnut Street ; then north of Walnut Street between 26th Avenue and 28U Avenue, then properties along both sides of North 28th Avenue between Walnut Street and West Chestnut, and the properties located along the south frontage of West Chestnut Avenue between 28th Avenue and 315t Avenue (see Attachment "A", Map of Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One); and WHEREAS, residents of the proposed Historic District submitted a petition signed by a majority of the properties within the limits of the district; and WHEREAS, the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission reviewed the resident petition and determined that the area contains a significant resource of buildings with architectural qualities which exemplify Yakima's cultural, economic and distinctive history; and conducted a public hearing on May 28, 2009 to receive testimony regarding the format of the Historic District and, WHEREAS, the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission at the conclusion of the public hearing on May 28, 2009 voted to approve the formation of the Historic District and adopted Findings of Fact to support the recommendation that the district be established in consideration of the requirements of YMC 11.62.045, now, therefore INDEX Barge Chestnut Ng Are Phew One neseluhon Page ol 2 ! z_ BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF YAKIMA: The City of Yakima hereby designates the "Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Area Historic District, Phase One" as a Local Historic District in the Yakima Register of Historic Places under the provisions of the Yakima Municipal Code 11.62.045 ADOPTED BY THE CITY COUNCIL this day of June, 2009. ATTEST: Dave Ed ler, Mayor City Clerk I • INDEX Barge Chesmut Neighborhood Area Phase One Rosowbon Page 2 of 2 # 2_ 0 1 inch = 200 feet EIN . 1) Attachment "A" BCNA Historical Preservation Committee Historical District: Phase One "Yakima 199 112 w 111 112 3204 108 107 110 109 111 109 0 , . 2912 2908 2906 112 111 109 110 w 111 109 > 112 110 1/1 109 ■10 108 109 107 112 110 07 107 ol ELEANOR ST 106 105 108 > 106 105 1 08 ' 107 ›- < 2- 108 n n n n 06 106 105 1 CU 1 .= W , , , i- 105 _ 1- 103 w ALLEY 104 103 104 0 0 105 .7' ,E1 L7 106 1 163 104 N > 04 R.■ ° a, 103 '8 .-L ; 10 ,, 6, 4 ' < ° 101 ,3E, 102 '77 3" 7009 94' 1 E'''.. S.] L ,' 2807 102 z - ■,; 103 1034 Z 1119 - T.. - 2307 2301 102 1-u 101 g. . I- ,- 3201 , 2799 2701 , 0 102 L-1 101 102 101 102 V 0 o E9 , BARGE ST z 0 ID 3110 3108 ./ r.7 / /1/ 5 ,/,/ ■--, 1,1 1, Lu 'r1 3 ' 8 -',/ ' ° ,-, z 7 __,', .,?, , „9 , : >,;: / , ,, 7 r o /,_,,,j . "tr', r% z,// ° 2706 2702 2402 , , ,/,', ..- //'/, 9 ; 2 2302 8 4( 0 a , , on 7 5 / 1 ' 8 „ 0 IN /77 N IN N E■ ',,,,/, // 5 / / ALLEY 4 r.` `/_, co /// 3209 2 2511 r ,,, ,. 2 / .= S = 2 r8 g; r m , , cc, , T.4 ,,, 2801 z , / 2701 0 7 •- 0 a7 , - . 49 l 0 // ' ■': '. 8 3 2 `- - yl / / a ' a a n 23 2307 2303 23111 //,, a, r4 , 0 o '7 /,/, W YAeSIMA AVE 0 0 c3 0 o 2, . ° 21 = 0 8 2 C. R■ 8, 1205 2 - .- ..- •-• ° o 0 0 En ' ' ■-, 0 0 ,-, n ' 'E , 'S s , ' 7 57 L., , a , . • ''' 0 3 9 O ' ° 'ES g 'C:',, 3. N o 0 ., , N 2402 ° 2302 .'=" 0 2 3002 2 0 '7 ' 17' g + r r ' E s .,- .'■ ■'9a, i,-, ,._.' r r to a, o 0 , , 0 o , E9 0 'u ■ 0 .7, `-', ; , 6 .‘, ‘`T •,, 5 6 0 77.1 ° • ALLEY 3211 3209 a 0 - .- a ■ , - - ,.■ - ■ , - - cr ■ , , - 8 2405 2 ; 7, ,., ; A 2 , ,.2. „0, `-,-,; r" , g., rT, ,-',1 `,&,' (0 ,^ ,-_---, ,,,,,,.° „,,,,-. , ,p„ r , , , ,,,,,,, ,,,:, L. 2311 2307 2 E , " 7., g — n , 2801 w 10 E.! N n -- . , •=r N N 202 201 ' 3102 7 1 N CHESTNUT AVE 3012 1. = 204 230 0 ,; . 2 : - "8 r8 29 202 0 , , L4-1 5E4 r'-4 204 203 204 o 3008 3004 '1 g.,1 7 9,1 EN.' 201 2702 , a5 2412 e-, 2402 > L , ,7 tf ■.c •IS 201 < > 3012 o o I.E3 c an o 201 5 2506 2504 202 ° 206 < ' 205 204 2612 2609 (0 ' ' ' ° ra CC 0 el 205 205 206 205 204 205 204 205 205 204 > _: 20 , Z 208 208 EN 205 200 205 .9 207 205 51 208 r .1 207 208 . 207 208 LLI 207 208 >- 707 39 7 210 210 209 210 207 708 , X W 207 Z 209 212 209 210 209 210 > 209 210 209 4 1 1- 00 ,' ,,■; /,.,, 3-9 ,,, ' /,'' //' , ,c ,, - ,,,, 8 8 212 212 211 > i 210 212 < 2';'// 209 214 I 211 211 212 211 212 0, 211 1-0 212 PALATINE AVE 215 213 214 st 210 21 .. rE, F 'r■S4 216 213 214 L.L., 213 214 ui 213 713 215 219 0 9 215 214 0 ,,, 218 En n n > 0 o - • ° . ■.o ' 217 LJJ 7 215 215 215 LABAN a 716 215 7/7/i:W/7 , N , - , N 216 Homes in Phase I 3 216 215 7,, ,._ N N 220 S 219 22C i 217 I 219 218 217 2310 36 Homes are Non-Contributing 218 217 218 // '2 0 N , 222 W 180 Homes are Contributing 218 0 0 0 P ^ 5 - .,. (0 . . ',. 223 224 5 - , C A > i-, 219 ,,, ,..., - , i.i ,..-6 , ' ' t :7 221 220 < 219 m 9 222 219 220 219 ° 0 3 1 / 9 / 7 ? N cc 33 % Contributre to the Historic District W WALNIJ I i 725 222 / S ni (i) 1 2804 404 404 403 Need a Minimum 109 Signature 403 405 ° ■ Target 135 Signatures 404 405 ' ^ 5 406 406 , < 1 1 7 406 406 L. 1 - W 407 s.1 08 409 408 410 •-1 C'5\- r 92:;% / :- Rentals As of 05/2007 2906 ry 2446:138 w 9 406 i 407 -, < 409 412 parcels selection 2511 409 410 412 09 410 -' 1 ' 2811 411 412 411 _4]_.4. 411 414 00 [ t-i BUSINESS OF THE CITY COUNCIL YAKIMA, WASHINGTON AGENDA STATEMENT Item No. 4 " If" For Meeting of June 2, 2009 ITEM TITLE: Set-Date for a Closed Record Public Hearing for the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District Nomination to the Yakima Register of Historic Places SUBMITTED BY: liam R. Cook Director of Community and Economic Development CONTACT PERSON/TELEPHONE: Vaughn McBride, Associate Planner (576-6315) SUMMARY EXPLANATION: Set Date of June 16, 2009, for a Closed Record Public Hearing for Council consideration of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District Nomination to Yakima Register of Historic Places. The Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Association has initiated nomination procedures for designation review of 216 properties which will comprise Phase I of those properties located within the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood to be placed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places. Phase I will include those properties located east of 32 Avenue, west of 24 Avenue, south of Barge Street and north of Walnut Street. On May 28, 2009 the Historic Preservation Commission issued a written recommendation for approval of this nomination. Resolution Ordinance Contract Other Funding Source N/A APPROVAL FOR SUBMITTAL: City Manager STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Set Date of Closed Record Public Hearing for June 16, 2009. BOARD RECOMMENDATION: Historic Preservation Commission recommended approval of the nomination to the Yakima Register of Historic Places on May 28, 2009. COUNCIL ACTION: INDEX CITY OF YAKIMA HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Commission Findings of Fact May 28, 2009 In the Matter of Application for Nomination to the Yakima Register of Historic Places: Submitted by: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Association Historic Preservation Committee To place the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood - Phase I as a historic district, bounded by South 32nd Avenue (west), South 24th Avenue (east), Barge Street (north), and W. Walnut Street (south) on the Yakima Register of Historic Places Introduction. The petition to nominate the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood area as a Historic District - Phase I was filed April 13, 2009. A total of 216 properties are included in Phase One of the district nomination. There are thirty- six (36) non-contributing properties of 216 total properties in the Phase I nomination. Seventy-eight percent (168 of the 216 properties) of the homeowners in the Phase 1 area nomination have agreed to have their home listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places as part of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood (Phase I) Historic District. The Historic Preservation Commission conducted an open record public hearing on April 22, 2009 to review the nomination application submitted by the Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Association to place the historic the Barge-Chestnut Commission Members 1 Celeste Barry - Stephanie Flynn - Scott Irons • Nancy Kenmotsu • Joe Mann • Karl Pasten • Jenifer Wilde- McMurtrie DOC. INDEX # „6- neighborhood area on the Yakima Register of Historic Places. The nomination was prepared by; Eugenia Woo of Artifacts, Inc. Mr. Gary Forrest, President, Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Association, Historic Preservation Committee and Mr. Walt Ranta spoke in favor of the application. No one provided letters or oral testimony in opposition to the application. Summary of Decision The Historic Preservation Commission approves of the nomination application to place the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood - Phase I designation on the Yakima Register of Historic Places as a Historic District. Basis for Decision Based upon a review of the complete application, site visit, discussions with the applicant/agent, staff Report of Findings, exhibits, testimony and other evidence presented at the open record public hearing on April 22, 2009; and a review of Yakima Historic Preservation Ordinance and Yakima Register of Historic Places Criteria; the Historic Preservation Commission recommends approval of this petition, based on the following findings of fact: FINDINGS OF FACT 1. The petition to nominate the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Association (BCNA) Historic District - Phase One was filed April 13, 2009. A total of 216 properties are included in Phase One of the district nomination. All of the homes in Phase One meet the 40-year age criteria for listing on the Yakima Register of Historic Places. The eleven blocks surveyed in Phase One were platted as early as 1907 and as late as 1939. Construction dates of homes on each block typically span between the 1910s and 1 960s, with the great majority of the 216 properties surveyed having been built in the 1920s and 1930s, followed by the 1940s. 2. The Barge-Chestnut neighborhood contains the array of twentieth century residential architecture found throughout Washington State. The present day urban form and land use pattern of the Barge-Chestnut neighborhood directly resulted from early uses and ownership of the land. Originally, the dominant use of the land was for orchard farming in the late 19th century and first couple decades of the 20th century gave way to more intense suburban residential development in the 1930s and 1940s. Many of the houses in the neighborhood were occupied by people who had direct tie Commission Members Celeste Barry • Stephanie Flynn • Scott Irons • Nancy Kenmotsu • Joe Mann • Karl Pasten • Jenifer Wilde- McMurtrie DOC. INDEX # A- to the fruit industry. The Barge-Chestnut neighborhood has developed into a cohesive residential district with a mix of early to mid-twentieth century residential architecture. Its resources, dating from the late 1 890s to mid-1960s, represent the birth, growth and development of Nob Hill, a once rural area transformed into one of Yakima's most desirable suburban neighborhoods. The combination of larger-scale, older houses such as Rosedell or the Irish House, along with the period revival style houses of the 1920s, and the popular Minimal Traditional style of the 1930s to 1950s, gives the Barge-Chestnut neighborhood its character. It is the consistency in craftsmanship and diversity of architectural styles mixed with mature landscaping that give the Barge-Chestnut neighborhood its potential historic district quality. The neighborhood is almost exclusively made up of single family homes with the occasional duplex; and with the exception of a couple blocks, there no sidewalks. Front yards with lawns terminate in concrete curbs adjacent to the street. A variety of mature trees are found throughout the neighborhood including Elm, Maple, Cedar, Spruce, Weeping Birch, Japanese maple, Sycamore, Blue Spruce and Arborvitae. 3. At least one work session is recommended for the Commission to discuss Design Review processes and other details, i.e. Certificate of Appropriateness process and criteria; 4. The Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District - Phase I, as proposed, is eligible for listing in the Yakima Register of Historic Places as a historic district in under YMC 11.62.045(A) as it meets Criteria One, Two, Three, Four and Five. 1. Is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of national, state, or local history. The Barge-Chestnut neighborhood is anchored on the east by Rosedell, the original home of A. E. Larson, one of Yakima's most prominent citizens and businessmen. The H.M. Gilbert House and William Irish House are other examples of fine residences built by some of Yakima's pioneers. More typical however, are the scores of Craftsman bungalows, Colonial Revival style houses, Tudor cottages, Spanish Eclectic homes, and the modest Minimal Traditional residences that make up this neighborhood. Many of the houses in the neighborhood were occupied by people who had direct ties to the fruit Commission Members 3 Celeste Barry • Stephanie Flynn • Scott Irons • Nancy Kenmotsu • Joe Mann • Karl Fasten Jenifer Wile le- Mc Mu rtrie DOC. INDEX industry. From its early years when the area was mostly orchards or sagebrush land, the neighborhood grew into a desirable suburban enclave. 