HomeMy WebLinkAbout02/14/1978 Business Meeting 697
FEBRUARY, 1978
The City Council met in session on this date at 1:30 PM in the Conference
Roam at City Hall, Yakima, Washington. Council members present were
Assistant Mayor Ralph Holbrook, Henry Beauchamp, Don Hinman, Jack
Sparling, Nadine Walker and Gordon Wonder. Mayor Betty L. Edmondson
absent. ,
Having received'an invitation from concerned citizens, via the Community
Relations Officer, to attend a cammunity meeting at the Southeast
Community Center on February 22, 1978 at 7:30 PM, to discuss the proposed
$7.2 million grant frown HUD, Council then discussed the proposed plan
and application for rehabilitation of an area in the Southeast sector of
the'cammunity. Councilman Beauchamp stated that he and Councilman
Walker had attended a community meeting at the Southeast Community
Center last Saturday regarding this subject, and Councilman Walker
explained that this project is not final. Carol Darby, Director of
Community Development, stated that after speaking with HUD last Thursday,
we were advised to send in our application for the $7.2 million grant. She
stated that during the next two or three week period, citizen input will be
obtained. Councilman Wonder asked if the City is going to try to sell
this project to the citizens. Miss Darby stated that this design gives
the citizens something to react to. She stated that staff will be
asking the citizens what they would want to do if they had a chance for
funds to help rehabilitate the area. She stated that she would have
liked to have been able to obtain citizen participation before making
application, however, time did not permit this. Hope Gomez, Community
Relations Officer, reported that at her February 8th meeting, the citizens
present requested her to write a letter to Council inviting them to
attend the meeting on February 22. Councilman Walker reported that the
citizens present at the meeting on Saturday were quite upset about this
proposed program. Councilman Hinman stated that this shows that Council
has not addressed the concerns of housing --we need to investigate what
the people want. Assistant Mayor Holbrook agreed, and stated that we
need some information before doing anything. He suggested that staff
should get together and come back next Tuesday with a report. Miss
Darby suggested that she put a packet together explaining the funds,
what is involved and what we are proposing, etc. Council members discussed
the question of whether or not they should attend this meeting. Assistant
Mayor Holbrook stated that any Council member may attend this meeting if they
wish; we don't need to decide as a Council. He stated that a consultant
discovered there might be UDAG funds available and Council hired him to
make a study on the Southeast Community. The proposed project was
brought to Council and we authorized them to apply for the grant with the
condition that the plans for the project may be changed or dropped.
Councilman Wonder inlired if UDAG funds could be used throughout the
southeast area. MisslDarby stated that one of the requirements is the
cooperation between the private and business sectors. This is an area
that has been changing as far as zoning is concerned and needs a
buffer zone between residential and business areas. Assistant Mayor
Holbrook stated that he would like a summary on the latitude of the
grant and a summary of the recommended program.
Councilman Wonder inquired if a letter had been sent regarding the
Cougar Lake Wilderness area, inasmuch as the Mayor had not attended the
meeting on this. City Manager Eastman reported that staff has been
working on a draft letter. He stated we have 30 days from a week ago
Saturday to put our position in written form.
Councilman Hinman suggested that discussion of appointments to boards
and commissions be done in Executive Session. It was then MOVED by
Walker, seconded by Hinman to move into Executive Session to discuss
legal matters and appointments to Boards and Commissions: carried,
Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and Wonder voting aye by
voice vote. Edmondson absent.
Upon completion of Executive Session, Council members discussed the
appointment to the Housing Authority. Councilman Wonder stated that
this appointment is iMportant because the Housing Authority is not an
advisory commission. Councilman Sparling asked what they have done so
far. Larry Wright, Principal Planner, stated that the Housing Authority
has had trouble getting started. He stated that they will have to work
closely with the City. Legally they are autonomous,?but not realistically.