2. Embodies the distinctive architectural characteristics of a type, period, style, or method of design or construction, or represents a significant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction. The Barge-Chestnut neighborhood has scores of Craftsman bungalows, Colonial Revival style houses, Tudor cottages, Spanish Eclectic homes, and the modest Minimal Traditional residences that make up this neighborhood. It is the consistency in craftsmanship and diversity of architectural styles mixed with mature landscaping that give the Barge-Chestnut neighborhood its potential historic district quality. 3. Is an outstanding work of a designer, builder, or architect who has made a substantial contribution to the art. The majority of the houses built in the Barge-Chestnut neighborhood were either not designed by architects or the architects are unknown. William W. deVeaux and john W. Maloney were two prominent architects who designet houses in the neighborhood. In Phase One, only one house was identified with an architect and six were identified with a builder (building contractor Louis C. Rainey is associated with five houses in Phase One). Some houses were built using plans from plan books that were popular at the time. 4. Exemplifies or reflects special elements of Yakima's cultural, special, economic, political, aesthetic, engineering, or architectural history. The dominant original use of the land was for orchard farming in the late 19th century and first couple decades of the 20th century gave way to more intense suburban residential development in the 1930s and 1940s. Many of the houses in the neighborhood were occupied by people who had direct ties to the fruit industry. The present day urban form and land use pattern of the Barge-Chestnut neighborhood directly resulted from early uses and ownership of the land. Architectural styles in Phase One and in the study area in general reflect the periods of construction and trends of the day. The oldest houses were designed in the Queen Anne style and date from 1 898 and 1906. It is a Commission Members 4 Celeste Barry • Stephanie Flynn • Scott Irons • Nancy Kenmotsu • Joe Mann • Karl Pasten • Jenifer Wilde- McMurtrie DOC. INDEX R-i style found more often in the older residential districts located north and southeast of downtown Yakima. The Queen Anne style residences in Nob Hill are usually associated wit h a property that was once part of a larger orchard. The Arts & Crafts style houses is one of the predominant styles in the neighborhood popular from about 1905 to the late 1920s to early 1930s. Fifty-nine (59) Arts & Crafts style houses are included in the Phase One nomination. Typical features of these homes include a low-pitched gabled roof (Occassionally hipped) with wide, unenclosed eave overhangs, exposed roof rafters, decorative beams or braces under gables, and porches supported by tapered square columns. Styles from the Eclectic movement such as Tudor, Colonial Revival, Spanish Eclectic and French Eclectic were popular in the 1 920s and 1930s. The predominant style in Phase One is the Minimal Traditional style - 66 houses built in the mid-1930s to 1950s reflect this style. Especially popular in the post-WWII years, these houses reflect the form of the more traditional Eclectic or Revival styles but lack the decorative detailing. 5. Is associated with the lives of persons significant in national, state, or local history. William W. deVeaux designed the H.M. Gilbert House at 2109 W. Yakima Avenue. He was born in 1866 in Charleston, South Carolina, yet chose to live most of his days in Yakima until his death in 1962 at the age of 96. De Veaux and his wife, Edith, were very active in the local Congregational Christian Church. He not only participated earnestly as a deacon, but also provided his architectural skills to the church by designing its present structure on N. 2nd Street. De Veaux's contributions to the city of Yakima can be observed in many other buildings throughout the downtown area. One of the best examples of his work is the Masonic Temple, on which de Veaux collaborated with his associate, Frederick Heath, of Tacoma. The Washington National Guard Armory Building (no longer extent), which was designed along with well-known Yakima architect William H. Weatherwax, was another fine example of de Veaux's work. The Winslow-McCafferty Building and the W. P. Sawyer House are also structures accredited to de Veaux. DeVeaux also designed the State Fair's first permanent exhibition hall, the Horticultural Building, built in 1895. His experience prepared him for his later career as a Commission Members 5 Celeste Barry • Stephanie Flynn • Scott Irons • Nancy Kenmotsu • Joe Mann • Karl Pasten • Jenifer Wilde- McMurtrie DOC. INDEX city building inspector. Starting out as an assistant city building inspector in 1938, de Veaux retired holding the title of Yakima Deputy City Building John W. Maloney The house located at 8 N. 24th Avenue was designed by architect John W. Maloney. Born in 1895 in Sacramento, California, _John W. Maloney was educated in the Catholic schools of Grass Valley, California. Maloney's work included a sizeable number of Yakima Valley institutional buildings, including the Young Women's Christian Association Building with Mary Remy (Yakima, 1935), Grandview High School (Grandview, 1937), and Yakima Indian Agency Building (Toppenish, 1931). He also designed the 4-H Building (1937) at the Central Washington State Fairgrounds. Louis C. Rainey Building contractor Louis C. Rainey is associated with five houses in Phase One. Rainey lived in the neighborhood and developed all five houses in the mid-1930s (2704 W. Yakima Avenue, 2792 W. Yakima Avenue, 2610 W. Yakima Avenue, 2703 W. Chestnut Street, and 2709 W. Chestnut Street). I-1( purchased vacant lots and built the houses and sold them one year later with the exception of 2709 W. Chestnut Street which served as his residence from 1935 to 1958. Similarly, builder Louis Jarvis built a house at 3002 Barge Street in 1927 and sold the property in 1929. RECOMMENDATION The Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District - Phase I nomination meets YMC 11.62.045(A), Criteria 1 through 5 for designation to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. The Yakima Historic Preservation Commission recommends approval of nomination of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District - Phase I to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. 1) The Commission, by a majority vote of its members, recommends the Yakima City Council approve of the nomination to establish the district. Commission Members Celeste Barry • Stephanie Flynn • Scott Irons • Nancy Kenmotsu • Joe Mann • Karl Pasten • Jenifer Wilde- McMurtrie DOC. INDEX Ai / `� � / ' ' SC��'' Irons, Chairman Date Commission Members 7 Celeste Barry Stephanie Flynn Scott Irons Nancy Kcnrnmtsu^ Joe Mann ^ Karl Pasten^Jeni6erYVUdo' &4cK4urbie D0C.lNDDX � # -/ 0 BCNA Historical Preservation Commith 1 inch =200 feet e Historical District: Phase n -e "Yakim _ 111 �� rtnuvn LIa 112 110 =ANOR ST 39 112 111 112 112 111 11i 109 112 t N 3204 108 109 o 0 2808 2806 112 110 n 107 110 107 108 2812 109 110 W 109 109 108 w 107 110 0 0 0 0 co 0 105 108 } 107 106 ta5 108 > 107 106 107 W Q w 108 r 0 N N r G u �' Q 106 105 H 105 106 103 106 w N ALLEY w 104 103 104 n 105 < m d o c 7.4 3091 3009 104 103 rn r o 103 104 Z 104 103 104 Z 104 2 r 2307 2301 °J 3201 101 n • 102 Z 102 w `� N m N 2807 102 ° Q 101 2709 2701 . `�° 102 > 101 102 101 102 N "' o co d 0 -1C s Z N z 10 3110 3108 2804 N ° ° o ro v o/ No Z �... 5 _. 0 Z j 2402 ,,,�� 10 2706 2702'�S�Ly}j / / // � / / t / i/ /, m u� 7 O O � N O m a, CO o /t>1 �� / o p a o-a cn ra / n N N N CO m N uY / 9 N 2ba2 a a M > s N 0 ,/'' // N N 8 = j/ 8 N ® N V /y+/ a N 4 , � j N �� 6 �/ /�' N ALLEY c z r o o A o 0 o 0 o 92. N o 0 0 0 0 '� "� 2701 = °' v' / r '., 3209 2 `^ 0 0 n 0 0 0 0 w 0 N /�O / 1 ,/� N 0 0 0 2801 Z N o 0 N `8 2511 N s „ / N Q ° 2311 2307 2303 2301 o N / N W YAKIMA AVE `" ° ° o 0 0 0 0 0 ° " �, 2 m o o N co w N o n 3206 2 0 0 0 3002 ° m co ° 0 0 N co 0 > 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N N N N °m m o o N o <° 0 8 `v ° o 0 0 : o ® 2402 00 2302 a N N N N N N N N N N iN N N N N O N N N N 6 5 6 N 0 N N N N N cr m ALLEY cv 3211 3209 7 0 0 0 r o 0 0 r o c o 0 0 8 °' m r v 3203 8 r 0 0 0 0 0 °o 0 w N N N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ° 0 0 0 0 0 2405 0 0 23311 2307 0 0 0 0 N 0 r. M CO �.y O 0 2801 w N N 0 N 0 N N N N n N o c, ° O N 202 201 3102 3012 �r 1//, W CHESTNUT AVE 0 co 0 0 . r p3 r o /./ t0 N 2810 202 m W / o ® N m 2412 w 204 2302 204 204 3008 3004 m °i 201 2702 m v 2402 Q > 203 3012 2a2 ro, to x ° ° ° m 201 S' 2506 2504 0 201 0 206 d • .. .. 205 204 2612 2608 0 0 0 0 0 205 0 205 206 205 204 205 204 m Z 208 2 05 205 204 208 0 208 c 207 206 w > 205 208 205 Q 204 207 ca 207 208 207 208 207 208 W a '�,��" %/ 210 207 210 209 210 207 208 Z 209 210 209 210 > 209 210 2 r" 4- / 0) o a ztz 212 W w 208 209 212 d 0 209 2 / 0 0 c 210 / �v /�,9 N ry 211 212 a = 2 211 212 211 292 c 211 217 // // 294 € 209 214 2 211 212 PALATINE AVE t' 215 213 214 v 210 210 ..... o ® 216 213 214 213 214 213 213 214 m o 8 N o m 216 218 1n 21 PI 8 PA a UJ 216 r / N a o 0 0 8 216 Homes in Phase 1 5 216 215 215 2 18 217 7 215 216 215 LABAN AVI / /��j.(�7 N 220 219 220 2 2310 36 Homes are Non - Contributing 218 217 218 217 c 219 218 217 •° 180 Homes are Contributing 218 219 N g 222 0 > 219 221 220 3 222 219 220 % 22 ti 11) 3 0 224 219 a 83.3 % Contributre to the Historic District W VVALr u 1 s 1 222 co 225 0 1 2608 2604 404 404 403 Need a Minimum 109 Signature Target 135 Signatures > 403 404 403 405 405 5 < } 406 406 ' w 406 f% Rentals As of 05/2007 7 406 2906 408 409 405 a 4p10 409 a 410 408 409 4 08 410 �P N�� ~�� CO parcels selection 2811 412 ran 411 412 411 414 411 414 YAKIMA CITY COUNCIL NOTICE OF CLOSED RECORD PUBLIC HEARING Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District Nornination To Yakima Register of Historic Places NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Yakima City Council will conduct a closed record public hearing to consider the recommendation of the Historic Preservation Commission to approve the nomination of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District — Phase 1 to the Yakima Register of Historic Places. This area is located east of 32 Avenue, west of 24 Avenue, south of Barge Street and north of Walnut Street The Historic Preservation Commission issued a written recommendatton for approval of this nomination application on May 28. 2009. Closed Record Hearing means the public is invited to testify on the existing Yakima Historic Preservation Commission reoordo, but will not be allowed to introduce any new information. Written comments may be submitted to the Council in two ways: 1) Send a letter via regular mail to "Yakima City Council, Council, �� 129 2n Street, YaAinm, WA 98901"; or, 2) E-mail your comments to CC0unQY©Ciyakim8.w/8.uS. Include in the e-mail subject line, "Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood." Please also include your name and mailing address. The public hearing will be held on Tuesday, June 16, 2009 at 7:00 p'mn', or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard, in the Council Chambers at Yakima City M8||, 129 North 2 Stre8t, Yakima, WA. Please contact Vaughn McBride at 576-6315 if you have any questions about this nomination. Dated this 3 day of June, 2009. Deborah Moore City Clerk DOC. INDEX � /� _ _ � - �� ADDITIONAL PARTIES OF RECO 1 — BARGE CHESTNUT DISTRICT PHASE ONE Gary Forrest Barge — Chestnut Neighborhood Assn Leslie Wahl 3011 Barge Street 2607 Barge Street 203 West Yakima Avenue Yakima, WA 98902 Yakima, WA 98902 Yakima, WA 98902 Velikanje Halverson P.C. Pete Mahony Claudia Christie 102 North 26 Avenue c/o Mike Shinn 2902 Surnmitview Avenue P.O. Box 22550 Yakima, WA 98902 Yakima, WA 98902 Yakima, WA 98907 Jim and Sally Baldwin Yvonne Wilbur Kristina and Gayle Harris 105 North 27 Avenue 4903 View land Drive 220 South 32 Avenue Yakima, WA 98902 Yakima, WA 98908 Yakima, WA 98902 Kelsey Lancaster Maud Scott Robert Wahl 215 South 32 Avenue 309 Union Street 2403 West Yakima Avenue Yakima, WA 98902 Yakima, WA 98901 Yakima, WA 98902 DOC. INDEX a e c li '' r iO. CITY OF YAKIMA HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION City of Yakima, Washington Historic Preservation Commission Sign-In Sheet Meeting Date: May 28, 2009 Name Address Phone P a-- - E --- Bytiv-to\viC a9 1 o 14,3,30„..k:f )(Mak (-1-5?),0 ap 30)1 i tryi v jj: ' 1-:)(JC-Ifeci 30c to s C..„,f, '655- le • /05 FJ- 7 7 4.1... il. -, e .: 7 i::0 t Lii r--) _ 654141/ / 1/iCi 6 (46/0 31/0 ik) 0-1< .416)-e , -- - ----74- :3/ / i iroiAl \1/4 1 / 4L ic-‘,.." / Li g i-AAJA-Avc .- 41.evuup 20\ 0 5. 3 2 m t-1 A ue ii57- 4580 - 95 5 U12iO V.,,3<viem. ;~ 0 I J. 1421,w 46 4 -1 111g ,-„, c c - ------- i a • , ---,. ,...., 5 Q,,,,,,A 3.7 3, L-S DM. February 27, 2008 INDEX Page 1 n -3 Name Address Phone -( 57,(57r 3 9 061, 2 7 1 57—/6)0 z-to5 A Lfrsc c- ( DOC. INDEX February 27, 2008 Page 2 1 0-5 11 . CITY OF YAKIMA HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION Commission Meeting Agenda at May 28, 2009 Time: 5:30pm - 7:00pm Place: City all Council Chambers Staff: Vaughn McBride, Historic Preservation Liaison I. Call to Order/Roll Call Scott Irons/Chair II. Adoption of Meeting Minutes Scott Irons/Chair Meeting of April 22, 2009 III. New Business Scott Irons/Chair A. Barge-Chestnut NH Association Scott Irons/Chair Phase I Nomination - Findings of Fact V. Old Business Scott Irons/Chair A. National HP Week Outcomes Scott Irons/Chair V. Adjournment Scott Irons/Chair Commission Members Celeste Barry • Stephanie Flynn • Scott Irons • Nancy Kenrnotsu • Joe Mann • Karl Pi Jennifer Wilde-McMurtrie 1 *- 3 •ittwayeevatelostaliva AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING STATE OF WASHINGTON CITY OF YAKIMA RE: Barge - Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District - Phase I Historic Preservation Commission Public Hearing Vicinity: Barge St - Walnut St - S 24th Ave S 32 Ave I, Rosalinda Ibarra, as an employee of the Yakima City Planning Division, have dispatched through the United States Mails, a Notice of Public Hearing. A true and correct copy of which is enclosed herewith; that said notice was addressed to the all property owners of record within the subject property, that said property owners are individually listed on the mailing list retained by the Planning Division, and that said notices were mailed by me on the 15th day of May, 2009. That I mailed said notices in the manner herein set forth and that all of the statements made herein are just and true. 1 _ , A osalinda Ibarra Planning Specialist DOC. INDEX # -2.. AARON &'SHEROLYN BERDAN ALTON N CRUSE AMY LOUISE RAVENHOLT 2808 W YAKIMA AVE 204 S 28TH AVE 210 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3775 YAKIMA, WA 98902 ___323 -31043 181323 -32553 181323 -32436 ANDREW J BUSH ARTHUR L & CYNTHIA WILLIAMS BRENNA L NELSON 2504 W YAKIMA AVE 2811 W CHESTNUT AVE 3002 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33458 181323 -34001 181323 -31492 BRENTON J & HANNAH R NOEL BRET W BOHOSKEY BRIAN & HOLLY DUNHAM WHEELER 2902 W CHESTNUT 2402 W CHESTNUT AVE 2704 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 989022839 181323 -32439 181323 -31512 181323 -31510 BRIAN B & JOSEPHINE L ULLOM BRIP.N J & DARCIE R ROBERTS BROOKE & J TJARNBERG CRESWEL 3105 W CHESTNUT AVE 2409 WEST CHESTNUT 2412 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -31486 181323 -32564 161323 -32433 BRUCE A & SUSAN D ROGERS BRUCE C & DOROTHY E BENSON C G & MARIA W LINSCHOOTEN 2605 W CHESTNUT AVE 2908 W YAKIMA AVE 3010 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 93902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2761 23 -34021 181323 -34549 181323 -34023 V & CLAUDIA C PETERSON CAROL E FAITH CAROL L & KARL VANEVENHOVEN 2b12 W CHESTNUT 213 S 25TH AVE 210 S 28TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3775 181323 -31050 181323 -34022 181323 -34485 CAROL M LOUDON CHRISTINE CORBETT CONKLIN CHRISTINE S & CRISTOBAL LOPE 2507 W CHESTNUT AVE 2702 W CHESTNUT AVE 215 S 26TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3708 181323 -32444 181323 -32427 181323 -34489 CHRISTOPHER J & JESSICA 1, ALBERT CONNIE MCGLOTHERN COREY HODGE 3007 W CHESTNUT 3110 W YAKIMA AVE 2507 W WALNUT ST YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2763 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3729 181323 -34429 181323 -34412 181323 -31489 CYNTHIA A TREVINO CYNTHIA ANN MC CONNELL CYNTHIA HOVLAND 2604 W CHESTNUT AVE 2609 PALATINE AVE 2610 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2354 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -314 °0 181323 -34466 181323 -33401 SYN A HS ANI D BRUCE SIMPSON DANA E & LISA A ALLISON If I s :'V 216 S 24TH AVE 5509 W LINCOLN AVE 1A, A 96902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98908 DOC. INDEX 181323 -34428 181323 -34480 N D — ��91323 -32552 DANIEL & KATHLEEN JENNINGS DANIEL M TAMSKY DANNY L & CATHY A FLOYD 2606 W CHESTNUT AVE PO BOX 2623 2507 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3722 YAKIMA, WA 98907 -2623 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 - 334439 181323 -34436 161323 -32445 DAVID & DEBORA AXFORD DAVID E DAVIS DAVID T REICH 2603 W WALNUT ST 218 S 26TH AVE 3005 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3730 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 181323 -34014 181323 -32429 181323 -32447 DEAN R CROW DEBORAH L BLACK DEBRA J BLODGETT -GOINS 220 S 25TH AVE 3108 W YAKIMA AVE 3001 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 181323 -31482 181323 -34414 181323 -32438 DENNIS W & JULIE A DEAN DEREK C PRESCOTT DERRY W JEFFERIS 2701 W CHESTNUT AVE 2608 PALATINE AVE 4975 MANFIELD ST YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3723 YAKIMA, WA 98902 SAN DIEGO, California 92116 -1S 181323 -34411 181323 -34481 181323 -31494 DEWARD K & CARLY L OSBORN DONALD & DENISE M SZOLOMAYER DONALD E. & FLORA M. BROOKS 2701 PALATINE AVE 205 S 26TH AVE 2708 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -32431 161323 -34003 181323 -34434 DONDA LAMBERT DONNA J. PEYTON DORENE K CHURCH 3104 W YAKIMA AVE 208 S 24TH AVE 214 S 26TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2763 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33471 181323 -33419 181323 -32547 DOROTHY E BONSER DOUGLAS BERNDT DOUGLAS L FEDERSPIEL 118 S. 31ST AVE 3106 W CHESTNUT AVE 2 S 28TH AVE {AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2816 [81323 -34482 181323-34483 181323 -32551 DOUGLAS P & LAURIE A KANYER D$UGT P & AU' KANYER DOUGLAS R & KELLEY C CAREY ?07 S 26TH AVE 20+ 2: *TH A .. 2801 W CHESTNUT AVE (AKIMA, WA 98902 -3708 YAKIMA, "• 98902 -3708 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3725 .81323 -31051 181323 -33010 181323 -31520 )UANE F & CHERI D HEILMAN EDUARDO PACHECO EDWARD & JOSEPHINE CONLON TRUS '.505 W CHESTNUT AVE 402 S 31ST AVE 2703 W CHESTNUT AVE AKIMA, WA 96902 -3719 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 81323 -31488 181323 -31049 181323 -31517 ;DWARD V & CHRISTINE SCHRANTZ ELAINE J. STEVENSON ERIC F & PAMELA SIMISON '606 W YAKIMA AVE 2509 W CHESTNUT AVE 2602 W YAKIMA AVE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 81323 - 34465 181323 -31042 181323 -34410 ,RIC GUSTAFSON ERIC S 7 CHRISTINA M ELDRIDGE ERICK ETAL AMUNDSON 18 S 24TH AVE 2502 W YAKIMA AVE 2703 PALATINE AVE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3780 INDEX 81323 -33463 181323 -34424 2-G 181323 -34002 RIK D & ALEAH K NICKELSON EVE MARIE DRAPER FRANK & LEAH VORNBROCK HEIBER 11 S 32ND AVE 2705 W WALNUT ST 2406 W CHESTNUT AVE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3732 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -32435 181323 -31522 181323 -34427 FREDERIQUE & ROBERT SPENCER GEANETTE PIPES GEORGE R. KELLY 3006 W YAKIMA AVE 6721 EASY ST 2607 W WALNUT ST YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2761 YAKIMA, WA 98903 -9666 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3730 181323 -32560 181323 -33472 181323 -33470 GINGER MC ILVANIE GLENN & NORKA L DAVIS GLENN M & COLLEEN JAKEMAN 2909 W CHESTNUT AVE 214 S 31ST AVE 220 S 31ST AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34463 181323 -31047 181323 -31048 GREGORY J & BARBARA J KINLOCH GREGORY R FAIN I CECIL & JANE M TERK 222 S 24TH AVE PO BOX 1941 2711 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98907 -1941 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3723 181323-31478 181323 -32562 181323 -34433 I. CEC':■ TE: JAMES D FORSYTHE JAMES DOLE 2 1 C N. A PO BOX 8317 212 S 26TH AVE YA': +, WA 98902 -3723 YAKIMA, WA 90908 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34422 181323 -34486 181323 -33412 JAMES H RICHARDSON JAMES MC CONNELL JAMES N & LORA L BARRETT 219 S 28TH AVE 217 S 26TH AVE 455 NE 17TH ST #24 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3708 MCMINNVILLE, Oregon 97128 -3301 18 ,-32556 181323 -34418 181323 -33407 JAMES P DUFAULT JASON M & ALLISON M DAVILA JASON SORENSON 2901 W CHESTNUT AVE 2704 PALATINE AVE 209 5 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3727 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3675 181323 -33468 181323 -32565 181323 -32566 JEFF S & LEA CLARK JEFFERY S FEEN JEFFREY A & STEPHANIE Y MANN 217 S 32ND AVE 2906 W YAKIMA AVE 2904 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3675 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 [81323 -32590 181323 -33921 181323 -34488 TIM & MARIA BERCOT JOEL R & DONNA M ELDER JOHN _C & CAROLYN GIOVANINI 2911 W CHESTNUT AVE 7007 W LINCOLN AVE 223 S 26TH AVE CAKIMA, WA 98908 YAKIMA, WA 98908 -1239 YAKIMA, WA 98902 .81323 -34006 181323 -32430 181323 -32558 FOHN M & CHERYL A CORNELL JONATHAN & HEIDI HULL JOSEPH A & AVRIL PANZAR_NO :504 W CHESTNUT AVE 3106 W YAKIMA AVE 2903 W CHESTNUT AVE ' AKIMA, WA 98902 -3720 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3727 81373 -34464 181323 -34408 181323 -34409 '0' I CROTTY JOSEPH J & PATRICIA A COSGROVE JOYCE CARR 2 .4TH AVE 2707 PALATINE DOC. 110 RAY SYMMONDS RD "AK... , WA 98902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98902 INDEX YAKIMA, WA 98901 81323 -33410 181323 -34417 181323 -33008 UDY F PILGER JUSTIN & MEIJA J YOUNKER KARLA R HUSEBY 004 W CHESTNUT AVE 2702 PALATINE AVE 215 S 32ND AVE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 • 181323 -32568 181323 -34432 181323 -34419 KATE HAUGE KATHRYN E BACKUS KELLI GREENE 2812 W YAKIMA AVE 6506 34TH AVE NW 2706 PALATINE AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 SEATTLE, WA 98117 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34407 181323 -31508 181323 -33424 KELLY MCKINNEY KELLY R & DEBORAH B HARMON KENNETH G & GERTRUDE JOHNSOI' 209 S 28TH AVE 2408 W YAKIMA AVE 202 S 28TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2833 YAKIMA, WA 96902 181323 -31509 181323 -34467 181323 -34010 KENNETH G & RACHAEL A LENZI KENNETH J & SANDRA M FLINT KEVIN W & CHERYL A SCHMOE 2410 W YAKIMA AVE 215 S 25TH AVE 212 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 96902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -31479 181323 -32567 161323 -33464 KIMBERLY J MURPHY KRISTAN J & MARTA E MORRIS LARRY & SHARON MINER 20215 28TH AVE SE 2902 W YAKIMA AVE 212 S 31ST AVE BOTHELL, WA 98012 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2843 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -32434 181323 -34413 181323 -34487 LAWRENCE L & LINDA HUCK LESLIE PADILLA LINDA HUCK 3008 W YAKIMA AVE 2607 PALATINE AVE 3008 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3776 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33411 181323 -33462 181323 -33402 LINDA S YATES LISA & JOSEPH P DELORME LISA J PRITCHARD 202 S 30TH AVE 2912 W CHESTNUT AVE 203 S 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34415 181323 -34012 181323-34013 LISA J RUITHERFORD LISA K WALLACE LISA .% W'.. AC' 2610 PALATINE AVE 218 S 25TH AVE 2 H • " "E YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3777 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAK MA, WA 98902 181323 -33409 181323 -33406 181323 -31506 LISA N FORTIER LUCILLE S YOUNG LYLE I & KAREN M C BONNY 3008 W CHESTNUT AVE 208 S 31ST AVE 2402 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3630 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33408 181323 -32428 181323 -34405 LYNN TARANGO M KIM KOVALIK MANKA FAMILY TRUST 210 S 31ST AVE 3112 W YAKIMA AVE 211 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33422 181323 -3342 181323 -31052 MARCUS & JILL FRY •RCUS J F MARIAN E MARKS 3012 W CHESTNUT AVE 112 • .T . /. 