698:
FEBRUARY 14, 1978
Assistant Mayor Holbrook inquired who wrote the letter in their packets
fran the Housing Authority recommending Mamie Mbrrison. City Manager
Eastman reported that it came from a staff member. Councilman Wonder
stated that in the future he thinks it would be better if Council doesn't
even receive it. Councilman Hinman stated that it is important that a
person be chosen who knows the needs of the community and also comes
from the east side of town. Councilman Walker nominated Johnnie Rance
for this position on the Housing Authority. Councilman Beauchamp seconded
this nomination. Councilman Wonder nominated Jean Allard. He stated
that as a Councilman, Jean Allard was the most active member in getting
the Housing Authority on board. He stated that Mr. Allard has the
empathy of those people and also it is important that there is someone
on the Board who is involved with real estate. Councilman Wailer spoke
in favor of Johnnie Rance, stating that his name was suggested to her at
the Board meeting at the Southeast Community Center. He knows the areas
of need, relates well with others, ha the respect of the catinunity, is
interested in serving, and willing to bring the information to the
community. Councilman Beauchamp reinforced his support of Johnnie
Rance, stating that the Housing Authority will have work predominately in the
eastern side of the community and it is important that a person fran
that area serves on the Board. A vote was called on the two nominations.
Beauchamp, Hinman and Walker voting for Johnnie Rance. Holbrook, Sparling
and Wonder voting for Jean Allard. There being no Council member wishing
to change his vote, it was the general consensus of the Council to take
this matter up on the 27th of February when the Mayor will be present.
Councilman Hinman nominated Tony Menke to serve on the Regional Planning
Board. He stated that Mt. Menke worked in the County Prosecutors Office
and therefore, has worked in this area. Mr. Menke is willing to serve
on this Board. Councilman Hinman reported that Mr. Menke presently resides
outside the City Limits, but is planning to move next month. After
discussion regarding Council's policy about appointing Board members who
are not City residents, it was MOVED by Hinman, seconded by Walker that
Tony Menke be appointed to the Regional Planning Commission, contingent
upon his moving within the City Limits within 60 days: carried, Beauchamp,
Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and Wonder voting aye by voice vote.
Edmondson absent.
In discussing the prospective retreat, it was the general consensus of
the Council that the time element and the expense of going to Hidden
Valley Ranch, Cle Elum, was not warranted. Council members discussed
how much time they needed to cover the subjects that need their attention
and where they would like to go for this retreat. It was the general
consensus of the Council to meet on Friday, mid morning at Whistlin'
Jack Lodge and stay until late afternoon on Saturday. Assistant City
Manager Zais reported that Whistlin' Jack Lodge has informed him that
they are open for the next four consecutive weeks after March 15.
At 3:00 PM, the Council members moved into the Council Chambers for the
balance of the meeting, Assistant Mayor Holbrook presiding, Council
members Beauchamp, Hinman, Sparling, Walker and Wonder, City Manager
Eastman and City Attorney Andrews present on roll call. Mayor Edmondson
absent and excused,as she is on vacation.
The Invocation was given by City Attorney Andrews.
Assistant Mayor Holbrook referred to the items placed on the Consent
Agenda, questioning whether there were any additions or deletions fran
either Council members or citizens present. Councilman Walker requested
that item #9 be deleted fran the Consent Agenda. It was the general
consensus of the Council that the deletion of item #9, as requested, be
made. The City Clerk then read the Consent Agenda items, including
Resolutions by title. It was MOVED by Walker, seconded by Beauchamp
that the Consent Agenda, as read, be passed: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman,
Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and Wonder voting aye on roll call. Edmondson
absent. (Subsequent paragraphs preceded by an asterisk (*) indicate
items on the Consent Agenda to be handled under one motion without
further discussion.)
699
FEBRUARY 14, 1978
Councilman Walker stated that she has a correction to the January 30,
1978 minutes on the motion adopting Resolution No. D-3842, and would
like the motion to read as follows: "Expressing his concern about the
proposal as written, he nevertheless felt the application should be
submitted, therefore, it was MOVED by Beauchamp, seconded by Walker that
Resolution No. D-3842, authorizing the City Manager to apply for an
Urban Development Action Grant, be passed." She stated that the balance
of the minutes on this subject is correct. It was then MOVED by Walker,
seconded by Wonder that the minutes, as corrected, be approved: carried,
Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and Wonder voting aye by
voice vote. Edmondson absent.
Council members having received a copy of a Notice of Intention to
Commence Annexation Proceedings, it was MOVED by Wonder, seconded by
Beauchamp that February 14, 1978, be set as the time for a meeting with
II/
the initiating parties who signed a Notice of Intention to Commence
Annexation Proceedings dated February 9, 1978, those initiating parties
being Ed Pietz and Todd McCloskey, owners, Thunderbird/Red Lion Motor
Inns: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sperling, Walker and Wonder
voting aye by voice vote. Edmondson absent. Jack G. Reiss, General
Manager, Thunderbird, representing the owners, stated that the Thunderbird
purchased the property in order to expand, not knowing that part of the
property is in the CoUnty. Mr. Reiss, representing the owners, having
indicated that they are willing to assume their share of the City's
indebtedness, it was duly MOVED, seconded and passed that the annexation
proposed by Petition No. 918 (Notice of Intention to Commence Annexation
Proceedings) be accepted by the City of Yakima and that the area sought
to be annexed be required to assume the City's existing indebtedness,
and that a Notice of intention to Annex be filed with the Yakima County
Boundary Review Board. The above motion was made by Wonder, seconded by
Beauchamp and carried: Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker
and Wonder voting aye by voice vote. Edmondson absent.
This being the time fixed for the hearing on the approval of form and
execution of a cooperation agreement between the Yakima Housing Authority
and the City of Yakima, Councilman Wonder expressed reservations in
authorizing execution of the agreement as it is, referring to Section 3
regarding the exemption from real and personal property taxes, and there
being no basis on which to collect "payments in lieu of taxes". Carol
Darby, Director of Community Development stated that in order to modify
this contract, the City would have to negotiate with HUD, as this is
their standard contract. Councilman Hinman questioned if he was interpreting
correctly Section 4 by believing that the City will have to rebuild,
repair, demolish or condemn unsafe or unsanitary dwelling units, substantially
in equal number of newly constructed dwelling units provided by this
project. Ken Crawford, Chief of Housing and Neighborhood Conservation,
replied that that-statement is correct. Mr. Crawford stated that this
contract is identical to the one which was executed last year in obtaining
funds for the 60 units. Tam Bostic, Vice Chairman of the Yakima Housing
Authority, spoke in favor of execution of this agreement, stating that
this City needs low income housing and it is not economically feasible
for the private sector to provide this, and therefore, the only solution
is to be subsidized. He stated that the Housing Authority will advertise
II/
for bids to provide these units and the bidders can come in with turn
key proposals. The City does not have any further financial obligations.
When the job is done, HUD gives the Housing Authority the money through
the sale of the bonds. He stated that there will be a mix in the units,
up to 4 to 5 bedroomsi There is a definite scale of income requirements
that has to be met. pane Council members expressed displeasure at
receiving this contract so close to the deadline for submission leaving no
opportunity to negotiate changes. It was then MOVED by Walker, seconded
by Beauchamp that Resolution No. D-3853, authorizing execution of an
agreement between the Yakima Housing Authority and the City of Yakima,
be passed: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and
Wonder voting aye on roll call. Edmondson absent.
RESOLUTION NO. D-3853, A RESOLUTION approving the form of the cooperation
agreement between the City of Yakima and the Housing Authority of the
City of Yakima and authorizing its execution.
• 700
FEBRUARY 14, 1978
This being the time fixed for the hearing on the Resolution of Intention
D-3833, to create a Local Improvement District for installation of
sanitary sewer mains in the vicinity of Prestige Manor, Gaylord Newby,
Broker for Prestige Realty, ,spoke on behalf of the formation of this
L.I.D., outlining the district and stated that Dr. Heffernan's property
is not included in this L.I.D. because he could be not be served without
the use of a lift pump. Mr. Newby also stated that if this property
could be serviced, it would be allowable with Dr. Heffernan paying his
pro-rated share. It was MOVED by Walker, seconded by Wonder that Ordinance
No. 2155, creating L.I.D. No. 1015, Prestige Manor Sewer District, be
passed: carried, Edmondson, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and
Wonder voting aye on roll call. Edmondson absent.
ORDINANCE NO. 2155, AN ORDINANCE providing for the improvements of
certain property by constructing a pipe sewer with the necessary wye
branches and manholes; establishing a Local Improvement District, providing
for the method of payment thereof, and creating a special fund.