42522 212TH AVE SE YAKIMA, WA 98902 Y'. I WA 98902 DOC. ENUMCLAW, WA 98022 INDEX 181323 -34024 181323 -31477 181323 -33460 MARK S & SHEILA S BERMAN MARY BETH BRADLEY MARY DEERAN COOPER 205 S 28TH AVE 2710 W YAKIMA AVE 3606 RICHEY RD YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -1551 181323 -33491 181323 -32446 181323 -34438 MATTHEW & ANN TWEEDY MELINDA ACKLEY MELINDA E WATTERSON 210 S 28TH AVE 3003 W CHESTNUT AVE 2601 W WALNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3775 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33434 181323 -34425 181323 -33455 MICHAEL & KATHY L KOVATCH MICHAEL & LORI DANFORTH MICHAEL 8 & JULIANNE BALMELL: 214 S 28TH AVE PO BOX 43 207 S 30TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98907 -0043 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34430 181323 -34423 181323 -33425 MICHAEL D & MARIA JOCYLANIA T JO MICHAEL S HOLTZINGER MIKE & LORI SCHMITT 2602 W CHESTNUT AVE 2707 W WALNUT 2810 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3726 181323 -33400 181323 -33420 181323 -32440 MONICA HULUBEI NANCY MALLAHAN NANCY RUSH 1611 1/2 S 5TH AVE 3102 W CHESTNUT AVE 3103 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2745 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2744 181323 -33428 181323 -33436 181323 -31521 NORA B KIRSCHNER PALMER P WRIGHT PARRISH FAMILY TRUST 208 S 28TH AVE 8307 VIEWCREST WAY 2607 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3775 YAKIMA, WA 98908 -1164 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3721 523 -31513 181323 -32563 181323 -34468 PATRICK R & ROSALIE M COCKRILL PATSY A REYNOLDS PATTI F NAGLE 2405 W CHESTNUT 2910 W YAKIMA AVE 219 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -32559 181323 -34011 181323 -33404 PAUL H & BEATRICE REISS PEGGY BORDEN PEGGY J DAVENPORT 9820 NE E 20TH ST 214 S 25TH AVE 205 S 32ND AVE BELLEVUE, WA 98004 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -31483 181323 -34400 181323 -34020 PETER K & ELIZABETH A HARVESON RACHEL A & JEREMY D SMITH RALPH &JACQUELINE -TR CALL 2609 W CHESTNUT AVE 210 S 24TH AVE 2608 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3721 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3722 181323 -34005 181323 -32550 181323 -34406 RAYMOND J. MILLER REYA WHITCOMB GORE RHONDA FRUITT 2412 W CHESTNUT AVE 8 S 28TH AVE 4726 36TH AVE NE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 SEATTLE, WA 98105 1fl'323 -34007 181323 -32570 181323 -32442 \RD D & CARLA M ADAMS RICHARD J & SANDRA K FAIRBROOK R RICHARD M & DEBRA J STRAIT W CHESTNUT AVE 2806 W YAKIMA AVE 3011 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 DOC YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 INDEX 181323 -34017 181323 -34420 - 81323 -33459 RITA M KINDER ROBERT & ELLEN SKARIN ROBERT & KATHRYN L ORTIZ 201 S 26TH AVE 213 S 28TH AVE 2110 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3708 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33461 181323 -31518 181323 -31519 ROBERT 8 & DARLENE FAIRBROOK ROBIN N & SHARON L CUSHING ROBIN ' & SHARON C SHING 2910 W CHESTNUT AVE 2601 W CHESTNUT AVE 2 :81. 'ES' E YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3728 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3721 YAKIMA, W■ 98902 -3721 181323 -34416 181323 -32432 181323 -32549 ROGER B ROWLES RONALD A & SANDRA A MORRIER RONALD C & JENNIFER LOYD 2612 PALATINE AVE 3102 W YAKIMA AVE 6 S 28TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33007 181323 -31476 181323 -34015 ROSE MARIE ALLGA.IER RUSSELL & SARA C MAIER RUSSELL A & COMILLE L BECKER 816 S 35TH AVE 2712 W YAKIMA AVE 224 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 1:1323 -34016 181323 -32443 181323 -31046 R S - A COI L. BECKER RUTH IRENE HESSEY REVOCABLE LIVI RYAN M & GENIPHER R MESSER 22- 2, , , ' 3009 W CHESTNUT AVE 2510 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33466 181323 -31491 181323 -34435 RYAN S & REBECCA A BOHLKE SCOTT A & MEGAN B GORANSON SCOTT BLOOMER 12036 NORTHPARK AVE N 2702 W YAKIMA AVE 216 S 26TH AVE SEATTLE, WA 98133 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -31044 181323 -33403 181323 -34431 SHAWN F & VICKI A MC VEY STACEY C LOCKE STEPHEN A & CANDACE A GRIFF 2506 W YAKIMA AVE 7709 OLMSTEAD COURT 208 S 26TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98908 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3709 181323 -34426 181323 -31053 1: 1323 -31511 STEVE & LORI S GRUNEWALD STEVE ROGERS S EVE •OG ".S ( 1) 2609 W WALNUT ST 2501 W CHESTNUT 2 • W S:'`UT YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3730 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34008 181323 -34469 181323 -34401 STEVEN T FOREMAN SUZANNE L NOBLE TERESA M SWEESY PO BOX 1651 221 S 25TH AVE 212 S 24TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98907 -1651 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3704 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 181323 -31515 181323 -33456 181323 -34004 THOMAS & BERTHA MULVIHILL THOMAS 0 & DEBORAH MC LEAN THOMAS P FRANK 2401 CHESTNUT AVE 205 S 30TH AVE 205 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34484 181323 -34437 181323 -31493 THOMAS T & SARAH L WIXSON TIMMY & JANE A GILLIHAN TIMOTHY L & SARAH BONW 209 S 26TH AVE 220 S 26TH AVE 2706 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 D©c YAKIMA, WA 98902 INDEX 181323 -34402 181323 -32441 N 1 2 c. ,181323 -33405 TODD & JULIA L KENNEDY TOM ISHAM TYGH & AIMEE LYBBERT 214 S 24TH AVE 3101 W CHESTNUT AVE 207 S 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323- 33469 181323 -31514 181323 -32437 VIRGINIA C. GABLE WALTER A & SHANNA M HEFNER III WALTER H & NORA A RANTA 219 S 32ND AVE PO BOX 9562 5 S 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98909 -9562 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34421 181323 -31507 181323 -33432 WILLIAM P. VETSCH WILLIAM R & ANN VICK MARTY YAKIMA MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 217 S 28TH AVE 2406 W YAKIMA AVE 2811 TIETON DR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323- 449 181323 -33453 181323 -33457 YA IMA A" L y `OS P YAK, MA VA 3.,..Y ME i , P YAKIMA VALLE . ME 001 28 IET01•: DR 281 TI ._ON or 2 <:11 T, ON D' YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKI'= WA 98902 YA ., •, 98902 1813 3 -33426 181323 -33452 181323 -33450 YAKI VA. ,Y M' 9S. YAKI VALL Y ME OS' 110 Y ■ KIMA ■ LLEY Mr/S.'±-91 ] 2811 'I ON 4R 2811 IETOL ►' 28 1 T E '!N D: YAKIMA, WA 96902 YAKIMA WA 98 + YA w., WA ':902 181323 -33438 181323 -33442 181323 -33445 9 YAKI' A VALLEY ,, EMO'I.L HISP YA' IMA .L. _Y MS`IAL HOSP YAKIMA V. EY ∎'E.. "AL HOSP 2811 TIE •_ D: 28 1 T TON D' 28 1 TI'`TON YAKI t, '+A "-'902 YAK , WA 98902 YA , WA 98902 1L z3 -33446 f . 181323 -33447 181323 -33454 II YA IM. 1.LL MEMVRIA P Y' KIMA -'_LEY M' 0' A Ha..• YAKIMA V. Y MT' "R .: OSP 281 . :IE `IN' DR 2: 1 TT TO DR 28 1 TI ' ON IR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAK :.., WA 9 + '02 YAKIMA WA 9 : -02 I 181323- 477 181323 -33478 il 181323 -33479 Y KIMA A LE / ': EMO It % ' YA IMA +.LLE M •: IAL HOSP YAKIMA ALLEY "EMS_ HOSP 28 IET01 IR 28,1 T.'ET►i 'R 2:11 T n!. ON oR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAK . WA 98902 YA'''.. W 98902 181323 -33492 181323 -33510 181323-33004 fp AKIMA VALLEY MEM /R " HOSP Y..KIMA V. LEY MO' HOSP YA IMA V , ' AL HOSPIT, .811 IETO 1' 2111 T Tv D. 281 T -TON DR Y "4K A, A' 9891 YA >I WA •:902 YAKI A, WA 98902 181323 -33413 181323 -33414 J 181323 -33415 YAKIMA `LLEY -EMI' AL HOSPITAL YAKIMA V. LEY ME - 4'Ie SPITAL YAK MA V:,LEY -0'IAL HOSPIT: 21'1 T:E *N 5' 2:11 T TO3 DR 2811 TT. -TO •R YA - , WA 98902 YA' . , WA 9:'02 YAKIMA, WA 98902 18 -33416 181323 -33417 D 1 81323 33418 r„, Y ' V. MEMORIA ':OSPITAL 'KIMA ,.LL MEMO ?AL HOSPITAL AKIM. ►'.LLEY E, w *'rAL HOSPIT; 2 '` ON DR 2811 TIETON CR D�+ 811 IET* • IR YAr jA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 �N ©C V YA•_MA, WA 98902 181 23 -33429 181323 - 3343 0 191323 -33435 YAK IMA VAL . V M ORIAL SPITAL Y•: KIMA VA . MEMORIAL HOSPITAL YA_tIMA VA'_ t' EMORI'• HOSPIT; 2811 TIE rN DR 28'.1 T - ON DR 281' TI ON DR YAKIMA WA 98902 YAK ,•, WA 98902 YAKI" WA 98902 191 23-334. 181323-33451 ., 18 323-33465 j YAKIMA LEY EMO' 11 HOSPIT LLEY E RIAL HOSPITAL YA IM F AL YA IMA .k A ALL .MO'IAL HOSPI 2611 TON DR 281 ETio .R 28.1 I get DR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAK '0., WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323-33473 181323-33474 9 181323-33475 YAK MA V .EY 40R1510SPITAL YAKI V EY Mr e, HOSPITAL YAKtMA V'LLE mr%e. AL HOSPI' 2811 'TON 2' 2811 T TO DR 281_ Tlk DR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKI—, WA 9:02 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323-33460 YA IMA V L. ME 'R , HOSPITAL 281 T 'TON D' YAKI,', WA 98902 238 labels printed for map sheet bargehist flttc C Pub / 41S Preservxhon )-0)q DOC. INDEX 1 .L.A.6,a, 11CLJG %JUG — 10611. l'1JI.13.,G VI, r LOULIL 1118. r liti11J11 011 V.)/ 1 J. L.. f agc 1 Ui 1 lbarra, Rosalinda :rom: Legals [legalsgyakirnaherald.corn] Sent: Wednesday, May 13, 2009 5:13 PM To: lbarra, Rosalinda Subject: Re: 05-15-09 Legal Notice: BCNA Phase One - Legal Notice ofPublic Hrg. Publish on 05/15. Acct 10952 I've scheduled the attached legal notice for 5/15, for a total cost of S97.30. On 5/13/09 12:16 PM, "Ibarra, Rosalinda" <ribarra©ci.yakima.wa.us> wrote: CITY OF YAKIMA NOTI HISTORIC LIC BCNA Phase One - Legal Notice of Public Hrg FREsERvATIoN COM MISSION Please publish only once on Friday May 15, 2009. NOTICE IS HEREBY GIV- EN that [he Yakima His- toric, Preservation Com. Charge acct 10952 mission will conduct a public hearing to consider the recommendation of the City of Yakima's His- Please reply with a confirmation of publication. Thanks! toric Preservation Liaison to place the Barge-Chest- nut Neighborhood Historic District - Phase One locat- , ed east of 32nd Avenue, west of. 241h Avenue ,South of Barge Street and north of Walnut Street on Rosalinda Ibarra the Yakima Register of Historic Places as a His- toric D(strict. Planning Specialist The purpose of this open record public hearing is to determine it the proposed I district meets the criteria: ribarra@ci.yakima.wa.us required for this designa— lion. At the conclusion of this hearing the Commis- sion will consider their rec. ommendation to the Yaki ma City Council concern- ing this nomination. City of Yakima Written comments may be submitted to the Historic Preservation Commission rn two ways: 129 North 2nd Street 1) Send a letter via regular mail to "City of Yak(ma„ Department of Community & Development, Yakima, WA 98901 129 Economic N. 2nd. Street, Yaki- ma, We. 98901"; or, 2) E-mail your comments p: (509) 575-6183 mcbride@ciyakima.wa.0 s. Please include in the e- I mail subject line, "Barge f: (509) 575-6105 Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District - Phase One: And also include your name and mailing addresS. The public hearing will be held on Thursday, May 28, 2009 at 5:30 p.m., or soon thereafter, in the Council Chambers at Ya- kima City Hall, 129 North 2nd Street, Yakima, WA, rra r•J iNJ IV ".1 ry rs.i Please contact Vaughn McBride, Historic Preser- Simon Sizer valion Liaison at 576-6315 if you have any questions egal/Obituary Clerk about this nomination, ,kima Herald-Republic Dated this 15th day of May, 2009, -hone: 509-577-7740 (09550500) May 15, 2009 Fax: 509-577-7766 legals@yakimaherald.com INDEX # () 5/14/2009 ^ a 1 "^ / lbarra Rosalinda From: lbarra, Rosalinda Sent: Friday, May 15, 2009 8:27 AM To: Adriana Janovich - Yakima Herald; Barbara Serrano 'YHK; Brackney, Rosanne; Brown, Michael; Bruce Smith Yak. Business Times; Chris Bristol - YHR; Claudia Moreno NoUoias Locales; Criag Troianello - Yakima Herald Rep.; Erin Snelgrove Yak. Herald Rep; Gabriel Martinez KDNA; George Finch - Business Journal; |bame. Rosalinda; KDNA; KIMA TV; KNDO News; KUNS-TV Univision; Lance Tormey; Lindsay France; Lou BartoUi; Lozano, Bonnie; Mai Hoang; Mark Morey; Marta Isabel Sanchez - Univiskon| Mike Ba|na|i KAPP; Mike Bastinelli; NWCN; Randy Beehler YPAC; Scott Mayes; Yakima Business Journal; Yakima Herald Republic Newspaper Subject: 05'15'09 Press Release: Notice of Historic Preservation Public Hearing - BargeChestnut Attachments: Notice of Historic Preservation Public Hearing - BargeChestnut.doc For more inforniation please contact Vaughn McBride at 509-576-6315. Thanks! u0supuda/mznm Planning Specialist rihuna@ciyukima.vu.u, City n[Yakima 129 North 2nd Street Yakima, WA 98901 p:(309) j7J'G183 f: (509) 575-6105 • INDEX � � �� 5/15/2004 - - CITY OF YAKIMA HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission will conduct a public hearing to consider and receive public comments regarding the establishment of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District — Phase One located in the vicinity east of 32 Avenue, west of 24 Avenue, south of Barge Street and north of Walnut Street - on the Yakima Register of Historic Races as a Historic District. The purpose of this open record public hearing is to determine if the proposed district meets the criteria required for this designation. At the conclusion of this hearing the Commission will consider their recommendation to the Yakima City Council concerning this nomination. Written comments may be submitted to the Historic Preservation Commission in two ways: 1) Send a letter via regular mail to "City of Yakima„ Department of Community & Economic Development, 129 N. 2" Street, Yakima, Wa. 98901"; or, 2) E-mail your comments to vmcbride@ci.yakimawa.us. Please include in the e-mail subject line, "Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District — Phase One."And also include your name and mailing address. The public hearing will be held on Thursday, May 28, 2009 at 5:30 p.m., or soon thereafter, in the Council Chambers at Yakima City Hall, 129 North 2 Street, Yakima, WA. Please contact Vaughn McBride, Historic Preservation Liaison at 576-6315 if you have any questions about this nomination. Dated this 15 day of May, 2009. DOC. INDEX # Ci) 1 X Cr) 0) CN1 C U.I Z 04 04 w > LI-I 2 > Z Z > < > C\ < < 1 < C\ 0 1 H M 2 Z H LO H U-1 CO imi-i C\I Z CN4 > Z > Z Z 0 M H CO 0 CI CO Z Z j I t W rZG Y E AK 3 I T MA AVE 1 LLI > UJ < > 1 ap C11 1 — HOME DR UJ \A/ Lt !UT ST 1--- < c i . ess, ?