This being the time fixed for the hearing on the Resolution of Intention
No. D-3834, to create a Local Improvement District for construction of
streets, curbs and gutters in the vicinity of Prestige Manor, Councilman
Wonder, referring to the protest received from Dr. Heffernan, 5005
Summitview Avenue, inquired why this property was included in the L.I.D.
Herb Mayer, City Engineer, stated that it was included at the request of
the applicant, as indicated in their December 13, 1977 request for
formation of a L.I.D. Mr. Mayer stated that the assessment will be
formularized on a share and share alike basis, rather than square footage
and if Council wishes to exclude this property, then his share would be
pro-rated to the other parcels. Paul Goode, Attorney, representing
Walter Uthmann, stated that the Uthmann's object to their property being
assessed for this L.I.D. as two parcels. He stated that the property is
divided for senior citizens property tax exemption only, and his client
would like their property to be treated the same as the Heffernan's
property. Councilman Walker inquired where the house is situated on the
property and Mr. Mayer pointed it out on the map. Mr. Newby stated that
there are two houses on that property, one behind the other one on the
north side of the lot. Dick Wiehl, reported that not only does his
client not benefit from this L.I.D., but the street will detract from
the value of the property, as the street will confuse his customers as
far as ingress to his business is concerned. Mt. Wiehl stated that Jim
Haney, appraiser, has appraised the property and stated he is of the
opinion that this property will not benefit from this street. He stated
that Dr. Heffernan does not object to the road being built, but does
object to being assessed. Mr. Newby reported that when Prestige Realty
approached Dr. Heffernan about purchasing part of his property for this
road, Dr. Heffernan presented his offer, One requirement being use of the
new road. He stated that this must mean that the doctor must see same
benefit to his property. Mr. Newby also reported that he was told personally
by Dr. Heffernan that he would like to have access to the rear of his
property once the new road was constructed. It was MOVED by Hinman,
seconded by Beauchamp that Ordinance No. 2156, creating a Local Improvement
District for the construction of streets, curbs and gutters, in the
vicinity of Prestige Manor excluding Dr. Heffernan's property, be passed.
It was MOVED by Wonder, seconded by Sparling to amend the motion regarding
Ordinance No. 2156, to delete the Uthmann's property from same L.I.D.:
carried, Beauchamp, Holbrook, Sparling and Wonder voting aye by voice
vote. Hinman and Walker voting nay. Edmondson absent. The question
was called on the motion, as amended. tion carried: carried, Beauchamp,
Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling and Wonder voting aye by voice. Walker
voting nay. Edmondson absent. Assistant Mayor Holbrook stated that
the boundaries of this L.I.D., is now the same as the sewer L.I.D., created
by Ordinance No. 2155.
ORDINANCE NO. 2156, AN ORDINANCE providing for the improvement of certain
streets, by grading, ballasting, surfacing with asphaltic concrete and
constructing concrete curbs and gutters, together with the necessary
drainage features, and lighting; establishing a Local Improvement District,
providing for the method of payment thereof, and creating a special
fund.
Jenny Thorton, representing the Yakima Campfire Office, presented Council
with their proposal for celebration of their 67th year as a Council.
701
FEBRUARY 14, 1978
She stated they would like to contribute to the downtown area by planting
flowers in the bark areas. On March 18, 1978, they would meet downtown
and have a birthday cake and then divide the girls into various groups,
with proper supervision, to plant the flowers. She stated that the
City's present watering system (trickle tubing) would provide enough
water for the plants and the girls would make it a year-round project to
care for the flowers. City Manager Eastman reported that Parks staff
has reviewed this proposal and recommends approval. This proposal is
now being presented to the Parks Commission. Councilman Wonder stated
he thought this was a wonderful idea and inquired if there was money in the
Parks Department to help pay for the bulbs. City Manager Eastman stated
that the girls would be professionally supervised. After a short discussion,
it was MOVED by Wonder, seconded by Walker to thank the Campfire girls
for their effort to beautify the City and assist them by asking the City
Manager to provide $100 seed or bulb money: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman,
Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and Wonder voting aye by voice vote. Edmondson
absent.
City Manager Eastman reported that Carol Darby and Ken Crawford spoke
with HUD regarding the possibility of using previous years C.D. block
grant funds to finance the balance needed for the Southeast Community
Center addition. HUD, will allow us to proceed to use funds from previous
C.D. years prior to the audit. Ken Crawford reported that the low
bidder stated that his bid will hold until Wednesday without any increase.
He also explained that the majority of the funds would come from the
contingency funds of the last three years C.D. money. Councilman Wonder
expressed concern about the expense of this project, stating that $53.00
per sq. ft. is steep. Ken Crawford explained that the nature of the
remodeling is a major factor. It was MOVED by Walker, seconded by
Hinman to authorize staff to prepare legislation to use previous Community
Development Funds and to award thisztproject. Assistant Mayor Holbrook
inquired if there is any recourse to the architect where we have a 67%
error in the estimate. City Manager Eastman stated one option would be
to redesign the building to cane within his estimate, but in this case,
it is not possible. After a short'discussiofi the condition of the
Southeast Community Center, the question was called on the Mbtion made
earlier. The motion . Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling,-and,Waiker
voting aye by voice vote. Wonder voting nay. Beauchamp not voting due
to conflict of interest. Edmondson absent. It was then MOVED by
Walker, seconded by Hinman to authorize the City Manager to award the
contract to V. K. Powell Company, Inc., for $89,000 plus tax, to cover
the patio and build an additional bath in the clinic at the Southeast
Community Center: carried, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling and Walker voting
aye by voice vote. Wonder voting nay. Beauchamp not voting due to
conflict of interest. Edmondson absent.
City Manager Eastman stated there are three alternative methods for
funding the proposed street light program. (1) 2% increase in utility
tax; (2) FRS funds; (3) existing revenues, which would require an adjustment
of other services. M. Eastman recommended the 2% utility increase as
being the most equitable way to pay the cost. The Council members then
discussed the placing of the street lights and the type of lights to be
used, referring to a street lighting, program map. City Manager Eastman
reported that there has not been a substantial number of requests for
any increased lighting in the City, however, from a police standpoint,
II/
the more lighting, the less burglary. Councilman Walker stated she felt
we should use FRS monies for this and Councilman Hinman stated he was
not convinced we Should even do it. City Manager Eastman stated he
would like some direction and offered three options: (1) we should
proceed with the program of changing lights over a period of time and
consider using FRS funds; (2) leave the program like it is without
Changing anything except where there is a new street or intersection;
and (3) leave it like it is now. Councilman Walker suggested that this
subject be one of the items discussed at the upcaming retreat. It was
the general consensus of the Council to discuss the street lighting
program and financing at the upcoming retreat. Councilman Wonder
stated he would like to see the proposed utility tax increase removed.
*It was MOVED by Walker, seconded by Beauchamp that Resolution No. D-
3854, authorizing payment to Leland E. Rheaume, in the amount of $96.06,
in settlement of a damage claim en the City Water Department personnel
turned off the wrong water meter adjacent to claimant's laundranat, be
- - ,
702
FEBRUARY 14, 1978
passed: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and
Wander voting aye on roll call. Edmondson absent.
RESOLUTION NO. D-3854, A RESOLUTION authorizing payment of $96.06 to
Leland E. Rheaume in settlement of a claim for damages filed with the
City of Yakima.
*It was MOVED by Walker, seconded by Beauchamp that the out-of-state
travel for Council members Gordon Wonder and Don Hinman to attend the
National League of Cities Annual Congressional-City Conference in
WashingtanD.C., March 3 - 8, 1978, at a cost to the City of $870 eadh,
be approved: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and
Wonder voting aye on roll call. Edmondson absent.
Mrs. Anderson, 2602 Willow, requested funds for the Southeast Community
Center Drop-In-Clinic, Which teaches sewing, knitting, etc. Asked by
Assistant Mayor Holbrook if she had talked with Mr. Rance about this
project, Mts. Anderson stated she had not. Lilly Schepel, Southeast
Community Center, also spoke in favor of this request for funds. Councilman
Walker stated that last fall the Board allocated funds for this program
and since then, they have not received a request for additional funds.