* c.4 0 u) Ct CO CNI Cf) LL1 > 1 C) SHELI LLI cv) > U) VE ill LLI City of Yakima, Washington M Subject Site FILE NO: - - I Notified Propery Owners APPLICANT: City of Yakima REQUEST Barge Chestnut Historic District - Phase One DOC, LOCATION: Barge St - Walnut St - S 24th Ave - S 32nd AveiNDEX 1 inch = 500 feet CITY OF YAKIMA, PLANNING DIVISION LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL I, Rosalinda Ibarra, as an employee of the City of Yakima, Planning Division, have transmitted to: Debbie Moore, Yakima City Clerk, by hand delivery, the following documents: 1. Mailing labels for BARGE - CHESTNUT HISTORIC DISTRICT - PHASE ONE including all labels for property owners within the subject property, agencies and parties of record. 2. One vicinity map. 3. I have also transmitted to Debbie Moore, Yakima City Clerk, by e-mail, a Legal Notice which was published for the Historic Preservation Public Hearing. This will supply information to be included in the City Clerk's legal notice of the City Council Public Hearing. , Signed this 1 day of May, 2009. L___DDCUrACLy osalinda lbarra Planning Specialist Received By: Ate 1 Date: ( , DOC. INDEX D - 1,81323 181323-33427 181323-34009 AARON & SHEROLYN BERDAN ALTON N DRUSE AMY LOUISE RAVENHOLT 2808 W YAKIMA AVE 204 S 28TH AVE 210 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902-3775 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323-31043 181323-32553 181323-32436 ANDREW J BUSH ARTHUR L & CYNTHIA WILLIAMS BRENNA L NELSON 2504 W YAKIMA AVE 2811 W CHESTNUT AVE 3002 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323-33458 181323-34001 181323-31492 BRENTON J & HANNAH R NOEL- BRET W BOHOSKEY BRIAN & HOLLY DUNHAM WHEELER 2902 W CHESTNUT 2402 W CHESTNUT AVE 2704 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 989022839 181323-32439 181323-31512 181323-31510 BRIAN B & JOSEPHINE L ULLOM BRIAN J & DARCIE R ROBERTS BROOKE & J TJARNBERG CRESWELI 3105 W CHESTNUT AVE 2409 WEST CHESTNUT 2412 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323-31486 181323-32564 181323-32433 BRUCE A & SUSAN D ROGERS BRUCE C & DOROTHY E BENSON C G & MARIA W LINSCHOOTEN 2605 W CHESTNUT AVE 2908 W YAKIMA AVE 3010 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902-2761 181323-34021 181323-34549 181323-34023 CARL V & CLAUDIA C PETERSON CAROL E FAITH CAROL L & KARL VANEVENh—EN 2612 W CHESTNUT 213 S 25TH AVE 210 S 28TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902-3775 181323-31050 181323-34022 181323-34485 CAROL M LOUDON CHRISTINE CORBETT CONKLIN CHRISTINE S & CRISTOBAL LOPE2 2507 W CHESTNUT AVE 2702 W CHESTNUT AVE 215 S 26TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 ' YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902-3708 181323-32444 181323-32427 181323-34489 CHRISTOPHER J & JESSICA L ALBERT CONNIE MCGLOTHERN COREY HODGE 3007 W CHESTNUT 3110 W YAKIMA AVE 2507 W WALNUT ST YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902-2763 YAKIMA, WA 98902-3729 r 181323-34429 181323-34412 181323-31489 CYNTHIA A TREVINO CYNTHIA ANN MC CONNELL CYNTHIA HOVLAND 2604 W CHESTNUT AVE 2609 PALATINE AVE 2610 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902-2354 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 18132 —31490 10 181323-34466 181323-33401 CY HO NI D BRUCE SIMPSON DANA E & LISA A ALLISON 2610 s. IMA ., 216 S 24TH AVE 5509 W LINCOLN AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 58908 DOC. INDEX 181323-34428 181323 ........ .....--- ---- 781323-32552 DANIEL & KATHLEEN JENNINGS DANIEL M TAMSKY DANNY L & CATHY A FLOYD 2606 W CHESTNUT AVE PO BOX 2623 2807 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902-3722 YAKIMA, WA 98907-2623 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34439 181323 -34436 181323 -32445 DAVID & DEBORA AXFORD DAVID E DAVIS DAVID T REICH 2603 W WALNUT ST 218 S 26TH AVE 3005 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3730 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 181323 -34014 181323 -32429 181323 -32447 DEAN R CROW DEBORAH L BLACK DEBRA 3 BLODGETT -GO1NS 220 S 25TH AVE 3108 W YAKIMA AVE 3001 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 93902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 181323 -31482 181323 -34414 181323 -32438 DENNIS W & JULIE A DEAN DEREK C PRESCOTT DERRY W JEFFERIS 2701 W CHESTNUT AVE 2608 PALATINE AVE 4975 MANFIELD ST YAKIMA, WA 96902 -3723 YAKIMA, WA 98902 SAN DIEGO, California 92116 -1 181323 - 34411 181323 -34481 181323 -31494 DEWARD K & CARLY L OSBORN DONALD & DENISE M SZOLOMAYER DONALD E. & FLORA M. BROOKS 2701 PALATINE AVE 205 S 26TH AVE 2708 W YAKIMA. AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 96902 181323 -32431 181323 -34003 181323 -34434 DONDA LAMBERT DONNA J. PEYTON DORENE K CHURCH 3104 W YAKIMA AVE 208 S 24TH AVE 214 S 26TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 96902 -2763 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98902 161,23 -33471 181323 -33419 181323 -32547 DOROTHY E BONSER DOUGLAS BERNDT DOUGLAS L FEDERSPIEL 218 S. 31ST AVE 3106 W CHESTNUT AVE 2 S 28TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2816 181323 -34482 181323 -34483 181323 -32551 DOUGLAS P & LAURIE A KANYER DO■GL' P & A - R' A KANYER DOUGLAS R & KELLEY C CAREY 207 S 26TH AVE 20 S 2.:H A 2801 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3708 YAK '�, W 98902 -3708 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3725 181323 -31051 181323 -33010 181323 -31520 DUANE F & CHERI 0 HEILMAN EDUARDO PACHECO EDWARD & JOSEPHINE CONLON TRU 2505 W CHESTNUT AVE 402 S 31ST AVE 2703 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3719 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -31488 181323 -31049 181323 -31517 EDWARD V & CHRISTINE SCHRANTZ ELAINE J. STEVENSON ERIC F & PAMELA SIMISON 2606 W YAKIMA AVE 2509 W CHESTNUT AVE 2602 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 18' 1 -34465 181323 -31042 181323 -34410 EF JSTAFSON ERIC 5 7 CHRISTINA M ELDRIDGE ERICK ETAL AMUNDSON 21 24TH AVE 2502 W YAKIMA AVE 2703 PALATINE AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 DOC. YAKIMA, WA 98902-3780 INDEX 181323 -33463 181323 -34424 # _ b _1 181323-34002 ERIK D & ALEAH K MICKELSON EVE MARIE DRAPER FRANK & LEAH VORNBROCK HEIBER 211 S 32ND AVE 2705 W WALNUT ST 2406 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 96902 -3732 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -32435 161323 -31522 181323 -34427 FREDERIQUE & ROBERT SPENCER GEANETTE PIPES GEORGE R. KELLY 3006 W YAKIMA AVE 6721 EASY ST 2607 W WALNUT ST YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2761 _ YAKIMA, WA 98903 -9666 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3730 181323 -32560 181323 -33472 181323 -33470 GINGER MC ILVANIE GLENN & NORKA L DAVIS GLENN M & COLLEEN JAKEMAN 2909 W CHESTNUT AVE 214 S 31ST AVE 220 S 31ST AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34463 181323 -31047 181323 -31048 GREGORY J & BARBARA J KINLOCH GREGORY R FAIN 1 CECIL & JANE M TERK 222 S 24TH AVE PO BOX 1941 2711 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98907 -1941 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3723 181323 -31476 111 181323 -32562 181323 -34433 CEt L P.RK JAMES D FORSYTHE JAMES DOLE 2,11 ++ S AVE PO BOX 8317 212 S 26TH AVE YA- I'' +'•, WA 98902 -3723 YAKIMA, WA 98908 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34422 181323 -34486 181323 -33412 JAMES H RICHARDSON JAMES MC CONNELL JAMES N & LORA L BARRETT 219 S 28TH AVE 217 S 26TH AVE 455 NE 17TH ST 424 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3708 MCMINNVILLE, Oregon 97126 -331 181323 -32556 181323 -34418 181323 -33407 JAMES P DUFAULT JASON M & ALLISON M DAVILA JASON SORENSON 2901 W CHESTNUT AVE 2704 PALATINE AVE 209 S 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3727 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3675 181323 -33468 161323 -32565 181323 -32566 JEFF S & LEA CLARK JEFFERY S FEEN JEFFREY A & STEPHANIE Y MANN 217 S 32ND AVE 2906 W YAKIMA AVE 2904 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3675 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -32590 181323 -33421 181323 -34488 JIM & MARIA BERCOT JOEL R & DONNA M ELDER JOHN C & CAROLYN GIOVANINI 2911 W CHESTNUT AVE 7007 W LINCOLN AVE 223 S 26TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 96908 YAKIMA, WA 98908 -1239 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34006 181323 -32430 181323 -32558 JOHN M & CHERYL A CORNELL JONATHAN & HEIDI HULL JOSEPH A & AVRIL PANZARINO 2504 W CHESTNUT AVE 3106 W YAKIMA AVE 2903 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3720 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3727 181323 -34464 181323 -34408 181323 -34409 JOSEPH I CROTTY JOSEPH J & PATRICIA A COSGROVE JOYCE CARR 220 S 24TH AVE 2707 PALATINE 110 RAY SYMMONDS RD YAKIMA, WA 99902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98902 DOC. YAKIMA, WA 98901 INDEX # 0- ! 181323 -33410 181323 - 34417 181323 -33008 JUDY F PILGER JUSTIN & MEIJA J YOUNKER KARLA R HUSEBY 3004 W CHESTNUT AVE 2702 PALATINE AVE 215 S 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -32568 181323 -34432 181323 - 34419 KATE HAUGE KATHRYN E BACKUS KELLI GREENE 2812 W YAKIMA AVE 6506 34TH AVE NW 2706 PALATINE AVE YAKIMA, WA 96902 SEATTLE, WA 98117 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34407 181323 -31508 181323 -33424 KELLY MCKINNEY KELLY R & DEBORAH B HARMON KENNETH G & GERTRUDE JOHNSON 209 S 28TH AVE 2408 W YAKIMA AVE 202 S 28TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2833 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -31509 181323 -34467 181323 -34010 KENNETH G & RACHAEL A LENZI KENNETH J & SANDRA M FLINT KEVIN W & CHERYL A SCHMCE 2410 W YAKIMA AVE 215 S 25TH AVE 212 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 96902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -31479 181323 -32567 181323 -33464 KIMBERLY J MURPHY KRISTAN J & MARTA E MORRIS LARRY & SHARON MINER 20215 28TH AVE SE 2902 W YAKIMA AVE 212 S 31ST AVE BOTHELL, WA 98012 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2843 YAKIMA, WA 98902 161323 -32434 181323 -34413 181323 -34487 LAWRENCE L & LINDA HUCK LESLIE PADILLA LINDA HUCK 3008 W YAKIMA AVE 2607 PALATINE AVE 3008 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3778 YAKIMA, WA 98902 1,_i23 -33411 181323 - 33462, 181323 -33402 LINDA S YATES LISA & JOSEPH P DELORME LISA J PRITCHARD 202 S 30TH AVE 2912 W CHESTNUT AVE 203 S 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34415 181323 -34012 181323 -34013 LISA J RUITHERFORD LISA K WALLACE LI A r WA .ACE 2610 PALATINE AVE 218 S 25TH AVE 21: 5 V• YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3777 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAK MA, WA 9890 181323 -33409 181323 -33406 181323 -31506 LISA N FORTIER LUCILLE S YOUNG LYLE I & KAREN M C BONNY 3008 W CHESTNUT AVE 208 S 31ST AVE 2402 W YAKIMA AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3630 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33408 181323 -32428 181323 -34405 LYNN TARANGO M KIM KOVALIK MANKA FAMILY TRUST 210 S 31ST AVE 3112 W YAKIMA AVE 211 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 1'23-33422 181323 - 33423: 181323 -31052 I S & JILL FRY MAR US JI 'Y MARIAN E MARKS W CHESTNUT AVE 301 CH:. -, NUT AVE 42522 212TH AVE SE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 DOC. ENUMCLAW, WA 98022 INDEX # D - V 181323 -34024 181323 - 31477 181323 -33460 MARK S & SHEILA S BERMAN MARY BETH BRADLEY MARY DEERAN COOPER 205 S 28TH AVE 2710 W YAKIMA AVE 3606 RICHEY RD YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -1551 181323 -33491 181323 -32446 181323 -34438 MATTHEW & ANN TWEEDY MELINDA ACKLEY MELINDA E WATTERSON 210 S 28TH AVE 3003 W CHESTNUT AVE 2601 W WALNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3775 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33434 181323 -34425 181323 -33455 MICHAEL & KATHY L KOVATCH MICHAEL & LORI DANFORTH MICHAEL B & JULIANNE BALMELLI 214 S 28TH AVE PO BOX 43 207 S 30TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98907 -0043 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34430 181323 -34423 181323 -33425 MICHAEL D & MARIA JOCYLANIA T JO MICHAEL S HOLTZINGER MIKE & LORI SCHMITT 2602 W CHESTNUT AVE 2707 W WALNUT 2810 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3726 181323 -33400 181323 -33420 181323 -32440 MONICA HULUBEI NANCY MALLAHAN NANCY RUSH 1611 1/2 S 5TH AVE 3102 W CHESTNUT AVE 3103 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2745 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2744 181323 -33426 181323 -33436 181323 -31521 JORA B KIRSCHNER PALMER P WRIGHT PARRISH FAMILY TRUST 208 S 28TH AVE 8307 VIEWCREST WAY 2607 W CHESTNUT AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3775 YAKIMA, WA 98908 -1164 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3721 181323 -31513 181323 -32563 181323 -34468 ?ATRICK R & ROSALIE M COCKRILL PATSY A REYNOLDS PATTI F NAGLE 2405 W CHESTNUT 2910 W YAKIMA AVE 219 5 25TH AVE (AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 L81323 -32559 181323 -34011 181323 -33404 ?AUL H & BEATRICE REISS PEGGY BORDEN PEGGY J DAVENPORT 3620 NE E 20TH ST 214 S 25TH AVE 205 S 32ND AVE 3ELLEVUE, WA 98004 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 ?81323 -3 1463 181323 -34400 181323 -34020 ?ETER