Councilman Beauchamp stated that this was a part of the FRS request
presented by the Southeast Community Center which was approved last week
with stipulations. Assistant Mayor Holbrook stated that this project
has not been turned down, but we are investigating the legality and hope
to have that information by the end of the month. -
Council members discussed the proposed parade ordinance, Councilman
Beauchamp questioning the hours permitted for parades, suggesting that
they be expanded. Councilman Walker stated that those hours were adopted
previously in order to ensure that the parade would be finished before
. the busy traffic period. 'Council members , discussed the fact that no
charge is made td cover theeXPense incurred by the City in hiring extra
police officers or for the cleanup crew. John Vanek, Assistant City
Attorney, reported that this charge was not included in the ordinance as per
Council's request the last time this was discussed. Assistant Mayor
Holbrook stated, that the people having the parades are actually non-
profit organizations and the cost of paying those expenses would prohibit
the parade from occurring. Councilman Wonder stated he believed that
any persons or organizations receiving special benefits from the City
should be charged for that benefit; however, the last time this was
discussed, the majority of the Council did not want to charge a fee.
Councilman Hinman stated that it is important that people should be able
to do this free of charge. It was then MOVED by Beauchamp, seconded by
Walker that Ordinance No. 2157, relating to parade and motorcade permits,
be passed: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling, Walker and
Wonder voting aye on roll call. Edmondson absent.
ORDINANCE NO. 2157, AN ORDINANCE relating to traffic control, defining
terms; prohibiting parades and motorcades without a permit; providing
for application, issuance, denial, modification and relocation of such
permits; providing for the appeal and additional review of permit modifications
or denial and amending Section 9.50.810 of the City of Yakima Municipal
Code.
*It was MOVED by Walker, seconded by Beauchamp that Resolution No. D-
3855, authorizing grants. of City federal revenue sharing funds to various
recipients, be passed: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman, Holbrook, Sparling,
Walker and Wonder voting aye on roll call. Edmondson absent.
RESOLUTION NO. D-3855, A RESOLUTION authorizing grants of City federal
revenue sharing money to various recipients.
Art Zerbach, Director of Finance & Budget, requested Council to consider
an amendment to the proposed ordinance appropriating FRS funds. He
stated that at the time the 1978 budget was prepared, $8,000 (which was
not a firm figure) was authorized for the purchase of Opticam emitters.
Now he would like Council to authorize an additional $3300 and stated
that $11,300 was deducted fram FRS funds. Mr. Zerbach also reported
that the funds for the fire breathing equipment needs to be reappropriated
703
FEBRUARY 14, 1978
in the amount of $29,544, as it was allocated in the 1977 budget and has
since lapsed. Council members briefly discussed the $6500 appropriation
to the Parks and Recreation Department, City Manager Eastman stating
that it should say for the benefit of Parker Field maintenance. It was
then MOVED by Walker, seconded by Hinman that Council amend the proposed
ordinance, per the Finance Director's suggestions, which are: allocate
total of $11,300 for Opticam emitters, and $29,544 for fire breathing
equipment and change the wording from softball association to "for the
benefit of Parker Field maintenance": carried, Beauchamp, Hinman,
Holbrook, Sparling, W4ker.and Wonder voting aye by voice vote. Edmondson
absent. The Ordinance appropriating Federal Revenue Sharing funds,
having been discussedand.read by title only at this meeting, was laid
on the table for one week or until Tuesday, February 21, 1978.
Councilman Hinman reported that he is unable to attend the Health District
meeting on Wednesday, as he will be out of town. Council members Walker
and Beauchamp reported they also will be unable to attend that meeting.
Councilman Hinman stated that at the time Council was discussing appointments
to boards and commissions, it was discussed that possibly the new Council
member would serve as an alternate. Councilman Sparling stated that he
would be willing to serve as an alternate Council representative on the
Health District Board
There being no further business to came before the Council, it was MOVED
by Walker, seconded bY Wonder to adjourn this meeting at the hour of
6:11 PM: carried, Beauchamp, Hinman, Holhrook, Sparling, Walker and
Wonder voting aye by voice vote. Edmondson absent.
READ AND CERTIFIED ACCURATE BY .
COUNC
11
ba, , A , A aett_t_4' - 17\ 7
co it '
ATTEST:
A! ,
,
•■bla 4'10
CITY i+0.;jr OR