K & ELIZABETH A HARVESON RACHEL A & JEREMY D SMITH RALPH &JACQUELINE -TR CALL 1609 W CHESTNUT AVE 210 S 24TH AVE 2608 W CHESTNUT AVE !AKIMA, WA 98902 -3721 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3722 °61323 -34005 181323 -32550 181323 -34406 LAYMOND J. MILLER REYA WHITCOMB GORE RHONDA PRUITT '412 W CHESTNUT AVE 8 S 28TH AVE 4726 36TH AVE NE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 SEATTLE, WA 98105 .81323 -34007 181323 -32570 181323 -32442 LICHARD D & CARLA M ADAMS RICHARD J & SANDRA K FAIREROOK R RICHARD M & DEBRA J STR '506 W CHESTNUT AVE 2806 W YAKIMA AVE 3011 W CHESTNUT AVE 'AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 D ©r YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 INDEX .81323 -34017 181323 -34420 # D..._ 181323-33459 '.ITA M KINDER ROBERT & ELLEN SILARIN ROBERT & KATHRYN L ORTIZ :01 S 26TH AVE 213 S 28TH AVE 2110 W YAKIMA AVE 'AKIMA, WA 98902 -3708 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33461 181323 -31518 181323 -31519 ROBERT B & DARLENE FAIRBROOK ROBIN N & SHARON L CUSHING ROBI N & . "ARON CU 2910 W CHESTNUT AVE 2601 W CHESTNUT AVE 2601 W CH'S U AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3728 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3721 YAKI.. A 98.02 -3721 181323 -34416 181323 -32432 181323 -32549 ROGER B ROWLES RONALD A & SANDRA A MORRIER RONALD C & JENNIFER LOYD 2612 PALATINE AVE 3102 W YAKIMA AVE 6 S 28TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33007 181323 -31476 181323 -34015 ROSE MARIE ALLGAIER RUSSELL & SARA C MAIER RUSSELL A & COMILLE L BECKER 816 S 35TH AVE 2712 W YAKIMA AVE 224 S 25TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34016 181323 -32443 181323 -31046 RU ";SELL COM L ECKER RUTH IRENE HESSEY REVOCABLE LIVI RYAN M & GENIPHER R MESSER 224 0 25 H ; <VE 3009 W CHESTNUT AVE 2510 W YAKIMA AVE YAKI` WA 9:'t2 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -2742 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33466 181323 -31491 181323 -34435 RYAN S & REBECCA A BOHLKE SCOTT A & MEGAN B GORANSON SCOTT BLOOMER 12036 NORTHPARK AVE N 2702 W YAKIMA AVE 216 S 26TH AVE SEATTLE, WA 98133 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181,43 -31044 181323 -33403 181323 -34431 SHAWN F & VICKI A MC VEY STACEY C LOCKE STEPHEN A & CANDACE A GRIFF 2506 W YAKIMA AVE 7709 OLMSTEAD COURT 208 S 26TH AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98908 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3709 181323 -34426 181323 -31053 18 323 -31511 STEVE & LORI S GRUNEWALO STEVE ROGERS STEVE :kGER: 2609 W WALNUT ST 2501 W CHESTNUT 250% C;E1T (AKIMA, WA 98902 -3730 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, W 98902 L81323 -34008 181323 -34469 181323 -34401 ;TEVEN T FOREMAN SUZANNE L NOBLE TERESA M SWEESY 30 BOX 1651 221 S 25TH AVE 212 S 24TH. AVE (AKIMA, WA 98907 -1651 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3704 YAKIMA, WA 98902 -3737 .81323 -31515 181323 -33456 181323 -34004 3HOMAS & BERTHA MULVIHILL THOMAS 0 & DEBORAH MC LEAN THOMAS 0 FRANK ;401 CHESTNUT AVE 205 S 30TH AVE 205 S 25TH AVE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 .83` - -34484 161323 -34437 181323 -31493 7H T & SARAH L WIXSON TIMMY & JANE A GILLIHAN TIMOTHY L & SARAH BONWELL 0 46TH AVE 220 S 26TH AVE 2706 W YAKIMA AVE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 DOC. INDEX .81323-34402 181323-32441 # Imo; 181323 -33405 'ODD & JULIA L KENNEDY TOM ISHAM TYGH & AIMEE LYBBERT 14 S 24TH AVE 3101 W CHESTNUT AVE 207 S 32ND AVE AKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -33469 181323 -31514 181323 -32437 VIRGINIA C. GABLE WALTER A & SHANNA M HEFNER III WALTER H & NORA A RANTA 219 S 32ND AVE PO BOX 9562 5 S 32ND AVE YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98909 -9562 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323 -34421 181323 -31507 181323 -33432 WILLIAM F. VETSCH WILLIAM R & ANN VICK MARTY YAKIMA MEMORIAL HOSPITAL 217 S 28TH AVE 2406 W YAKIMA AVE 2811 TIETON DR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 1.1323 -33449 181323-33453 181323 -33457 YAKIMA V.- EY MEM HOSP 3'3MA. VA -_ Y MEM HOSP YAKIMA VALL' M HOSP 2811 TI. TO *R 2.1' TI' ON * ' — 281 TIET• - DR YA WA 9899 YAKI WA 98902 YA 1IMA, nA 98902 181323 -3 -426 181323 -33452 181323- 33450 0 YAKIMA A EY MEM • P '" 0 Y. IMA .. . Y ME •SP AS C YAKIMA VAL Y HOSPITAL '811 :'IETO !' 28 IETON D' 28.1 TIE'.N DR Y _;A, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YA �.). ;' WA 98902 181323-3343: 181323-33442 181323 -33445 YAKIMA VA EY ME'' e :IAL HO YAAKIMA AL . MEMO HOSP YAKIMA VAL -' , ,t MORI HOSP 11 TI ON DR 2' :1 IETON D' 2811 TIE'•N DR YA' d WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAK... WA 98902 181323 -33446 -- 0 181323 -33447 D 181323 -33454 YAKIMA VALL' MEMO". ._. .!'• YAK MA VALL *RIAL HOSP Y. IMA VAL Y MEN:: AL HOSP 28 5IET1' DR 281 TIE el DR 28 1 TIE oN DR YAKI t,-, "A 98902 YAKI'' WA 98902 YAKI`•; WA 98902 181323 -33477 0 181323- 3347: 181323 -33479 YAKIMA Y MEMORI HOSP '*.KIMA V. EY M .ORIAL_ HQ'SP YAKIMA VAL Y M "++0 AL HOSP 2' +'11 T ETON - - 28' '" TON DR 2 ::1 TIET'' DR YA I -, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAK ^A 98902 181323 -33492 181323-335 i 181323 -33004 YAKIMA VA nY d' "^ •:IFS: i P Y. IMA -.,LEY ME.*! A. SF Y•..IMA VALL" MEMO.' HOSPI7 28.1 TIE'•N DR 281 IETON DR 281 TIET0/ DR YAK_ .. WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, AAA 98902 81323 -331 (_.2) 181323 -33414 181323 -33415 YAKIMA V•LLE' MEMORI:. "* L YAKIMA VALL MORIA 'OSPITAL YA MA VALL.. M£M«}) - SP17 28 7 TON DR 28 TIE •' DR 2811' - ' ET *+ DR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 ' I ) 181323 -3_'16 181323 -334 7 81323 -334 • -.YAKIMA ALL MEMO:... HOSPITAL YAKIMA V' LE MEMORIA OSPITAL Y= IMA •' LEY Mme: ?I7 toy 81 IETON €1 ' ETON D' 281 IETON DR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 DOC. YAKIMA, WA 98902 INDEX 0 # 0 - 1 181323 -33429 18. 323 -33430 ' 23 -33' AKIMA .• `+` H FITAL YAK V± .:Y MEMORIAL HOSPITAL AKIMA /ALLEY '` '.sr .. HOSPI7 2 :11 f' ET*•_ D' 2811 i TON • 28., IETON DR YA - 'A, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 J1323-33 181323-33451 -_/) 181 23-33465 YA'XIMA ALLE' MEMO' AL HOSP TAL YAKIVA VALLE EMO' .e YAKIMA VALL" ',""O•IAL HOSPIT 281.. T ETON DR 2611 DR 2611 TIETe' DR YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 YAKIMA, WA 98902 181323-3347. 181323-3347 181323-33475 1(-1 YA% MA VA. EY MEMOR AL HJIIITAL YAK A VAL Y MEMOR :.OSPITAL YA. " VALLEY 'PEMO' t HOSPIT 2811 TI ON DR 2811 TIE aN DR 2811 TON R• YAKI ' WA 98902 YAKIMA A 98902 YAKIMA, "- 8902 111 181323-33480 YAKIMA VALLEY EMORIAL HOSPITAL 281 TIETON rR YAKIM W *8902 238 labels printed for map sheet bargehist e-e+ 1 ' 11 3 M c ( o Pubbc 7X - hi CA Coir ° LP/ /14 1 DOC. INDEX - r (.1) I— H I— . ILI Z C\I C\I Ca 11.1 > LLI > Z Z Z > < > < < M O M I— M Z I— LO I— N (.0 Ca 'il" LLI 0") 1.1.1 Ca Z CN > Z > Z Z 0 1 • I— CO CD C\I CO ' Z I 1 RzE 3T W YAKIMA AVE w > w > 1 I— 1 Ca I— La (0 > HOME DR en 04 < IN N /J .,), JUT ST up ".-- cs,i 0 (1) ce) . 04 G LU O > }--- SHE- 1°44/1" E ' LLI co > 0) LLI ILI 1 City of Yakima, Washington M Subject Site FILE NO: 1 Notified Propery Owners APPLICANT: City of Yakima REQUEST Barge Chestnut Historic District - Phase One DOC. . . LOCATION: Barge St - Walnut St - S 24th Ave - S 32nd Ave INDEX # 0_ ! 1 inch = 500 feet ragelol Ibarra, Rosalinda From: lbarra, Rosalinda Sent: Wednesday, May 13, 2009 4:03 PM To: Moore, Debbie Subject: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood historic designation. Attachments: Notice of Historic Preservation Public Hearing - BargeChestnut.doc Hi Debbie, I am sending you the legal notice which will be published for the Historic Preservation public hearing for the Barge-Chestnut Historic District - Phase One. This will serve as an example for you to use when you publish the notice announcing the City Council Public Hearing which is scheduled to be held on June 16, 2009. Thanks! Wpsalindi Ibarra Planning Specialist ribarra@ci.yalcima.vva.us City of Yakima 129 North 2nd Street Yakima, WA 98901 p: (509) 575-6183 f: (509) 575-6105 DOC. INDEX I D_1 5/13/2009 May 29, 2009 RECEIVED From: Gary Forrest, BCNA Historic Committee JUN 0 2 2009 To Vaughn McBride, City of Yakima Historic Commission Liaison CITY OF YAKIMA PLANNING DIV. Subject: Barge-Chestnut Historic District Phase One Application Dear Vaughn, Enclosed please find a second group of original signatures from owners in the phase one area who have agreed to have their home listed on the Yakima Registry of Historic Places and/or Districts should they qualify and should the District be formed. This group contains and additional 15 signatures bringing the total to 183 signatures from 216 properties and representing 84.7%. We conducted two mailings to cover the absentee owners and those missed during the original canvass. The mailings were conducted on 04/13/09 and 04/27/09. The last signature arrived in the mail on 05/28/09. As explained in my letter of 04/13/09, the mailing included information on how a district is formed and the benefits derived from its creation. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contact me by phone 248-1845 or email •sforre@msn.com -7a Gary Forrest BCNA Historic Preservation Committee Cc: Eugenia Woo, Artifacts Inc. file DOC. INDEX C-- . . . . .... 3 .. ... . ........ .. .. „....., ... gico.3. : - • rn - . . - .-- .... lit For .‘.. .....- t L in .• k,. ,) ..0etty . is ri * 1 P. • f ro - t o His on t,) w 0 0 1 ' ' t. distric ka Reg lm case of a 0 Z to 1 (les n • t he Ya . .. "' ......a pia_ _ -1, .• -- prope listed on .. ro e proper rt in the cas qfTE # ...., have my P P as a contributing * LA., II' — .• : . ' ant to hav 1 cons low, ture be , ' ..:.,.,.... . . m signa ,, ,,,,. —dalify „,- By m as an individual listing or P TDRE 2.--.. siGr houtu it LI andjor Districts s PHONE c Places ister o .,,, ... ADDRESS , # NAME c ii ? FIELD .... ,.■ . • - * *. , * , * . , ' 0. " , ,,,,." , ' *:.. --• - .. , • - ••• _ ,. , _ , ,, . , , , ':. 1-iistOriC Placs arid cji Districts Propertylistirig Cionseilt Form . - . By my signature below, f consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places and/or Districts should it qualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. f. NAME , ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE FIELD S 0 6 ITE # z u G Zo r+1- itti . i . pipt 'N / ,1 Allarihit."A OF ... 1 :1 1 Regiet of His es* ,:ahifortisfriots p.ro Listipg: consent Form By my signature below, consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places and/or Districts should it qualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. (.3 NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGN ■;. URE„ FIELD SITE # 0 \f"cca 31D3 \tik 1% :// ...ar —411. • * ..„ ,. . . . (. - t Form . * Coriseri : and. i' 'Dist!'" orri, ritomitti,.Listing 1 - i 0* i places ci) ui Register of Historic of district. 00 It 11 : piates,- . , d on the r ilf*HiStorie . *0 have my property lis e property in the case a a 0 z e SITE # — p FIELD S *- ' I consent to . contributing d al listing or as a 11 '1,11:,,,,V,fikirria'. ' nature below, lify as an individual uRE 70 . . By my sig. should it qua hou SIG A CtS) yakima Reg 01 1 4 fr-.4 and/or D t cts s Is n r OP 41 *, 1 pjf 41tA i / Ai" pRON 4609 .... ,„, A aii„...../Auf ADDRESS 4 ilP vigor if NAME r+ 1 ? r i 1 c - ,e yf'eY 7 'c&S 0-1C C63- 0 vvikli„ . ..:.....,....., Places ‘ . ton ter o f His ii * . twr „,41 --- ' ••••••• *d ,, , , r- . . ' . * Yakima Regis; case of a is ii fed on the ak . the c d• trict, 0 0 1 _.. property in * im- i-RegiS. • * I consent , , or as a contributing P ' ''''T`I'...'..;:Yu‘kiii• i...---• . i ature below, ,. individual listing .,..„ - my signature '''''..***'••• . By my -: should it quail y f as an indivi -,„-- , • and/or Districts shou p HO t to have my property is NE 4i....„,v0,14,8ci. „.it 1 VV HELD SITE # ADDRESS A FsS NAME ) - SIGNATURE 1 _ t .,.. . ,..„ ' Vakiiiia ilegliterof Hietoric Plaoes and be Distriots PrOtietty Listing Consent Form - t By my signature below, I consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places r3 and/or Districts should it qualify as an individual fisting or as a contributing property in the case of a district. t NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE C.3 ill FIELD SITE # 0 0 ,...... 4 e) Peri\ r D --f.--es. , A • • - 6 AP . cv 8 c S i' = 4/ i - v :1;\ i ( 0 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII. IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII IIIMIMIIIIIIIMIIIIII , , ammili 111111111.111111111111111111111111=1 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIM IIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIMIIIIIM IIIMMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII i e By my signature below, 9 consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places and /or Districts should it qualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. d ct NAME ADDRESS PHONE !SIGNATURE FIELD SITE # .-. Der. -I- Vi es p e tE. 152- 7i T 'AAA Dl ev, p Dcw OtAfilAp 1 809 (A.) CI,45 I'Vt4 4 Alf- " • • } I I 'ak 4 By my signature below, I consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of H Places and/or Districts should it qualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. S1 � NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE FIELD SITE # aRr° L 11 Wc) tit). 0,.hfin. qi.(;1-41q.PY „9- (so 7. ya i . m - a. Fiegister of- FI. i'stior'ic Plac s .*a .5 Proli'.'e '1.- Ci:)ii.erit Form. .- - -- rt (......) below, 1 consent By my signature b , to have my property listed on the Yakima Register . - R 'star of Historic Places and/or Dstricts should it qua in district. .......,. \ i ilify as an individual list g or as a contributing property in in the case of a dis NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE FIELD SITE # 0 p..„ --- Kei ' ' 7 i 7 ii- ) ,, , i ..,,-, . f , - i i -.:Yakittia,*Register:oc)fl-liStcjric Places and or Districts PrOrierty l_istirtsaCc:oriserit Form By my signature below, 1 consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places and /or Districts should it qualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE FIELD SITE # Li ti-Y1 U efi (?t,' e 115.3 j U fZ - °ti`, ®. By my signature below, 1 consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places and/or Districts should it Qualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. 0 0 0 NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE FIELD SITE # ftL JM frit Go e Dc-1 B W 0.11c4i - 0-0 11111111.111111111111111111111111111111 11 11111111111 1 111111111111111111111 . . PripriettN,f Lis By my signa u B ' t re below, I consent to have my pr p arty t o listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places and/or Districts hould it qualify as an individual listing or as a con ributing property in the case of a district. ■1/4 1 c_i n ui , NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE FIELD SITE # 0 0 • 9(06-097 IPIIPIEPPIIIIInka,go AAAtair IIS-- . 411..... ...., , . . Register of Historic Places anct DistrictS Property n.. By my signature below, I consentito have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places and/or Districts should it qualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. on U.1 NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE FIELD SITE # KIM T V-NA 2p_ I I 111 , t4 FOrtfY By my signature below, I consent to have my property listed on the Yakima Register of Historic Places andior Districts should it cualify as an individual listing or as a contributing property in the case of a district. NAME ADDRESS PHONE SIGNATURE I FIELD SITE # ‘ CI - 1,0 a ID Rit 5 0 q -c, imp 1111111111M111111 111111111111111111111 111111111111111 1111111111111111 m '"''',----- ... , .•..•,,,,:-..-- d n 1 - R - gister of His t o f a district. the e Yakima .. CD Cb : r rl7"4l'7Zeirlit';:l.4.7.107,,,. prope I isted—l.:771-1: e case sei)rolc Places m prope-J fing property p ell 0 sent to have m , or as a c ontribu signature or PHONE 0 andlor ADDRESS my y istricts should it qualify as an individual hsting FIELD SITE # 0 NAME l AXf 114 ci-P-C1/6, 4--lie--- VV /111Y-4 111111 111111111111111 MEM 111111111111111111111111111111 , 11 =111 1 Il IIIIIIIIIIIIIIMII Alan D. Campbell • West H. Campbell - James C. Carmody • J. Jay Carroll ?. James S Elliott Mark E. Fickes • Carter L Fie d • Tyler M Hinckley Lawrence E. Martin • Kevan T Montoya • Linda A, Sellers Michael F Shinn - Sara L. Watkins Of Counsel Frederick N Halverson • Terry C. Schmalz ELIKANirt 'H ALVERSONpc A-r-roRNFys AT LAW Pen& ,..; 0 May 28, 2009 M AY 2 8 2009 cir or Yakima Historic Preservation Commission PIA p VA KA Itfic c/o City of Yakima, Department of Comrnunity Li/v and Economic Development 129 N. 2 Street Yakima, WA 98901 Re: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District-Phase 1 Dear Commission Members: The undersigned is attorney for Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital concerning its campus development and master planning initiative. Last week I was forwarded a copy of the City of Yakima's Notice of Public Hearing for the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District Phase-1 nomination announcing a public hearing to be held Thursday, May 28, 2009 at 5:30 p.m., with a map attached to the Notice identifying the "subject site" as a rectangle of property bounded on the east by 24 Avenue, the north by Barge Street, the west by N. 32 Avenue, and on the south by W. Walnut Street. The Notice indicated that the nominated historic district would be "in this vicinity," not necessarily inclusive of every parcel within it. A copy of the Notice and map received by the Hospital are appended hereto as Attachment "A." As the Hospital has been working closely on its campus development planning with the Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Association, I contacted Mr. Gary Forrest, Co-Chair of the Barge- Chestnut Neighborhood Association Historic Preservation Committee today and asked him for a copy of the "actual" boundaries intended for the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District. I also spoke with Vaughn McBride, Historic Preservation Liaison for the City of Yakima and was provided with more precise maps, copies of which are appended hereto as Attachment "B," showing that there are several parcels between S. 28 Avenue and S. 32n Avenue, north of W. Walnut Street, that are not intended for inclusion in the Historic District. Out of an abundance of caution, nevertheless, Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital wants to make sure that the boundaries are drawn as depicted on Attachment "B," not as shown on the mailing to the public, Attachrnent "A." The reason being, there are 35 parcels owned by Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital located north of W. Walnut Street, south of W. Chestnut Avenue, between S. 28 Avenue and S. 31 Avenue, and two other non-hospital owned parcels for which the Hospital has engaged the owners in discussion regarding the acquisition of same, which are part of the Hospital's campus plan/master planning initiative. A map of the Hospital campus, including the two non-owned parcels (located just east of the Hospital's northern-most property on S. 30 Avenue), is appended hereto as Attachrnent "C," and a listing of the parcels, their DOC. INDEX 509.248.6030 fax 509 4536880 405 East Lincoln P 0. Box 22550 Yakima, WA 9890.. • ' Yakima Historic Preservation Commission May 28, 2009 Page 2 acreage, and the date they were acquired by Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital, is appended as Attachment "D" hereto. Again, these comments are submitted purely out of an abundance of caution to avoid confusion as to the Historic District's boundaries. Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital continues to work cooperatively with the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Association in efforts to ensure that both organizations can meet their objectives for a successful hospital campus/historic neighborhood partnership. Sincerely, VELIKANJE HALVER A , P.C. ri „... .....-. s..41 . Mic. ael F. Shinn MFS:bw / / Encl. / g1cafskyalcana valley memorial hospda1-14974 \expanded day care4/28 \20011 class ut reVICNA13151 thst commits doc 5/2S/2009 3I2 pmts.' DOC. INDEX X30NI 'O00 «�� L31.IV CITY OF YAKIMA HISTORIC PRESERVATION COMMISSION NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the Yakima Historic Preservation Commission will conduct a public hearing to consider and receive public comments regarding the establishment of the Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District — Phase One located in the vicinity east of 32 Avenue, west of 24 Avenue, south of Barge Street and north of Walnut Street - on the Yakima Register of Historic Places as a Historic District. The purpose of this open record public hearing is to determine if the proposed district meets the criteria required for this designation. At the conclusion of this hearing the Commission will consider their recommendation to the Yakima City Council concerning this nomination. Written comments may be submitted to the Historic Preservation Commission in two ways: 1) Send a letter via regular mail to "City of Yakima„ Department of Community & Economic Development, 129 N. 2 Street, Yakima, Wa. 98901"; or, 2) E-mail your comments to vmcbride@ci,yakima.wa.us. Please include in the e-mail subject line, "Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District — Phase One." And also include your name and mailing address. The public hearing will be held on Thursday, May 28, 2009 at 5:30 p.m., or soon thereafter, in the Council Chambers at Yakima City Hall, 129 North 2 rld Street, Yakima, WA. Please contact Vaughn McBride, Historic Preservation Liaison at 576-6315 if you have any questions about this nomination. Dated this 15 day of May, 2009. DOC. INDEX osmatommerarmartmtam..m. 7 CO 1 1 1 .-- I— H H cl , CO CO r.-- LU Z C\J 04 Li 04 Ili > w > Z Z Z > < > 2' c < < 1 < c 0 1 H 1 Z 1--- LO H LU CO LU 04 Z cNi > Z > Z Z < 0 1 H Cr) 0 C\I C) - -BAGE 3-T--- z 7 -- ' W YAKIMA AVE 1 w > UJ = CO Cssi H i HOME DR Op C\1 i , A A k U) LLI i cf c\1 a CO f: co C\I t...1. CO I L - ) SHEC til LLJ o) > 0 PsVE < CA4*-11' 1 City of Yakima, Washington = Subject Ste FILE NO; L r - ja : a 4 Notified Propery Owners APPLICANT: City of Yakima REQUEST. Barge Chestnut Historic District - Phase One te, INDEX \z LOCATION: Barge St - Walnut St - S 24th Ave - S 32nd Ave # E - 9 1 inch = 500 feet A "B" DOC. INDEX # E -R z Can*rbty.Ln 1.4 g , 4: ‹ z. !> (51 M ,.. • . , . 44604, .,..., . „g4,171 .,. . - . ■ , • 1 • K 4 - ,g1 •", ., ,, 1 1 , 14 te,„ 6 , , 1 .1 G , , , .. Li to 0„ . 6 10 0 ,,,4 to 1 ti ' SM .341A3,vu oral . , . ,. ,o a ria, : * M 44-!* „zet, ,. 27(47 114, " spat' .9-4 1 1° ° '' v-' ' g P AC 4 — -W M t* •&if, -trit$4? 0,,, ).X raiii , , ,. , , -..---d•2141 AM 2716 ' • . , • • • , • • r •• 1,'( 1, I (., i t ■ j , 7 7 , 7 11 1. : ) - a rA au , 1 `, I( '...." ' ' ° .,,! 1 , ( (00 1 • ,,,, i' .t: f t I.. L ■ , r tto ' ,31,psoa.„8.4 • . ,t0V Ai ., . , , eii2.403,..ti 2sit ' 4411, A i CA 4 xv 1 421151 24 .''''sraisi ,0 . a) , ;AA, , t , 2 , : 3.0045, 29 • - it* 2•OP 93 aloit t.146 c J : f ‘.,,, . ■,-.) i i a 471 0 , H 2 8 1 ' 4 .r .gfi #0 7 0 5. 0 04 L I f K tYYY)e RSe Iv A 1 g 0 .1, t fire eiw`Tft.12,071,749 -4 - ,....) , 2 „ 14 , ,,/ i i 'tv '.' W W lilt 1011 _`' , - , 2 .1tat ' 6 et) LY ci *t. --- rri C.7 0 i l ')1' . sell tiori Cortiarait tee P)CNA Historical Pre .t.1 t Historical Dishict: Phase Oilt-:', "Yal'ut.z" a Nit. Work Sheet. i\lec. • t4- Yt.). IC)ci 515 . vir4 orr, 'e- I /-4 1 3.S" °S ortY'v-4 . fr1/4., t) Re \•,.„, 4. ,, , 6 -c) t 1 0 7 ATTM�rT "C" DOC. INDEX a E _a - r . 1 s r— t t t I t-- ilt : 1 t_ 4 _ I_ , i 1 t , , 1 i r 1 a... ...1. • 1 1 1 ^ 1 ' ' . 1 . ......... ........ 11... ........i..... .. I r i 1 I - i ■ ' r 1 • t 1 1Tilif I1TT rill it 11111 t I , 1 ■ ■ ., ■ ■ . ■ ....7' .i. L__.,...._......_._i_ ._ -: — : , 1. itiTrL 1 • I ' , I I 1 ' I —. E. ::: I f... — 4: f — f -- •ff — 2f.: - ' I f I i - I , 1 , — l'— L - - m , - ,,,, — - f — --::: ...: 1 — i I — — I '4' 1 , — — — I I I LI 1 -- f' = ' 1 — 1 -- ,..H r ---- 1 ' -,„ , i, - -- - - - - t . E--,-= , , rlt I, 1 r ': ,..;\ - -7- I I 1, - f „f L I 1 , __ , • --.., i — 1 — " -- - ' / f — — I Of V ' 1 fi . \ ' ' ' ' ' — — ' — — — — — J ' I I __..it.,:,-,,. .) „,, p _ 9 1 , .. _ \ \,..\1„, ,..,,i......, _ . ! _____..., ,... ...._..:........,_ ■ ___ ■ w liVainut Street^:" *-5'".- 7,....=-: --4 1 - - v , i .,, ..— , -- L ,ok I - 4- 1 -I'll ---- 1 L f ',,, f 1 , ff; ''''''.'" f. i ' ''' '7, if ' '''')" 4 '' i 1 , , , g . 1 Fli fl _ . T.: 0. ........._ , , . , .....— , .. > . f ,, .,..- .........,-- smo 11 - ' .—* "! t i = - L, = — — Mil ,.___ 1, -3 — - cp 0 c, . _ ,,, _ _ .. ._ , , „I I 1 I illtitlialllit- .1_ 1-1- ill. . I I -,---------: ,, _ _ _ . - - ---,,---.:7 ---1'—'—'—‘—*—*—*--- -7-7 ----r-!"- - - ,- -- i , ---- - r 3 ...,'""' „... de. 1...i 0 Figure 1: Existing Yakima Valley Niernorial Hospital Campus rrl W P AI 1 T ACHMF,NT "D" DOC. INDEX Parcel Lot Size Owner Date Acquired Number 1 181323-33438 .83 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 8/30/1984 ' 2 ' 181323-33437 .17 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 6/2/2005 3 181323-33435 .30 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 3/31/2004 ' 4 ' 181323-33432 .19 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 2/8/2001 5 ' 181323-33430 .16 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital , 12/7/2001 6 181323-33429 .20 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 11/29/2006 7 181323-33426 .26 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 9/30/1997 8 181323-33457 .20 acres ' Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 5/29/2008 9 181323-33456 .21 acres 1 McLean 10 , 181323-33455 ' .24 acres Balmelli 11 181323-33454 .20 acres , Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 2/28/2002 12 181323-33453 .17 acres ' Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 4/18/1997 13 ! 181323-33452 .21 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital ! 8/29/2003 I 14 ! 181323-33451 .21 acres , Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 5/26/1998 15 181323-33449 .30 acres ' Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 6/12/1998 16 181323-33450 .20 acres ' Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 10/31/1995 [ 17 181323-33447 .20 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 1 7/1/2002 18 181323-33446 .32 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 5/4/1993 19 181323-33510 .43 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 1 10/9/1998 20 181323-33445 .25 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital ' 7/16/1984 21 181323-33442 .18 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 7/13/1981 22 181323-33416 .16 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital ' 5/28/2003 23 ' 181323-33415 .16 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 12/17/2002 24 181323-33414 .16 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 6/20/2002 ' 25 181323-33413 .15 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 3/31/1995 26 181323-33418 .29 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 11/26/1996 ! 27 181323-33417 .29 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 11/13/1995 28 181323-33465 .22 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 7/2/2001 29 181323-33004 .21 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 7/31/1995 30 1 181323-33473 .21 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital , 8/26/1993 ' 31 ' 181323-33480 ! .23 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 4/4/2002 32 181323-33474 ! .21 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 8/26/2002 33 181323-33479 .21 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 7/13/2002 34 181323-33475 .22 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 7/19/2002 35 181323-33478 .22 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 1/25/1990 36 ! 181323-33492 .23 acres Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital ! 3/14/1991 37 181323-33477 1 .22 acres ! Yakima Valley Memorial Hospital 8/21/1990 g \mfs\yakima valley memorial hospital-14974 \ expanded day care-028\2008 class ui review\ parcel number table,doc 5128/2009 222 proamb DOC. INDEX ------ CE1VE0 'WAY May 28, 2009 2 8 200g °in, NA/8,1 Yolk NING 41 4 On, From: Gary Forrest, BCNA Historic Preservation Committee Co-Chairman To: City of Yakima Inquiry Commission Subject: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District-Phase One. Dear Members, Next month will mark the two year anniversary of our associations quest to form a historic district honoring the City of Yakima and the 1200+ homes within the Barge- Chestnut Area where almost 90% of the homes are 50 years of age or older and 44 of them are nearing the century mark (16 or more have already celebrated). During the last two years, our committee spent over 1000 volunteer hours researching the 216 homes in Phase One and documenting them to Washington State Historic Property Guideline Standards ( We discovered early on that 1200 homes was much too big of a bite at one time and had to settle on seven separate phases). We completed our work on Phase One this past April with the initial gathering of 168 signatures from properly owners supporting the creation of a historic district. A mailing was done to cover the absentee owners and those not home when we made the physical canvass. 14 more signatures have been gained and the final count in favor is 182 signatures. This represents 84% of the property owners in favor of forming a historic district and listing their homes in the Yakima Registry of Historic Places and/or Districts should those properties qualify. At last estimate over 80% of the homes in their present condition within the proposed district would qualify as contributing to a historic district. We are ready for an official designation and respectfully request and are forever hopeful that this commission will make a favorable recommendation to the Yakima Historic Commission and to the City Councii. Sin rely, / 70 f - 4 a wi Gary Forrest Co-Chairman, BCNA Historic Preservation Committee. DOC. INDEX # F F McBride, Vaughn From: Suzanne Noble i iicom] Sent: Thursday, 5:47 AM To: McBride, Vaughn Subject: Historic neighborhood Dear cfty officials, | wish tV express my strong support for g designated historic neighborhood in Yakima. Please encourage all Yakima residents to take pride in their homes by acknowledging the beauty and high quality of life here. Respecting the history of our collective past by preservation demonstrates a high level of civic responsibility which serves to improve both our community's self coriception and image throughout the state. Thank you for your time and attention given to this highly valuable p jRcL Sincerely, Suzanne Noble Sent from my iPhone DOC. INDEX 1 # -7 ~- , ^ap.; Bride, Vaughn From: Pete Mahony[peh*mohony©johnihaosnonn Sent: Wednesday, May 27, 2009 6:57 PM To: McBride, Vaughn Subject: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District Phase One Dear Mr. McBride, I am writing to you to voice my OPPOSITION to the proposed historic district in the "Barge-Chestnut" neighborhood. My home, located at102N.20 m Ave, is technically just outside of the proposed Phase One zone, and I have owned my home for about 15 years. However I'm assuming a Phase Two naturally would follow Phase One, and would expect my home to be included in Phase Two. Thus why I'm voicing my opposition early in the process. The proposed zone is certainly an older neighborhood, however it does not constitute a "historical" neighborhood in my opinion. The style and age of homes is widely varied, with many of the newer ones obviously having been modified/remodeled over the years. 1 have added on to my own home as well which was built in the 30's, and enlisted the aid of an architect to ensure the addition was integrated into the original design of the home. Likely many af my neighbors would've done the same with such a project* | didn't need some committee (likely consisting of non-architects) approving my design. The addition was certainly built according to City code, and actually had to go through a public hearing process. I've since received many compliments on how the addition looks like its part of the original structure. There ianV underlying theme or character ho the neighborhood, such as a predominantly Victorian style, colonial style, etc. There are also very few homes of which | would consider historically significant. Many of the homes are fairly well nnaintained, but of 7,ethiacondibonhaooxintedandourvivedovertheyeorovvithoutanadded/oymrofrogu|aUnn. The homeowners have done a / ob maintaining their homes of their own free will. That is one of the attractions of the neighborhood and why | moved into it. simply a well maintained, older neighborhood but not one of historical significance and not one in need of additional regulation to "preserve history." Not many, if any, details have been announced about the proposed district as it's early in the process. l'm sure the advocates will reassure the homeowners that unreasonable restrictions will not be imposed, and we'll all be told we can still paint our homes the color we want. Perhaps a significant remodel would need approval, but how will some sort of committee determine what should be connidenodappropriahe.asMheroistru|ynocommoncharecterofhVmasinthoneighborhood? And if the advocates continue to claim that |itt|e, if any, restrictions will be imposed, then why create the historic district in the first place? My opinion on the answer to that question is two-fold. It's my gut feel that the homeowners behind this proposal are concerned about the growth of Memorial Hospital, and feel a historic district designation will give the neighborhood more clout when opposing the hospital's growth projects, hohevemoreinMuenoeon what Memorial canlcannot do. I happen to be a supporter of Memorial, feel they are an instrumental member of the community, and have demonstrated responsible growth and genuine concern for the surrounding neighborhood. Others likely don't view Memorial this way. The other opinion is the advocates simply are interested in tax benefits for home improvement projects. 1 am not at all informed on the details of possible tax benefits, so my opinion on this is purely speculative. I'm always interested in reducing my taxes as the next guy is. But again, given the apparent lack of historical significance in the neighborhood, I don't feel its right for this particular older" neighborbood to get tax breaks wher the next one doesn't. And we alt know how budgets work. You take revenue away from one area, you try to get it back through some other means. | won't be able to attend tomorrow night's meeting, thus wanted to get my comments to you via email. | will be very interested in how this proposal prnOnesmes, but hopefully it will be short-lived. Peter Mahony 0Mmhony Director of Operations John /. Haas, Inc. po Box w*/ DOC. INDEX # e �� 5/28/2009 ^ "5^^"^ 1 McBride, Vaughn From: ROBERT AND LESLIE WAHL [reIjwahI@msncom] Sent: Wednesday, May 27, 2008 8:06 PM To: McBride, Vaughn Subject: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District - Phase One I am lending my voice in support of the formation of the first historic district in Yakima. My husband Bob and l have lived in the proposed district for 10 years and believe the neighborhood is unique and worthy of recognition. We have worked actively with the committee on the project for 2 1/2yeorsmnd have developed a deep appreciation for the variety of architectural styles and the lives of the citizens who resided here. From a practical standpoint, our city needs to encourage property owners to invest in the upkeep and restoration of their homes which will increase property values, support high occupancy rates and generate needed income for the city. The Barge Chestnut historic district will aid in this endeavor. Respectfully Submitted, Leslie Wahl 203 W. Yakima Ave. Yakima, WA 98902 509'542'9183 DOC. INDEX # ��~�� ^ "6° ^°^^ 3ride, Vaughn From: Russell Maier frusseU.nnaier@zommhealthow.orQ] Sent: Tuesday, May 26, 2009 4:01 PM To: McBride, Vaughn Subject: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic Distrct Phase One Vaughn, | wanted to write and express my support for this project, Although | cannot attend, | think the future value of preserving this neighborhood has great ong term value to the city. What areas are highlighted in Cities around the nation? Their historic neighborhoods. Favorable action by the city will demonstrate their view of the value of preserving the historic past. If you need any further information, let me know. nusseomu.c, 2712 W Yakima Ave Yakima wavo90o DOC. INDEX # ^- 7 - 5/27/2A0Q ^�61. McBride, Vaughn From: Erik K8iokelson[emicke|n@msn.conj Sent: K8onday, May 25, 2009 11:14 PM To: McBride, Vaughn Subject: Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood HisbzhoDisbiot — Phase One To whom it may concern: J just wanted to write in my favor for the "Barge-Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District". My wife and I moved into the neighborhood and live on 32nd just because we wanted to live in this neighborhood. We love to walk down Chestnut down to Franklin park and back on Barge. We have always enjoyed looking at all the old houses and the character that comes with it. It has such rich character and adds to what "Ymkirna" truely is. Sincerely, Erik and Aleah Mickelson 211 5 32nd Ave. 509-833-5951 Hotmail® has a new way to see what's up with your friends. Check it out. DOC. INDEX # /�~ � �- � aE,,, 3ride, Vaughn From: kimhuvo|ik[Wm.knva|ih@dharternot] Sent: 3ohurdmy, May 23, 2009 9:10 PM To: McBride, Vaughn Subject: Barge Chestnut Histroic Neighborhood - Phase One My home is within the boundaries of the proposed historic district. | am grateful for the hard work already put into this project and wholeheartedly support the proposed designation. Sincerely, Kim Kovalik 3112 W Yakima Ave Yakima, WA 98902 DOC, ..,~~E. # E_ 2 McBride, Vaughn From: Kinder [ki Sent: Saturday, May 23, 2009 8:42 PM To: McBride, Vaughn 1 am writing in support of the establishment of the Barge Chestnut N i hbVrhoOdA85ouiadonH|StorcDisUict. 1 live in the Phase 1 area at 201 S.20MhAxe..on the comer of20th Ave. and Chestnut Ave. Many of the homes in this area are about all that are left OfYakima's historic buildings. Certainly this is the only area in Yakima with a concentration of older buildings. When we moved into town from the country 4 years ago, this was the only area in the city of Yakima that I wanted to live in, due to the beautiful old homes and historic feel of the neighborhood. Many of my neighbors feel the same way, and were drawn to this area because of their love of histonc areas and homes. Their pnde of ownership is evident in the care of the homes and yards in this area. Most cities have a historic distnct, with well preserved older homes which add to the value to the city. 1 believe it is time for Yakima to take a stand and show that they want to preserve their history and honor their past. Establishment of the Barge Chestnut Neighborhood Historic District is a step in the right direction. Thank you, Rita Kinder DOC. I�� ^^��^ 1 # E_